*

Quadhouse

  • F Cup
  • 725
    • quadhouse.deviantart.com
finally
« on: September 01, 2002, 01:51:20 AM »
Part 5 of Keeper has been finished.  I have sent copies to both Mark T and Sebbo.  It is also at The (prohibited O) and (prohibited L).  Feedback is requested.  
“HEY, HOLD UP!” Chaka said.  She turned to Jade, “Did you just say that there are monsters in the sewers?”

Jade looked up at her sempai and smiled, “I’m sorry, but as a Junior Waste Management Technician, I am not authorized to discuss this issue.”

For a long time, the whole group stared at the little girl in horror as she licked the spoon.

*

Derob

  • D Cup
  • 123
Re: finally
« Reply #1 on: September 01, 2002, 02:25:25 PM »
Good to see you back. I enjoyed the story, though shrinking's not usually my cup of tea. Nice catch that D-cup means inches of projection beyond the chest, so keeping the same cup size on a smaller frame means proportionately a much more impressive rack.

I have two major criticisms: your grammar and your handling of viewpoint. There are many points where your grammar and sentence construction aren't right. Any one of them wouldn't be too bad; taken together, they really jostle me out of the story. All a story has is words, so I like to see them strung together properly.

As for viewpoint, viewpoint-switching doesn't bother me that much, though you need to put a dividing line or chapter break or something to indicate a shift in viewpoint. The days of the omniscient narrator who shifts viewpoint every two or three paragraphs are some seventy-five years behind us. There are still omniscient narrator stories, but not that many (these days limited omniscient narrators are most common), so it's not surprising that I and others feel dislocated by it.

But that's not what was really jarring about the story to me. What lost me in the story was your shift from third person to first. You were going along and talking about Lisa, employing a third-person view, and all of a sudden you're talking about "That evening I was surprised..." I'd pick a viewpoint (third or first) and stick with it, regardless of the head-hopping you do, and I'd put a break between sections where the narrator's viewpoint changes.

--D
   

*

Darkstorm

  • E Cup
  • 423
    • -
Re: finally
« Reply #2 on: September 07, 2002, 10:22:56 PM »
well I loved it! short, voluptuous women are really my thing - it's nice to see a story featuring a woman being short for once (giantess or muscle stuff ain't my bag).
only minor point - maybe you could describe the actual transformation; i think it's the process as well as the end results that make be stories great to read.
other than that, keep up the good work! i've got the story in fovourites among such stories as Jessica's Curse(Thanx Eliot!), The Sculptor(You go TR!) and Valentines Day(kudos Boobarian!)
well done all who contribute these fine works