*

E_W

  • X Cup
  • 2225
Re: What a Bitch
« Reply #45 on: September 16, 2003, 02:26:39 PM »
Quote:

  I'm not saying it couldn't be biological to some degree




I believe I stated in my first post that I allowed some room for biological factors as well.  I guess that was a lot of posts ago so I don't blame you.

I was never trying to pick a fight with you specifically in the first place, but I ended up trying to adress all the opposition at once.  There are certainly others on your side who seem to hold a strict biologist view. (Is that the word?  I'm lingually challenged here.)  For your information, I'm a natural sciences major and a lot more comfortable around genetics than psychology or sociology, even though I keep an eye on the debate in both fields.  Here's a question for you that I'd really like to see answered, in as many and complicated words as it takes; how does one differentiate between genetically inherited traits and enviromental (in the most generic sense) conditioning in the brain?  Of course the structure for the basic brain cells is decided by the genetic code in combination with our own biochemistry, of course we have different hormones running through our veins, but couldn't actual physiological male/female differences to some degree be explained by stimulation, or lack thereof, of certain areas in the brain as well?

I'd never say that the physical sciences will be able to fully explain what goes on in the human mind.  We will simply never be able to keep track of all the variables.  

To quote Stephen Hawking from a lecture of his I recently attended, physics will never be able to fully explain the universe.  The same goes for women (well, people in general really) which proves I picked the wrong profession.    On the other hand, imagine knowing exactly what turns people on and how... frightening, really.  

*

GizmoWidget

  • P Cup
  • 1577
Re: What a Bitch
« Reply #46 on: September 16, 2003, 03:11:05 PM »
EW said;
Quote:

There are certainly others on your side who seem to hold a strict biologist view.



Yes, in fact this unfortunately is the predominant view in the physical sciences.  As I've said here previously, the typical view is that if science cannot explain or predict something, it simply doesn't exist.  At it's worst, this viewpoint is applied to the study of the mind and mental contents and the false conclusion is drawn that the mind and mental contents do not exist.  

My own field of study stradles the fence; I am a behavioral scientist, but I study the physiological mechanisms that underlie behavior.  I have an extensive background in neurobiology and human physiology, as well as philosophy, psychology, and anthropology.  While my field specifically is experimental psychology, I consider myself a general cognitive scientist.  I'm interested in what the mind is and how it works, and I don't believe that any one discipline can provide all the answers.

Quote:

Here's a question for you that I'd really like to see answered, in as many and complicated words as it takes; how does one differentiate between genetically inherited traits and enviromental (in the most generic sense) conditioning in the brain?



I'd like to know too, along with just about every biologist, psychologist, philosopher, and anthropologist that has ever seriously studied behavior...  This question is basically the core of what we do as serious thinkers who study just about any aspect of human nature.  Basically, it's the Nature vs. Nurture debate.  In general, it's been pretty well established that the two interact, the question is finding out just how important each is for a given social and/or behavioral phenomena.  That's why I study the brain, it's the engine of reason, the throne of understanding and it makes us who and what we are as individuals.  That is also why I study perception.  If you want to understand just about anything, the first step is to understand how it is we know what we know, or what we think we know as the case may be.  Sensory perception is where the rubber meets the road; it's the interface of ontology and epistemology.  All knowledge and understanding occurs through the mechanisms of sensory perception.  (Please note, this claim does not necessarily bind me to a radical empiricist theory of knowledge, as per Hume or Locke, so let's please not get into that here...)

Quote:

Of course the structure for the basic brain cells is decided by the genetic code in combination with our own biochemistry, of course we have different hormones running through our veins, but couldn't actual physiological male/female differences to some degree be explained by stimulation, or lack thereof, of certain areas in the brain as well?



