*

Jithero

  • F Cup
  • 641
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #15 on: October 04, 2003, 03:14:03 AM »
First, I don't like publicly ranking or evaulating people as a general rule.  I found the star rating thing annoying because I (and most people) are just not going to be bothered to rank every single user, especially since the vast majority of people around here are all worthwhile contributors.  There are one or two people on my "hate list" but they're easy to remember and can always be identified by the content of their posts..
However if I was having a bad day I can think of no better stress reliever than to sit here and give everyone bad stars, thus ruining their ranking and making the whole system pointless anyway.  (Yes I am being a bit facetious here).  The above applies to thread rankings as well.

Also like some others have said, I don't see the cup sizes as indicators of anything other than what they are - how many posts you've made.  I know there are some who are driven to post more frequently to get their cup size up (it's always fun to get to that next size), and this does lead to fewer "meaty" threads.  As long as we're not worried about bandwidth, though, I am fine spending the extra time to skim past a few more posts.
"A patriot must always be ready to defend his country against his government." - Edward Abbey

*

TheHerald

  • Ink & Paint Club Outcast
  • 3862
  • Ink & Paint Club Outcast
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #16 on: October 04, 2003, 03:15:01 AM »
While I make an honest effort to only post when I have something to say, I would HATE to have my posts be rated by somebody else.  

Do you have any idea how difficult it would be to get a lurker to post? I can tell you from personal experiance because I'm essentially a shy individual in social settings and deciding to post/speak up on any given issue requires confidence. Confidence that the people you are posting to will respect you and your comment even if they don't agree with your opinion. I believe the number one reason people don't post is the belief that they have nothing to offer to the thread. Knowing that they may be rated on their comment certainly won't encourage them to speak up.

Call me idealistic, but I like to believe that everyone's opinions/comments are valuable. Even the one sentence (or one word) posts created by someone who has a high number of total posts. The only exception I can think of are the personal attacks and other messages of hate or disrespect I see so rarely here.

No, the total number of posts is not a ranking or rating system. Bear in mind that it DOES indicate a certain commitment of someone's time (and thought). Some people have more time than others to make posts here. Some have less time now then they use to. I hope Munch Wolf and RandomX don't mind my using them as examples of this. MW and I gained alot more time when we lost a full time job and we both increased the rate at which we posted as a direct result. RandomX recently started school and gained privacy (and for now, time) that allows her to post more frequently here. In these examples, does that lower the quality of the posts since the poster can now post more often? I prefer to belief that the answer is no.

Hmm, I think I've used up MY time and will shut up now.    
Thank you for your patience as I indulge my need to share.

*

jaytas

  • Good listener
  • 2537
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #17 on: October 04, 2003, 03:16:48 AM »
Think of them not as ranking or rating but as milestones. For a person to see just how much they have said. Maybe as an indicator of when they have said too much?  


*

HeavyMetal1980

  • Banned User
  • 4843
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #18 on: October 04, 2003, 06:54:26 AM »
OK, it's clear you guys could use the opinion of a relatively new member...me.

I believe that rating and ranking should be decided by the administartors, moderators, and web masters. And they in turn can receive info from other posters as to whether or not someone deserves a specific title. Otherwise, the number of posts you have means exactly that...how much you post, nothing more.

I for one believe that the amount you post gives you no special priviledges. What people say about you, and how the community as a whole feels about you determines your net worth.

If I may, I'd like to use  Anekee's Forum  as an example. She has a ranking system that works similar to the amount of posts you have. But it only goes so far. After that, if you receive ANY other title it is because she, the administartor, and the moderators together believe you deserve it. I was just a guy posting a lot until she took the time to read my posts and e-mails and later decided that she felt I deserved a new title. I could post all day and all night, she didn't care. It was what I wrote that interested her, be it important, funny, charming, or helped build up her community.

She even offered to make me a moderator, but I felt that I lose my cool too much and declined. She appreciated my honesty and thus respected me more.

And just so you know, I have had posts edited or deleted for flaming or being off-topic too much. So anytime I start to think I am special and can do what I want, The moderators are quick to tell me different.

As far as the BEA goes, yes, I originally came here to respond to the comments and such about Anekee, but in talking (or typing as you will) I found some great people here and have settled down with the "Noble Crusade". I accept NOW that people will believe what they want and that flame wars are just silly as in the end, no one changes their mind and believes what they did before the arguement even started. I refer to flame wars in a light-hearted way and look at them as just a way to vent and discuss things that may be bothering someone.

Of course, I expect a mod to delete, lock, or edit when things get out of hand, so I am careful to mention that any smart-ass comments (for the most part) aren't taken too seriously.

I post when I have something to say. Important, funny, or otherwise. A really funny remark, or some nice pics, or even a derailed thread that leads to something more fun, can be just as much a joy to read as a carefully well written novel.

