[nycetee]

...Jenny Hill-with an early Lisa Phillips coming in 2nd....

[Palomine]

I don't think that either Kerry or Nadine actually cross the line into 'plumpers' even at their biggest (only iMHO of course). Both are among my very favorites.

In terms of bonafide plumpers, I too am partial to Candy Kane. Gaynor is also great, and the fact that she did hardcore doesn't  hurt. Also as mentioned Dean Ackerlund was spectacular. Finally, tho' she too IMHO really isn't quite large enough to qualify for 'plumper' Cathy Patrick has always impressed. Her 'satin' set is a classic.. such a lovely face and such amazingly abundant flesy glory... truly deserving of the accolade 'classic.'

[ March 29, 2002: Message edited by: Palomine ]

[pilotblaze]

I think picking the "Best of All Time" would be next to impossible.  There have been so many great BBW/plumper models over the years.  I love every one of the models you all have mentioned already.

What really drags me is when these models come on the scene, capture everybody's interest, and then for whatever reason start losing a lot of weight.  Lisa Phillips, Cathy Patrick, Autumn Jade (let's hear it for her recent return to much of her former glory), Sammie, the list goes on and on.  I don't begrudge anybody their right to do what they want with their own health and body, but I think there is a pattern here that speaks of influence. The media, fashion industry, allure of crossover modeling, what have you.  It's just too bad, because left alone, perhaps these ladies would have been happy the way they were, the way we initially came to appreciate them.  OK, rant over.  (Gee, have I said this already?  Hmmn...)

Here's some others that I really liked that you might recognize: A programmer/model from early Gent days named Mindy Rae.  The early Karen Wing (she lost a bunch of weight, too).  More recently, Star, and Laura Bailey.  Don't forget Colette - I sure am sorry she decided to stop modeling.  This list goes on and on too...  
-D'

[toomuch]

D'Artagnian brings up a new sub-subject that might be worth exploring: favorite plumpers who've done hardcore. In my view (admittedly most of these observations are made from still pictures only):

Chessie Moore, Melonie Anton, and Toni Kessering would take the top places on my list for raunch. I thought Melonie actually got sexier as she got heavier, while Chessie just got matronly.

Lisa Phillips had a great animal quality, but she lost too much weight for my taste before she began doing hardcore.

Gaynor, Samantha and Julia Miles all look like huge fun, but I haven't seen enough of them in action. I look forward to more.

Nejla/Nikki, Roberta Smallwood, and Rhonda Baxter all had a sweetness that I quite like, although the first two appear hungrier (and more grateful) than Rhonda, who is delicious but passive.

I have the impression that Candye Kane did hardcore, but I've never seen it and can't comment.

Anybody interested in pursuing this conversation, or speculating on those who remained discreet?

[Candye Man]

Yeah, Lisa Phillips looked very "deflated" when she lost the weight.
 
Candye did do some h/c:  a couple with Peter North, one with some dude whose name I don't know, and one or two with caveman/game show contestant Ron Jeremy.  Candye was great at on-camera orgasms.  
 
Used to have one of the Peter North movies in a Yahoo briefcase, but those yahoos shut it down.  Hoping to re-post it some time in one of my Groups.    

[jayjay88]

I shouldn't be in this thread because i like 'em 'lean 'n mean'......BUT i do think Julia Myles has the most perfect breast shape going...it makes me overlook the bits i don't care for.
......jayjay  

[**DONOTDELETE**]

Hmmm.. Via Paxton first, then hmmm.. Lisa Phillips, Candye Kane, Julia Miles, Kimiko Matsuzaka, Anna Nicole Smith, and Toni Francis... I guess?? I dunno.. It's a toss-up there, but Via takes first place for sure. :^)

~Curvy  

[sheber]

Trinity Loren...  

[Palomine]

Gotta agree with Curvy, Via Paxton and Kimiko Matsuzaka are both spectacular, tho' again IMHO neither is quite over-the-line into plumper territory. To me, these gals are simply voluptuous, having full thighs, slightly rounded bellies, flaring hips and of course stunning bustlines. To truly be classified as 'plumper' to me, a woman has all of this and then at least another 15 or 20 pounds BEYOND... that's *plump* to me.Thus, Kimiko Matsuzaka isn't quite there, but Mariko Morikawa is. Both are delicious looking regardless.

Of course, some of the models mentioned have gained and lost not-insignificant amounts of weight during their modelling careers, so the picture of Chessie in one fan's mind could be as much as 50 pounds different from another fan's idea of her.

Well-padded women can be beautiful.
 
PS: I attemtped to attach a particularly delightful picture of Mariko with this post, showing her in all her fleshy glory, but got a string of returned errors for my trouble. Ah well...

[steveo]

Roberta Smallwood!

[**DONOTDELETE**]

"To me, these gals are simply voluptuous, having full thighs, slightly rounded bellies, flaring hips and of course stunning bustlines."

Yep. :^)  Viva la voluptuous! That's why I love the old pinup gals. Talk about curvy!

~Curvy  

[TheZookie007]

Susie Sparks and Subgirlie and Jenny and Sammie and Julie Miles and Nadine Jensen and Gaynor and Roberta Smallwood all readily come to mind (in no particular order).

ahhhhh.....the bigger the better. I have absolutely nothing against plumpers. They tend to be the most natural-looking big bust babes around, and they all keep getting bigger and better (none of that "diet" nonsense to keep them back)! You grow, girls!  

[toomuch]

Just ran across this ancient and entertaining thread while doing a search. It's eight years old!!

I find, on reviewing these nominees, that the ladies who were my favorites back then remain so today. Nadine, described as a borderline plumper eight years ago, has certainly graduated to a full-fledged plumper today, but in my opinion she wears her fleshy goodness in ravishing fashion.

Sapphire and Maria Moore weren't mentioned in the earlier review, but certainly qualify today.

Suzie Sparks, Starr Moses, and a briefly-seen RedHotT from TopHeavy are all long gone, more's the pity. I miss them.

A couple of more recent nominees in the Just Barely Plumpers category would be Fuko and Rachel Aldana.

Surely, there are other chubby lovers out there who'd like to add their favorites.

[pedonbio]

Id say Mary Waters..She seemed to really enjoy struting her stuff. cheers PE

I'm inclined to agree:

[Feral]

What a blast from the past. Would need to define what a plumper is, though. From scanning over the other posts I would say she would have to fall between a near plumper like Nadine or Dors and have to be lighter then an extreme BBW like Norma Stitz or Karola.

And since TTIWWOP I'd have to go with Maria Moore: