*

Dan Standing

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 41
    • ESCarchive
Any feedback regarding T&A welcomed...
« on: March 18, 2010, 06:33:26 AM »
Hi all. I'm usually just lurking around the forums, but figured I'd finally ask if anyone had any feedback on my works in the BESC. Part 1 of T&A: Three's a Crowd just went up. And if anyone had anything to say (compliment or critique) of the first T&A, Spritely, or The Chest I'd be happy to hear it.

Thanks!

*

trainman

Re: Any feedback regarding T&A welcomed...
« Reply #1 on: March 19, 2010, 12:25:07 AM »
I'm not a BESC subscriber at the moment, so I haven't seen the latest.  But I've definitely enjoyed your other stuff -- I'm sure it helps that I'm a fan of the "wishes-gone-wrong" genre.  In that spirit, "Spritely" is probably my favorite -- short, sweet, and with some unique physical transformations.

*

Dan Standing

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 41
    • ESCarchive
Re: Any feedback regarding T&A welcomed...
« Reply #2 on: March 19, 2010, 06:00:23 AM »
Thanks for the feedback!

I love the "wishes-gone-wrong" genre as well (clearly, haha), but since it is such an oft-used style I always try and make sure I work something in that I really haven't seen before.

As a fellow fan of the genre, if you get a BESC membership again you'll probably like UNDER, which is a story of mine the BESC has had for a bit. Not sure when it'll get posted, but it's chock full of twisted wishes and unique changes (although far from short).

*

chucarli

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 4
Re: Any feedback regarding T&A welcomed...
« Reply #3 on: March 19, 2010, 08:06:38 AM »
Fantastic stuff, really the only material that's been worth a membership over the last few months.  Thanks.

*

Dan Standing

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 41
    • ESCarchive
Re: Any feedback regarding T&A welcomed...
« Reply #4 on: March 19, 2010, 08:29:23 AM »
Wow, thank you! I haven't had a membership since the end of 2009 so I don't know how I compare, but I really appreciate the support! I actually haven't yet gotten my PDF copy of the latest comic so I hope it's been on par with my others, post-illustrations...

*

Melian

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 8
    • Email
Re: Any feedback regarding T&A welcomed...
« Reply #5 on: March 19, 2010, 12:22:29 PM »
Well, end pages were the best of that comic, it made me wait for the next part :)

Still, I am hoping for the 7th part of Growing and Changing in Las Vegas, that should be some killer stuff with excellent plot twists.  Well, it's 12 days to the deadline, we'll see what happens :3

And I truly hope, that non-comics won't come even a little out. (okay, it's okay to have once or twice a year some text stories,(maybe?)) I've had enough of text stories, because you can read them on Fictionmania - for free. There are hundreds of stories, which quality is usually pretty good. Of course there are some miserable blended in, but you can distill them quickly. And this is a pay site, and I'm giving my money for illustrated stuff. And I wouldn't have said a thing about the products of this club, if this membership had been free... I'm just hoping, that the club will focus their resources for the comics, because only a few can draw good enough to make stories enjoyable as illustrated versions. I personally would draw something by myself, but making excellent drawings takes too much time of my life, and that's why I'm the member of the BESC.

Keep it up, I still have my hopes up on the seventh part of Growing and Changing blaa blaa blaa :) And I hope, that my whining didn't sound like a whining :D

*

trainman

Re: Any feedback regarding T&A welcomed...
« Reply #6 on: March 20, 2010, 12:43:47 AM »
I've had enough of text stories, because you can read them on Fictionmania - for free.

The (prohibited O) would probably be the better comparison, since that's a BE site.  (And personally, I'm not as much of a fan of Fictionmania as I used to be -- I'm interested in stories involving magical or scientific "indistinguishable from magic" transformations, but since FM came back from their extended downtime, the percentage of cross-dressing/"sissification" stories seems to have drastically increased.)

I'm fine with text stories on the BESC -- especially since they are illustrated, and it presumably means they can get more content published (comics are definitely a more labor-intensive process).  Some of the ones that are already there are among my favorite works of BE fiction, including the aforementioned "The Chest," and "Big New World."

*

Darkstorm

  • E Cup
  • 423
    • -
Re: Any feedback regarding T&A welcomed...
« Reply #7 on: March 20, 2010, 01:43:48 AM »
And I truly hope, that non-comics won't come even a little out. (okay, it's okay to have once or twice a year some text stories,(maybe?)) I've had enough of text stories, because you can read them on Fictionmania - for free. There are hundreds of stories, which quality is usually pretty good. Of course there are some miserable blended in, but you can distill them quickly. And this is a pay site, and I'm giving my money for illustrated stuff. And I wouldn't have said a thing about the products of this club, if this membership had been free... I'm just hoping, that the club will focus their resources for the comics, because only a few can draw good enough to make stories enjoyable as illustrated versions. I personally would draw something by myself, but making excellent drawings takes too much time of my life, and that's why I'm the member of the BESC.