I am not TRYING to increase cup sizes, just respond to all the threads that interest me, and the BEA has MANY! I haven't even began to scratch the surface of the latest threads as of yet. As to older threads, if they are ignored, I assume they are ignored for a reason and don't reply unless I feel there is a good reason to (which for the most part, I haven't) or maybe just to comment on something funny someone else wrote.

Well, that's my opinion anyway.

I thought it might have value to listen to someone who originally trashed the BEA for being a bunch of wanking perverts (my first impression) and hateful people (refering to Anekee), only to dig deeper and try to figure you guys out...getting to know and accept you in the process.

I believe the cup system should stay as a fun way of keeping track of post count, and that if anyone has a specific title or honor, then they should be dubbed by the administrator, moderators, and so forth.

And when someone is out of line for too long, then should lose their title, and when they REALLY get out of hand, to simply be banned (as I saw in the banned from the BEA thread).


OK, I said everything I could think of, now I prepare to be questioned, responded to, agreed or disagreed with, and so forth.



 
"Listen to the Wind and dance with the Flames..."

~ HeavyMetal1980

*

E_W

  • X Cup
  • 2225
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #19 on: October 04, 2003, 07:46:59 AM »
Since when did the BEA forum become a beauty pageant style competition?  Ohhh... let's write something witty; that way I'll get more stars... the rating system was terrible and I don't think you need any stars to feel appreciated.  That's what positive responses are for.  

The cup size ratings indicates the level of involvement in the forum rather than the overall quality of posts.  Someone with a high cup size rating is a veteran of the board, nothing more.  If you really want to know what people think about each other, try reading the posts.  

I don't go around IRL asking people to rate my conversation skills or my wit on a scale from one to five.  No really, I don't, because a number has no true meaning in this context.  Also, people would think I was desperately seeking confirmation.  I certainly would.  

*

St Stephan

  • Moderator
  • 2682
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #20 on: October 04, 2003, 08:14:16 AM »
You want a mod's opinion?  Here's mine.  But first a caveat: we mods do not run this place.  We don't decide policy.  We're police-cum-garbagemen, not government.  So this is only my opinion, and it carries no more weight than anyone else's.

IMHO the whole rating idea, be it stars or cup sizes or Junior/Senior/Golden Member* is just silly.  Some posts are good and some are bad -  better put, some appeal to a lot of people and some don't.  If a poster is a pain in the @$$, that quickly gets known, and contrariwise if a poster usually has something of interest to say.  We learn to ignore the former and follow up the latter.

We have seen instances of people quite openly making multiple posts in order to increase their cup size.  Hey guys, that's not the kind of BE we're interested in here.  It's just silly and clutters up the Forum.

I say forget the star ratings and jettison the cup ratings (but keep the individual titles, they have character, like the avatars). JMHO.

0 ( ( o ! < J
*I'll show you my Member if you show me yours.    
Avatar with the gracious approval of the lovely Vanessa Montagne.
BEA members will find the full-sized (1.12 MB) animation,
cleansed of clumsy clowning claptrap by cloddish clerics, here.
For the original pictures, and thousands more, visit Vanessa.

*

RandomX

  • ZZZ Cup
  • 5718
    • www.overflowingforum.com
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #21 on: October 04, 2003, 09:45:08 AM »
St.S, I was watching your avatar off in a daze...it occured to me, where does the guy get a third hand?

And you want to see other guy's members?  
100% real woman, with notarized documents and witnesses to back this claim up.

*

DruulEmpire

  • Freakin' Huge!
  • 12880
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #22 on: October 04, 2003, 10:20:12 AM »
The star system wound up meaning little, since it was perfectly easy for a few people to go around giving high ratings -- which I didn't mind at all, and it was pretty, but it didn't mean a whole lot.  Almost as soon as I got here I was rated as high as MunchWolf, and I had to insist that I could never be on a par with MunchWolf.  I like Galavatron's solution -- look carefully and you'll notice that he has INCORPORATED his old stars into his avatar.

I miss the cup system simply because I liked the conceit of a woman achieving steadily more ludicrous cup sizes (as you might gather from my avatar).  Seems to me that everyone has gotten so hung up over ranking that they've forgotten what such cup sizes are supposed to suggest in the first place!

The trouble with rating systems is that they only make sense grading consistency, and I for one admittedly have no consistency.  Over in the Addventure, I can just as easily leap off some old and barely legible Francis story as Laelia's Femalien thread.  Here, I don't respond to every new thing, but if I FEEL like saying "Great morph," I will feel moved to post that -- after all, people here are looking for applause and feedback all the time.

I do wonder a little at "Let's have endless round robin contests or semi-private chats" thread, but those pop up everywhere, they seem to come part and parcel with the Web.

