I'm absolutely going to ignore your definition of smart vs dumb porn. If you want it here is mine.
The purpose of porn is to arouse, not stimulate the intellect. If it arouses it does it's job and I see it as smart porn. If it doesn't arouse then it misses the whole point, thus is dumb porn.
Some "porn" is both intelligent and arousing, just look at what Bunuel was doing. He didn't see it as porn, or erotica (well, maybe). But some of the stuff he was doing is definitely arousing, see Belle Du Jour, or La Vida Criminal De Archibaldo Cruz. To me that is good (or smart) porn. But I also find a lot of the XXX heavy breathers to be quite arousing, that's good porn too.
Some of the dumb Porn that I've seen is stuff like the musical porn version of Alice In Wonderland. Yes, there are naked people running around and such, but it remains completely unarousing, thus bad (or dumb) porn. Another example is the clinical zooms they did on some of the older porn: a screen-filling zoom of a clitoris is not arousing to me, there should be some other stuff there, and it's just plain missing.
Whoever did these did not understand porn.
On the other hand, the stuff I do not find arousing (or smart), somebody else might. But then it's up to them to defend it, if they want to. I cannot speak for them, only for myself.
Your definition of smart & dumb just doesn't work for me, since it ignores the very purpose of porn. Sex is for everybody, dumb or smart. And everybody can have a rewarding relationship with the opposite (or the same if that is their preference) sex, regardless of their or their partner's degree of intelligence. Why can't a smart and a dumb person not have a good relationship or simply good sex? Or even two dumb people? Sex and smartness or dumbness have nothing to do with each other.
The points you are trying to make(?) are that there are dumb ways of perceiving or using porn. Sorry, I don't buy that. People will do whatever pops their cookies. If it arouses them to depersonalize or objectify the women or men they are looking at, then that is what works for them as porn. Something else is not going to work.
If they prefer to have an actual person with a name and an identity arouse them, then that's it.
Again, look at Bunuel's (or Svankmajer's) work to see that people will be aroused by an infinite variety of very specific stimulus. Change one the variables, and it doesn't work.
I am reminded of a female teacher that found a male student drawing a naked female torso in class. She was upset, of course but decided to teach the guy a lesson. She calmly asked him to draw the figure's face and to give her a name and a personality. She obviously has no understanding of the student's sexuality. For him, doing that would screw up the whole fantasy.
I can see why she was offended, but she needn't be, just as she needn't project her own values or views of sexuality on somebody else.
On a talk show there were these feminists who were talking about how degrading or ridiculous porn was. They did an exercise where they had clothed men duplicate the poses of the models in a porn magazine. Of course it was ridiculous seeng men do this. But these feminist were simply missing the point. Some of those outrageous poses don't do it for me. Personally I prefer more classical poses, but once in a while I see a pose that seems very raunchy to me (even if it is out there), all of a sudden a particular pose might click with me. In the same manner those poses will work for somebody else. The main purpose of a porn magazine is not to make women look ridiculous or to degrade them (though these might be a component, just as something else might), but to arouse the person looking at the images.