<<Listen, Jizz, I actually admire your honesty and sincerity. What your sexual experiences will lack in quantity will be made up for in quality. You may not think so at the time, but immediately afterwards, it will become devastatingly apparent.>>
Well put. As I only know you from here in the Forum, I can't be sure, but here's another possible way to look at things. My best friend is a girl. I've mentioned her in a post or two, she's the one who points out giant breasts to me in public; I point out guys for her too, we help each other out.

We haven't dated and I'm not attracted to her, but that's beside the point. Anyway, one day back when I was deeply depressed, I was wondering why girls didn't notice me, saying many of the things you've said. She thought about it, and explained to me that while some guys are the kind who can just go up to a girl and get a "yes," there's another kind of guy who is often not noticed the first time around because his charm comes out of knowing him. He might only be "okay" at first, she said, but as you get to know him, he becomes more attractive, and in the long run they're often better than the ones the girls go nuts for on sight. I guess my charm is set on time-release, because she said I'm one of those, and my experience has found it to be largely true. You seem like a very nice guy, and I'm sure this is also the case with you. (There are girls like this, too, I know several.)
As a fellow romantic and highly idealistic 18-year-old, I find it very refreshing to not the only guy my age who feels the same about this topic. Biggest thing to remember is don't let yourself get jaded. Some people go through life only seeing things as they appear, and they die bitter. Some go through life trying their best to see the good; sometimes these people die unhappy too...but in the end, wouldn't it make it just a little bit better to have seen things in a nicer light while you were here? Keep believing.