Keep it up, I still have my hopes up on the seventh part of Growing and Changing blaa blaa blaa :) And I hope, that my whining didn't sound like a whining :D

Seriously, while I support your right to an opinion, I strongly disagree with it. What you have said about text stories can also be applied to comics. There are more than enough available as webcomics, whether your tastes run to Milkmaid, Lightfoot's works, Bust Artists, or paid material at expansion comics (and many others). Just remember what the club is called and what it's content has always been - stories. If you don't like them, you have joined the wrong site. It would make as much sense joining an S&M site and complaining about so much leather!

To each their own; I for one think comics have become over-represented at the club. They are labour intensive to produce, meaning that the artist has less time to work on more stories; the comics are often broken up into episodes because of this, meaning that we not only get less story per month, but the club can milk just one out over three months or more.


And I truly hope, that non-comics won't come even a little out. (okay, it's okay to have once or twice a year some text stories,(maybe?))

This is already the case - there has only been 1 text story published since October last year. This is why I get vocal about this particular issue. In fact, up until very recently, most of last year's entries have been comics (24 out of 29 publications were comics in 2009. 4 out of 5 publications so far in 2010 are comics. In fact 6 of the last 9 publications are all chapters from the same comic  - DOES THAT SOUND EQUAL AND FAIR TO YOU?)
So ask yourself this: have you REALLY looked through that content? The reason there was more text stories earlier on, is that there were MORE stories published, instead of artist-heavy webisodes featuring 5 pages of bugger-all story.

Look, sorry for the rant.... I just get really uptight when I see so much material available for comic fans, and all that seems to be heard is "gee, can we have more comics please?"
« Last Edit: March 20, 2010, 05:10:53 AM by Darkstorm »

*

Darkstorm

  • E Cup
  • 423
    • -
Re: Any feedback regarding T&A welcomed...
« Reply #8 on: March 20, 2010, 01:51:59 AM »
Wow, thank you! I haven't had a membership since the end of 2009 so I don't know how I compare, but I really appreciate the support! I actually haven't yet gotten my PDF copy of the latest comic so I hope it's been on par with my others, post-illustrations...

I'd like to apologise for hijacking your thread Dan - your stories (what I have read of them so far) have been great  :) Some excellent ideas (though admittedly I'm not big on the multi boob thing)- It'd be interesting to see a text story from you....

*

Dan Standing

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 41
    • ESCarchive
Re: Any feedback regarding T&A welcomed...
« Reply #9 on: March 20, 2010, 08:59:42 AM »
Haha, wow, a lot goes on when I drive for 8 hours...

To sort of summarize what I've read here since my last post:

I understand the comics vs. stories debate. However, personally I like reading both comics and text stories for different reasons. I enjoy the comics because, hey, EVERYTHING is illustrated, so if the story is particulalry visually intense then it's great to get everything drawn. But I also enjoy text stories because you really get to be inside the person's head; what does the transformation feel like? What are their feelings on it? What do they have to do to adjust to the change? Sexy little details you don't normally get in a comic. And when a text story has an illustration at JUST the right spot, it works for me.

So, basically, when I come up with a plot idea, I just try and decide whether I feel like it's more about a quick plot/McGuffin that works better visually (like Spritely or T&A) or if it's more about how the person reacts and feels about what's been done to them (like The Chest or the upcoming Under).

Honestly, when I still had a membership the only thing that bothered me about comics vs. stories was whether I felt like I was reading a comic that should have been a story, or a story that really should have been a comic. But when done right I'll gladly pay for either.

To those who voiced their opinions/enjoyment of my work, thanks so much! I'm not really concerned with the "hijacking" of the thread, ha, but if there are more opinions to be had of my work I'll gladly continue to listen. I want to make sure anything else I write is properly targetted.

*

Melian

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 8
    • Email
Re: Any feedback regarding T&A welcomed...
« Reply #10 on: March 21, 2010, 03:01:14 PM »
Seriously, while I support your right to an opinion, I strongly disagree with it. What you have said about text stories can also be applied to comics. There are more than enough available as webcomics, whether your tastes run to Milkmaid, Lightfoot's works, Bust Artists, or paid material at expansion comics (and many others). Just remember what the club is called and what it's content has always been - stories. If you don't like them, you have joined the wrong site. It would make as much sense joining an S&M site and complaining about so much leather!

