[solvegas]

I may have misunderstood you when reading your post, but you must understand that we don't all speak English here and to be able to express something and to understand each other we have to translate from our native language to English and from English to our native language and in that process aspects are lost. or the semantics are not adequate and there is a misunderstanding.
An image would help in these cases.

Mi primer idioma era el Espanol pero yo e vivido aqui en los Estados Unidos 52 anos y normalmente uso el Ingles. Sorry, to translate, my first language was Spanish, but I've been living in the United States for the last 52 years, so I normally just use English. Spanish has accent punctuations and letters that English doesn't have and the keyboard I'm using doesn't have them. Anyways, due to geographical location and colloquialisms, English isn't exactly the same everywhere. Like it's been said, England and America are two countries separated by a common language. The point I'm making is that some of the responses I and Bombayduk are getting are coming across as negative and aggressive even if you don't want it to be so. Now, if Beshine would relax some of her de facto control of this thread and allow us to post more images, we could probably show and prove our points more easily. Imagine if we could post some, but not many, of her recent OnlyFans posts so we could compare and show the points we are trying to make. I've seen some OnlyFans photos of Beshine in some other sites, but I don't dare post them here since I've been banned before, and I don't wish to go through that again.  But what I've seen of the recent photos, verify that she is much larger volume wise now than she was in 2011 and her breasts are much rounder than then. Yes, she is bigger now than then and I wish she would just tell us because frankly, that would be hot. I remember at the beginning of this thread when she would post her size and volume and it was/is the reason why this thread is so huge. Anyway, let's just be civil and polite to each other and enjoy Beshine. 

[Bombayduk]

Aggressive is not a language problem and looking back, this has been the same things for years, absolutely negative; someone show me an actual contribution.  Quite convinced at this point that they just get their rocks off on being disruptive because you can point to pictures and videos and they won't even look because it is not what they want to see.  Face it, Sol, if someone can look at 2011 pictures, then look at 2022 pictures and say they are the same, their either have no sense of perspective, are lying, or are blind.  And imagine, here we are 12 years later, and someone is still whining about the 2011 fill-up video; obviously something went wrong so let it go.  The pictures are here, they just are too lazy to look and afraid they may see something that they don't want to see, things we have been talking about.  None belong to her OF yet they complain about camera angles, distance, and lens as if all the OF pictures or videos use some sort of trickery; Beshine has some expensive equipment and while you could say they are all selfies, very few is she actually holding a selfie stick.  Are her boobs closer to the camera in a frontal exposure?  Damn right, just like every girl in every thread at the BEA, but with Beshine, unless the camera is behind her, a boob is always going to be closer because they project from her body in three directions.  So basically, they are complaining about something they haven't even paid to see.  Some people whine and complain; life must be miserable for them.  Me, I look at thing realistically and optimistically, I take people at their word until they give me reason not to, and Beshine has not given me reason to suspect she is lying.  Just a FYI, you notice, just like I said, they ignored the math aspect again; how wide are boobs, touching yet the sideboobs extend past the arms of chairs?

[lolchair]

Let's be realistic here. For all we know Beshine has reduced and is recycling old content. Nobody has seen her since she stopped camming.
She has also completely stopped doing huge boob talk in her Beshine.com photo/vid discriptions. Something changed.

[Maik]

Let's be realistic here. For all we know Beshine has reduced and is recycling old content. Nobody has seen her since she stopped camming.
She has also completely stopped doing huge boob talk in her Beshine.com photo/vid discriptions. Something changed.

Well we all can hope that this isn't so but we have no proove till she will publish those information.
She will be 40 years old this year and has reached proportions no one has ever dreamed of in the past. Maybe her focus has changed over the last time and she has now other interests.
We don't know what her personal situation these days is or if there are some health issues. I have some estimations but nothing proove cause I don't know her in person and so I don't spread any false or negative or hurtful informations.
Maybe the optimistic situation could be that she has reached the limit or lifetime of her expanders and has switched to the next level with some evolutional design, lightweight and able to go bigger  . You know she was always one step ahead (huge expanders, internal bra,...).
I think there is nothing wrong by publishing older content.
My 2cent.