Yes, exactly.  Our genetic code specifies how brain cells are to be made and how they are to work, but it doesn't specify how a brain is to be functionally structured.  Lots of animal studies have shown there are particular critical periods for the development of particular basic visual and linguistic abilities.  If an organism isn't exposed to these influences at the proper time, those abilities will develop only poorly or not at all in the brain.  Endocrinology also has an important role here for gender differences as well.  Estrogens and testosterones have documented effects on the development of the brains of laboratory animals and as a result their behaviors change.  This is the basis of my twins example in a previous post.

Quote:

I'd never say that the physical sciences will be able to fully explain what goes on in the human mind.  We will simply never be able to keep track of all the variables.



It's not so much a question of keeping track of enough variables, but that does represent a significant challenge that perhaps could not be overcome.  One of the complicating factors is the multiplicative complexity of the brain.  The average human brain contains 10 to the 11th power neurons.  These neurons are capable of retracting axonal or dendritic connections with other neurons, and then form new ones by growing new axons or dendrites.  Now this process takes on the average about six weeks.  So if you factor that in with the total number of neurons in the brain, and how long the average human lifespan is, and add a correction factor to account for cellular necrosis over the life span, our brains are capable of forming 10 to the 800th power *possible* synaptic connections.  Now keep in mind that there are only 10 to the 42nd power fundamental particles (protons, neutrons, and electrons) in the universe.  That makes the human brain the most complex mechanism we know of, by several orders of magnitude.

The deeper reason science will never truly explain the mind  is more about the logical structure of the scientific method, and what makes subjective phenomenological experience what it is.  The logical structure of science is such that it's methods deliberately objectify the observer in the process of observing.  We look at a given phenomenon, and then step back from it such that our previous viewpoint is itself now a subject of observation.  This idea is fundamental to all science.  Science seeks to find transcendent generalities that are independent of an individual observer, and that can be demonstrated by running the proper experiment.  Thus, the individual viewpoint is necessarily excluded from the phenomena that are to be explained.  But, what makes our phenomenological experience what it is, is that it occurs at a specific point in space/time, within a particular context of conditions and circumstances.  That is the essence of what the mind does, it comprehends those particular moments as they occur, and the process of memory sort of stitches them all together so we have a continuous, coherent experience of ourselves as individual organisms.  The logical structure of scientific understanding is incompatible with this essence of individual experience.  A great first article to get you into this stuff is called "What Is It Like To Be A Bat", by the philosopher Thomas Nagel.  I highly recommend it.  The argument he puts forth in that article is the best explanation of what I've just tried to say.

Quote:

To quote Stephen Hawking from a lecture of his I recently attended, physics will never be able to fully explain the universe.  The same goes for women (well, people in general really) which proves I picked the wrong profession.    On the other hand, imagine knowing exactly what turns people on and how... frightening, really.  



Yes, the mind is what is normative... we will never be able to step outside the mind to understand the mind.    
Put Buck O'Neal in the Major League Baseball Hall of Fame!!!

*

E_W

  • X Cup
  • 2225
Re: What a Bitch
« Reply #47 on: September 16, 2003, 03:49:39 PM »
Good luck with your research... should you ever make any particularly bright discovery, tell me and I'll put in a good word for you with my professors... you know, the guys who pick the Nobel Laureates...  

*

Kanodin

  • Banned User
  • 1325
Re: What a B
« Reply #48 on: September 20, 2003, 04:43:34 PM »
Has anyone here said that the phenotypical differences between 'men' and 'women' are completely arbitrary?

Before, I would have classified Widget as a rhetorical seducer, but now that Widget had a chance to elaborate on certain claims, I would say we agree on a lot more than we disagree on (Widget, your later posts in this thread make a lot more sense than your earlier ones; e.g. you were disagreeing with one's contention that at least one woman on earth had a specific behavior).

Now that Widget has renewed my interest, I just have to ask this question: has your field established a certainty beyond cogito ergo sum, or have we taken a step backward from that? (a serious question) I have not yet taken the time to read Wittgenstein or some of the other less recognizable advocates you cite.  