And you can bet that if I find myself (somewhat) alone with Vixen one night, I'm gonna chat up a storm.

In the final assessment, I don't care that much about any "official" rating.  All I care about is the positive response from any one person who happens to read and enjoy me.

Quite simply, Jug: if what you mean is "Someone seems to me to be a pest," maybe you should just post that and see if anyone agrees.  We already seem to be of a same mind on the subjects of spammers and flamers.

*

DrHyde

  • Mad Scientist
  • 3469
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #23 on: October 04, 2003, 11:06:38 AM »
I personally only post if it seems relevant to the discussion. Regardless of which system we use, its still going to be a pissing contest. A couple of guys might be trying to go for highest post no matter what system is used. I don't find the star system really all that bad at all. Its not necessary for the enjoyment of the site, but neither is the cup system. Either setup is fine with me. I'd rather just post on topic. Whatever happened to that?

*

Palomine

  • Moderator
  • 24024
  • Modern Male Mammal, Linux enthusiast.
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #24 on: October 04, 2003, 11:12:00 AM »
Quote:

I was just reading another thread regarding number of posts.  In my opinion, this is one of the most lame metrics to rate the quality of participation of a user.  As I stated in that thread, it is the equivalent of a "pissing contest", inspiring people to just post post post, giving very little regard to what they are saying.




I agree completely. Futhermore, the star ranking and even the cup size (based on quantity of posts) both strike me as somewhat meaningless IMO.

*

MunchWolf

  • What Tagline?
  • 11463
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #25 on: October 04, 2003, 12:44:37 PM »
I like the cup sizes ... but then .. I don't have one ... but I can see reason to remove the post count (at least from the general post info ... still keep it on the personal profiles page) ... personally I think more people should have titles, and there should be criteria (like they've been posting more than a year, and have more than a thousand posts) .. but that puts more work into Imaginos' pot (or at least turns something fun, into work, which is never good) ...

-Munch "Work is a four letter word" Wolf

*

Seelie

  • G Cup
  • 739
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #26 on: October 04, 2003, 12:51:46 PM »
Meh, it all just gedts down to jealousy, which is why I call it a lowest common denominator issue. Should we cater to other people's personality flaws (ie jealousy over titles) or not? If their actions prompted by the jealousy reduce enough people's fun, then something needs to be done. But as it stands I see more people joking and having fun with the cup sizes than bragging or ruining the atmosphere of the forum to get them. And I've got a pretty clean view having been gone for a year and jumping back in by reading every post in every thread on the first 3 pages of each forum. Yeah there are people posting for cup size, but most people joke about it good naturedly. Isn't that what it's supposed to be all about?

Oh wait, that's the hokey pokey. My mistake. I meant isn't that why we're all here?
-----
Hmm, I guess I'm not as omniscient as I thought.

*

DruulEmpire

  • Freakin' Huge!
  • 12880
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #27 on: October 04, 2003, 02:25:25 PM »
This discussion reminds me a little of the Save the Golden Wolf thread I posted down in OT.  At the time I posted, Sadistyk had not yet overtaken sheber, but I saw him moving in on (or up on) MunchWolf and Goldeneye.  We are seeing the passing of an old order on the first page of the User List, and that may be what's bugging people.  MunchWolf, Goldeneye, sheber, the moderators ... the established veteran personalities could always be found at the top.  Now, we are in for some shaking up.  Sadistyk will be top poster well before Christmas, and even as I write this Elvish Wizard and RandomX may be leapfrogging right over steveo onto the first page.  What's more, at the rate he's going, by sometime next year HeavyMetal1980 will be second only to Sadistyk.

While it's regrettable to see good conscientious veteran posters knocked down like this, there's no real alternative to it.  Soon the top of the list will simply show who's the chattiest, and the real standbys of the forum will belong to a lower echelon.  But so what?  Right now I'm enjoying the "nerd vibe" of being directly below rtpoe and St. Stephan.  I am finding the company I keep on the User List to be far more interesting than the top of it.

*

MunchWolf

  • What Tagline?
  • 11463
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #28 on: October 04, 2003, 02:35:29 PM »
the only problem with being on top .. is you have no where to go but down ...

-Munch "oooh .. I should write DeInspirational Posters" Wolf

*

ElmerFudd

  • Z Cup
  • 2746
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #29 on: October 04, 2003, 03:41:28 PM »
I really don't pay attention to post counts.  When I see a new thread by certain posters, I'll always take the time to see what they're up to now (Munch, Goober, Wolf, Palomine, Imaginos (ooh I'm a suck-up!)).  If you're not included, please think of that as a "yet" (also, these folks post a lot of "interesting stuff" in off-topic and general).

Also take into account, as said before, that some people have more time on their hands at the moment (hi Sadistyk!).