[Boosterboobs]

Aggressive is not a language problem and looking back, this has been the same things for years, absolutely negative; someone show me an actual contribution.  Quite convinced at this point that they just get their rocks off on being disruptive because you can point to pictures and videos and they won't even look because it is not what they want to see.  Face it, Sol, if someone can look at 2011 pictures, then look at 2022 pictures and say they are the same, their either have no sense of perspective, are lying, or are blind.  And imagine, here we are 12 years later, and someone is still whining about the 2011 fill-up video; obviously something went wrong so let it go.  The pictures are here, they just are too lazy to look and afraid they may see something that they don't want to see, things we have been talking about.  None belong to her OF yet they complain about camera angles, distance, and lens as if all the OF pictures or videos use some sort of trickery; Beshine has some expensive equipment and while you could say they are all selfies, very few is she actually holding a selfie stick.  Are her boobs closer to the camera in a frontal exposure?  Damn right, just like every girl in every thread at the BEA, but with Beshine, unless the camera is behind her, a boob is always going to be closer because they project from her body in three directions.  So basically, they are complaining about something they haven't even paid to see.  Some people whine and complain; life must be miserable for them.  Me, I look at thing realistically and optimistically, I take people at their word until they give me reason not to, and Beshine has not given me reason to suspect she is lying.  Just a FYI, you notice, just like I said, they ignored the math aspect again; how wide are boobs, touching yet the sideboobs extend past the arms of chairs?

I only read a lot of theories, numbers, calculations, percentages and measurements but I have not yet seen any photographic proof of how you take that data and no proof where she is bigger since 2011.
You demand others to prove it to you and you prove it but if you continue hiding behind your theories and "measurements"
Whenever you want!

[solvegas]

Beshine has posted a new photoshoot on her site, "Behind the Dunes", near a town called Sylt near the North Sea which is an area with lots of sand dunes. I thought this photo showed her own dunes. 

[Bombayduk]

Let's be realistic here. For all we know Beshine has reduced and is recycling old content. Nobody has seen her since she stopped camming.
She has also completely stopped doing huge boob talk in her Beshine.com photo/vid discriptions. Something changed.

Well we all can hope that this isn't so but we have no proove till she will publish those information.
She will be 40 years old this year and has reached proportions no one has ever dreamed of in the past. Maybe her focus has changed over the last time and she has now other interests.
We don't know what her personal situation these days is or if there are some health issues. I have some estimations but nothing proove cause I don't know her in person and so I don't spread any false or negative or hurtful informations.
Maybe the optimistic situation could be that she has reached the limit or lifetime of her expanders and has switched to the next level with some evolutional design, lightweight and able to go bigger  . You know she was always one step ahead (huge expanders, internal bra,...).
I think there is nothing wrong by publishing older content.
My 2cent.

Well stated; why would anyone be so pessimistic as to think, let alone post, that Beshine got a reduction when there is no evidence to support such a notion?  Her OF material remains relatively fresh in my opinion; over the years, you can delineate one year from the next through hair length, some change she has made, or location.  There is nothing in her words or appearance that would suggest she has any desire to change unless that change is actually to make her boobs bigger.  And right in this thread, always ahead of the game, she stated that the expanders she was having custom made would be permanent, that at a given time, she would have the saline drained and a permanent filler infused.  It seems she has foreseen and done everything she could to be sure she will carry her boobs to the grave and the words she speaks on OF continue to lend to the idea.

[lolchair]

why would anyone be so pessimistic as to think, let alone post, that Beshine got a reduction when there is no evidence to support such a notion?

"why would anyone be so optimistic as to think, let alone post, that Beshine got a fill up when there is no evidence to support such a notion?"
Oh wait, when Bombayduk says so this does not apply.

Maik is right that there is too much speculation based on absolutely nothing. People are upset because their all realise you are constantly writing like you know how Beshine thinks, what she does and how it all works. And the worst part is that you make it sound like any criticism towards you is the same as people attacking Beshine. Please stop presenting yourself like you are representing her. People are not attacking her. They are questioning your made up claims.

[Bombayduk]

Beshine has posted a new photoshoot on her site, "Behind the Dunes", near a town called Sylt near the North Sea which is an area with lots of sand dunes. I thought this photo showed her own dunes. 

I noticed the new posting this morning and her continued commitment in returning to regularly scheduled updates like the days of old as well as the change in the descriptions since the site returned to active.  It used to be that every description had adjective heavy references to the size of her boobs, while the ones since reactivation don't even mention them, just the nature aspect.  It is as if she has changed webmasters, this one wanting to talk about the beauty of the surroundings while the old one centered on the breasts being here or there and what that meant.  I'm not saying one is better than the other because they both have their good points.