*

Xen0phage

  • C Cup
  • 70
Re: What a Bitch
« Reply #49 on: September 20, 2003, 05:23:53 PM »
LOL not only have I heard young ladies bitch when i have taken a look at them weather for thier bust or what ever i have had them complain right to my face. and i simpley say "Listen, if you don't want certain guys to look then don't show it off!"

So agree with much of the sentiment here that if you are gonna show it off to attract the cuties then you gotta be willing to take oggling from the not so cute ones  

*

GizmoWidget

  • P Cup
  • 1577
Re: What a B
« Reply #50 on: September 20, 2003, 05:47:20 PM »
Kanodin said;
Quote:

I just have to ask this question: has your field established a certainty beyond cogito ergo sum, or have we taken a step backward from that? (a serious question) I have not yet taken the time to read Wittgenstein or some of the other less recognizable advocates you cite.



Your question is essentially the philosophical debate of whether essence preceeds existence, or existence preceeds essence.  The existentialists, particularly Jean Paul Sartre claims that existence preceeds essence.  Our thoughts and experiences are determined by what we are, not the other way around.  No, ultimately, this question is unanswerable, because as I state above, the mind is normative; we cannot step out of the mind to understand the mind.  But, within the framework that has been established in the cognitive sciences, it's pretty well concluded that the physical instantiation of what we are is the ultimate delimiter in determining who we are.

Considering what I've said above, if you doubt this there's nothing much more I can say to you.  I can only give one example.  If you believe that Descarte's Cogito is the determining factor in our existence, then the first time you'd stop thinking about your own existence, you'd cease to exist; e.g. you'd always have to be entertaining the thought of "I am" in some form or another.  If some hot babe with big tits walks past you on the street and you suddenly think "ooh baby, nice rack" and are no longer consciously maintaining the though "I am", you'd poof out of existence.  
Put Buck O'Neal in the Major League Baseball Hall of Fame!!!

*

gOOber

  • Pic-O-Matic
  • 25236
Re: What a B
« Reply #51 on: September 20, 2003, 09:51:50 PM »
   
....rejoicing in the fullness thereof....

*

HeavyMetal1980

  • Banned User
  • 4843
Re: What a...
« Reply #52 on: September 21, 2003, 02:00:32 AM »
Er...OK.

That's NOT going to sit well with the ladies!

...you know...the ones that ARE ladies!!

   
"Listen to the Wind and dance with the Flames..."

~ HeavyMetal1980

*

Sadistyk

  • Oh My God Cup
  • 10601
Re: What a...
« Reply #53 on: September 21, 2003, 03:49:16 AM »
Oh, I'm going to get out of the line of fire on that one.

*

Aelfscine

  • D Cup
  • 122
Re: What a...
« Reply #54 on: September 21, 2003, 11:11:49 AM »
Fun thing to toss into the gears...

There was an article on CNN.com a while ago that was asserting a fusion of the Nature/Nurture argument.  It was saying that yes, there were genes that influenced behaviour, but that they needed to be triggered by outside stimulation.  The example given was of a gene that gave a predisposition toward physical violence.  The study basically looked at two conditions:

Is the gene present?
Is the [censored] abused/exposed to violent behavior?

The results generally were that both conditions needed to be positive in order for the [censored] to become violent themselves.  Without the gene, the [censored] wouldn't usually internalize the violent behavior.  Without the exposure to abuse, the gene would never be stimulated, and would not have any influence over the [censored] .