To each their own; I for one think comics have become over-represented at the club. They are labour intensive to produce, meaning that the artist has less time to work on more stories; the comics are often broken up into episodes because of this, meaning that we not only get less story per month, but the club can milk just one out over three months or more.


This is already the case - there has only been 1 text story published since October last year. This is why I get vocal about this particular issue. In fact, up until very recently, most of last year's entries have been comics (24 out of 29 publications were comics in 2009. 4 out of 5 publications so far in 2010 are comics. In fact 6 of the last 9 publications are all chapters from the same comic  - DOES THAT SOUND EQUAL AND FAIR TO YOU?)
So ask yourself this: have you REALLY looked through that content? The reason there was more text stories earlier on, is that there were MORE stories published, instead of artist-heavy webisodes featuring 5 pages of bugger-all story.

Look, sorry for the rant.... I just get really uptight when I see so much material available for comic fans, and all that seems to be heard is "gee, can we have more comics please?"

And I'm sorry for my comment, I didn't mean to upset anyone. I've never really followed the statistics of published material, but to my conception the main theme at this site (BE, of course) were comics. Okay, I checked now the main page, it says "comics and stories". Maybe I just presumed the comics would be the main theme, because they need much more skill to be created? Or would be worth paying? Well, at least in my opinion, because I don't see any reason for myself to be not able to write an adequate story by myself. But when it comes to drawing, I'll gladly get someone else to do the job :D

And that's great, if the major part of published material is comics. And when I said about about publishing material should be more comics than text stories, I meant it generally. Like hoping that as the future overall lines. There wasn't any complain meant to be in that opinion or any connection to the published material.

"In fact 6 of the last 9 publications are all chapters from the same comic [/color]  - DOES THAT SOUND EQUAL AND FAIR TO YOU?"

That is fantastic and I hope they keep up with this way. But it's not fair for the text story fans :/

And apologies: I was on the lazy mood, so I didn't chop the quote to smaller pieces. In addition, English isn't my mother tongue, otherwise you would get a little more depth to my comments/opinions and a clearer grammar, too :P

EDIT: I guess, that my joke "And I hope, that my whining didn't sound like a whining" made you think, that I complained. I'm just sometimes self-sarcastical and for example, ram my own opinions.  :)
« Last Edit: March 21, 2010, 03:06:27 PM by Melian »

Re: Any feedback regarding T&A welcomed...
« Reply #11 on: March 21, 2010, 04:39:31 PM »

Maybe I just presumed the comics would be the main theme, because they need much more skill to be created?

Or would be worth paying?

Well, at least in my opinion, because I don't see any reason for myself to be not able to write an adequate story by myself.

Skill??? Depends... as an artist, yes. Comics take time and effort to render, color, and finalize. As a writer, not so much once you get your system in place. If you can describe a scene in 75-100 words then the whole process becomes nearly automatic. The writer comes up with a fantasy and then goes. If the BESC is producing more comics its becuase the BESC finds comics easier to produce than stories. I'd bet there's a considerable back log of comic scrips but very little in ready to illustrate stories.

Depends what you consider worth Paying. BA's comics are the most value for your dollar. (now with Slimy Thief's new triple bundle, the previous statement might not be accurate.)

You should write a script. But consider the fact that the BESC thinks crafting a comic strip for them is a privilege not an buisness endeavor. (I make this comment backed by previous forum statements, if this has changed feel free to correct me and I'll retract this statement.)
Breasts grow - that's BE... what happens after that is irrelevant.
--Prophet Tenebrae---

Re: Any feedback regarding T&A welcomed...
« Reply #12 on: March 23, 2010, 07:55:20 PM »
Dan,

I'm not a story club member at the mo but I do have the earlier installments of T&A which I really enjoyed. I like warped wishes stories and think the way you took it was brilliant.

Keep up the fine work!!

*

Dan Standing

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 41
    • ESCarchive
Re: Any feedback regarding T&A welcomed...
« Reply #13 on: March 23, 2010, 09:55:00 PM »
Thanks so much!

*

Melian

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 8
    • Email
Re: Any feedback regarding T&A welcomed...
« Reply #14 on: March 24, 2010, 11:10:41 AM »
You should write a script. But consider the fact that the BESC thinks crafting a comic strip for them is a privilege not an buisness endeavor. (I make this comment backed by previous forum statements, if this has changed feel free to correct me and I'll retract this statement.)

I've thought that, but right now my life is at that kind of state, where I'm not capable of doing anything else than necessary work. And I guess you're not interested in my private life, so no further need of explanation :P And I don't hold any further knowledge about former forum statements, so I guess you're right.