Anyway, it is Sunday and I decided to post a old picture this week to remind everyone how much space once existed between Beshine's growing boobs.  There are topless pictures on this thread from the same time period that demonstrate the same.  But as everyone can see, without a top to squeeze her boobs together, they are pressed against each other today; that is a lot of added saline.  I would venture to say that her breasts naturally touching probably led to the change from a rather traditional heavily restrictive bra style in 2019 to what we see her call a bra today, which is a very elastic and stretched tank top with thin straps to discourage the garment from slipping downward with the inevitable bob of her boobs with every step.  I think you saw the video of how she steps into it as if it was a slip and then pulls it up, stretching a lot to get one boob in at a time.  Nothing like the old days.

One thing for sure, those that are essentially calling Beshine a liar by saying her boobs have not changed in size over the past 12 years despite her postings or by ignoring her encountering a new array of big boob problems along the way as she spoke of many times, or inferring she got tired of her boobs and had a reduction, or by saying her material is all old, have no basis for their claims, present no evidence of support, and only exist on this thread by the grace of the mods and/or Beshine in their efforts to demean her and those that support her.  They come here, make false claims, and demand that we prove them wrong; what childish behavior in the face of no evidence proving them right.

[Paddy]

why would anyone be so pessimistic as to think, let alone post, that Beshine got a reduction when there is no evidence to support such a notion?

"why would anyone be so optimistic as to think, let alone post, that Beshine got a fill up when there is no evidence to support such a notion?"
Oh wait, when Bombayduk says so this does not apply.

Maik is right that there is too much speculation based on absolutely nothing. People are upset because their all realise you are constantly writing like you know how Beshine thinks, what she does and how it all works. And the worst part is that you make it sound like any criticism towards you is the same as people attacking Beshine. Please stop presenting yourself like you are representing her. People are not attacking her. They are questioning your made up claims.

Could not have said it any better…..

[solvegas]

Look at Bomayduk's latest photo, reply #21233, and you will see that she is wearing high heels and her butt is pretty flat. She hasn't put heels on for years because the weight of her breasts is so much more that heels are dangerous and destabilizing. Bombayduk talks about how she has to adjust to her changing conditions due to weight changes and some people criticize him for this.

[Bombayduk]

Look at Bomayduk's latest photo, reply #21233, and you will see that she is wearing high heels and her butt is pretty flat. She hasn't put heels on for years because the weight of her breasts is so much more that heels are dangerous and destabilizing. Bombayduk talks about how she has to adjust to her changing conditions due to weight changes and some people criticize him for this.

Thanks, Sol, and if you remember the video, Beshine was strutting her stuff in those heels on a rather lightly paved drive, seemingly unchallenged.  There is so much one can glean from a single photo and even more from a video if your left brain is dominant and you examine everything from a logical perspective.  Logic allows you to hypothesize based on objective evidence, but it does not support assumption based theorizing.  Actually, it was Beshine herself that talked about all the ways her expanding boobs were changing her life and I found that fascinating, because she was not complaining but saying how much she loved constantly experiencing these changes.  We had seen many big boob girls come and go, downsizing because they didn't like the burden or inconveniences, but we never heard any of them marvel at all the ways her huge and heavy boobs made her life.  You have to seriously love something that makes your life harder, not easier.  I don't understand why people fail to understand what should be simple concepts.  I talk about these things because Beshine talks about these things and she makes it very obvious that she loves them, in fact, she says it in videos.  It's not me making up shit, it is me expressing and expounding upon what Beshine has already said in most cases.  It is not my fault that people intentionally choose to be blind to what she says, but the fact remains, she talks about her 'huge boobie adventures' all the time; I have no choice but to assume it is because she isn't lying, that she really does love them. 

Hard to say the same when you claim she may have removed her implants that she never filled after 2011 and everything is just old recycled material.  In fact, that is impossible to say and lacks any evidence.  There is no Burden of Proof Reversal, it is not Argumentum ad ignorantiam, live by the commandments of logical debate and present the evidence of your claims.