Studies of language have proven similar cases.  Chomsky argued that there was a 'language mechanism' in the brain that processed language.  That is, we haven't just learned how to produce language, we're physically built to do it, hardwired, if you will.  Not only that, but there is a critical period from birth to around twelve years of age where we are physically really damned good at learning langauge.  Little [censored] soak up words and grammar like sponges, and all by themselves organize complex syntax effortlessly.  While we teach them words and correct their mistakes, we certainly don't sit down with a five-year-old and diagram sentences with them.  [censored] ren in this 'critical period' learn language naturally and easily because their minds are genetically and physically ready to do it.  This period is a window, however, and those genes partially shut off after about age 12.  Adults that complain of difficulty learning new languages aren't simply making it up; it's literally more difficult, as their brains are no longer in the state they were as [censored] ren.

The importance of stimulation to provoke a predisposition is emphasized with "Genie," a girl in the 1970's who was terribly abused as a [censored] .  Her father basically isolated the family from everything, and Genie spent most of her days tied to a chair in a room, alone, and was virtually never spoken to.  She was eventually discovered and freed after the age of 13, and the lack of exposure to language had taken its toll.  Her critical period over, she was a linguistic cripple, and had great difficulty with a sentence any longer than "Milk" and then pointing to it.  The time for her language apparatus to be stimulated had passed, the critical period was over, and for the rest of her life, she would never be able to produce 'normal' language.

Now, my opinion on how this all relates to the argument at hand.  Yes, men and women are biologically different.  There probably are different behavior influencing genes between the two genders, and probably there are very many that are the same.  (Bear in mind that not everyone will even have the same set of them)  However, those genes that affect behavior will ALL lay dormant until they are exposed to the behavior that triggers them.  To be horrifically politically incorrect, let's say there's a 'Bitchiness' gene.  Men can all look on smugly and say "At last, we're proven right, they're genetically compelled to be a bitch."  Not true!  If such a gene were there, again, it would need cultural stimulation.

On a large scale, each culture has taken its own divergent path of behaviors that it glorifies.  Patriarchy, Matriarchy, whatever, someone somewhere decided that that was the way to be.  With a culture in place, the folks with genes that can encourage that behavior are going to be stimulated, setting off the genes, and encouraging the behavior more!  If that behavior is glorified, they'll probably mate, and spread the gene around a bit.  Then they'll raise their [censored] , stimulate the gene in them, and the whole cycle repeats.

I'm not saying by any means that genetics determine behavior or that behavior determines genetics.  I'm saying that they're incredibly and inextricably intertwined, and trying to separate them is impossible.  Neither one is more important than the other, or possibly could be.  At most, genetics or behavior alone can attempt to 'stack the deck,' but even then, not very reliably.

I'll shut up now.    
Tip o' the hat to Morphermor for the avatar!

*

HeavyMetal1980

  • Banned User
  • 4843
Re: What a...
« Reply #55 on: September 21, 2003, 10:21:13 PM »
I believe heredity and environment play a role in ALL human behavior.

High-blood pressure can make someone more irritable than others, thus, it takes less to piss them off!

Likewise, someone that has received unwanted attention most of their lives, is more prone to avoiding or dislikeing others.

These are just two examples.

But, I'll say once again, some women like that kind of attention...others don't.

Just depends on the woman.

There are plenty of fish in the sea...a true fisherman doen't give up until he makes a catch (hopefully a GOOD one!)


 
"Listen to the Wind and dance with the Flames..."

~ HeavyMetal1980

*

Kanodin

  • Banned User
  • 1325
Re: What a...
« Reply #56 on: September 23, 2003, 03:59:55 AM »
That's a fun one... try this:

Descartes walks into a bar.  The bartender walk up to him and asks, "the usual?"  Descartes replies, "I think not," and he vanishes.

Honestly though, "I think" implies an existing reference to a first person.  If we conclude from this that "I am," then proving existence from a premise that asserts that very same thing seems... circular.  I like the first few meditations, but I don't buy the latter part of it concluding that God exists simply because we have the idea of God.

Nevertheless, I do think it's rather humorous to think that we linked God to breasts (I hope I didn't end the universe by combining those two words in one sentence).  I hope we didn't offend God, although God must have the best sense of humor.