By the way, Sol, on OF, Beshine shows she does wear heels under certain circumstances today, which I'm quite sure does not include strutting up and down a roughly paved drive, let alone cobblestone.  But just thinking at how easy she made it look back then and how Foxy injured her ankle with less than spike heels, lends me to think that when Beshine described her body as "athletic," that may have been an indication of her abilities rather than appearance.  The one thing of absolute certainty, she does not move today anything close to how she moved in 2011.  Something changed that made her step far more cautiously, but don't look to lolchair for answers, he says that there is no evidence Beshine got a fill up after 12 years ago.  For some reason, maybe it's just me, but I look at that as calling Beshine a liar since she continually remarked that her boobs were getting larger.

[Miggieknows]

Ladies and gentlemen
All in all even though there is clashing and arguments here in This thread talking about if Beshine
Has been filling her boobs or never did past 2011 or like 12 years ago….. like really if one is not a visual person, you won’t see a difference but me personally

I can see that Beshine Boobs look way different from 2011 to today ….
You can also see that her BOOBS touch in many pics even in videos too
And I’m referring to Beshine OF page cause in that you see Beshine in her every day life experience with SUCH MASSIVE HUGE GIANT BOOBS journeys she has and the challenges Beshine takes and handles and also that mass weight of her BOOBS can be read in every pictures and vids …… so idk
I only stat that let’s just enjoy Beshine and her super MASSIVE GIANT HUGE BOOBS!!!!

And let’s just be patient and see till the day Beshine does say or will ever say her claims or whether she will say hey guys my boobs been growing …… this is how big I am……

We just gotta dream guess numbers till the Queen says…….

[Boosterboobs]

Anyway, it is Sunday and I decided to post a old picture this week to remind everyone how much space once existed between Beshine's growing boobs.  There are topless pictures on this thread from the same time period that demonstrate the same.  But as everyone can see, without a top to squeeze her boobs together, they are pressed against each other today; that is a lot of added saline.  I would venture to say that her breasts naturally touching probably led to the change from a rather traditional heavily restrictive bra style in 2019 to what we see her call a bra today, which is a very elastic and stretched tank top with thin straps to discourage the garment from slipping downward with the inevitable bob of her boobs with every step.  I think you saw the video of how she steps into it as if it was a slip and then pulls it up, stretching a lot to get one boob in at a time.  Nothing like the old days.

This photo belongs to the gallery dated 01-26-2011 on the Beshine website and there is just a big space between her breasts because she still hasn't done the 10k filler that happened the week of February 14-20 (1700cc on one side and 2000cc In another side)
That explains why you can now see more together without a bra

One thing for sure, those that are essentially calling Beshine a liar by saying her boobs have not changed in size over the past 12 years despite her postings or by ignoring her encountering a new array of big boob problems along the way as she spoke of many times, or inferring she got tired of her boobs and had a reduction, or by saying her material is all old, have no basis for their claims, present no evidence of support, and only exist on this thread by the grace of the mods and/or Beshine in their efforts to demean her and those that support her.  They come here, make false claims, and demand that we prove them wrong; what childish behavior in the face of no evidence proving them right.

Definition of Liar:
"Deliberately saying the opposite of what is known, believed or thought to be true in order to deceive someone"

First she has to say that she is a certain size and then find out that she is not the size she claims.

One thing for sure, those that are essentially calling Beshine a liar by saying her boobs have not changed in size over the past 12 years despite her postings or by ignoring her encountering a new array of big boob problems along the way as she spoke of many times, or inferring she got tired of her boobs and had a reduction, or by saying her material is all old, have no basis for their claims, present no evidence of support, and only exist on this thread by the grace of the mods and/or Beshine in their efforts to demean her and those that support her.  They come here, make false claims, and demand that we prove them wrong; what childish behavior in the face of no evidence proving them right.

That she expresses, writes, shares her daily experience with huge tits and expresses it with a comment does not mean that she has a filler; that you interpret it; That's why she can never be a liar.
That she expresses, writes, shares her daily experience with huge tits and expresses it with a comment does not mean that she has a filler; that you interpret it; That's why she can never be a liar.
All of us in this thread are fans of her, but some of us don't agree with your statements or theories, you don't degrade her.
I will always be a fan of hers even though she has never filled in since 2011 and I think the others too. She looks very pretty, happy and with an impressive size of tits.

what childish behavior in the face of no evidence proving them right.

Have you provided any evidence that shows you are right? You have preferred to publish an old photo rather than some comparison where it looks bigger than 2011.
I have not seen the videos that you told me where the difference in size can be seen, they are not on their website; maybe you could send me a video capture by MD? maybe i have them

[Bombayduk]

^ad ignorantiam