OK, it's clear you guys could use the opinion of a relatively new member...me.
I believe that rating and ranking should be decided by the administartors, moderators, and web masters. And they in turn can receive info from other posters as to whether or not someone deserves a specific title. Otherwise, the number of posts you have means exactly that...how much you post, nothing more.
I for one believe that the amount you post gives you no special priviledges. What people say about you, and how the community as a whole feels about you determines your net worth.
If I may, I'd like to use Anekee's Forum as an example. She has a ranking system that works similar to the amount of posts you have. But it only goes so far. After that, if you receive ANY other title it is because she, the administartor, and the moderators together believe you deserve it. I was just a guy posting a lot until she took the time to read my posts and e-mails and later decided that she felt I deserved a new title. I could post all day and all night, she didn't care. It was what I wrote that interested her, be it important, funny, charming, or helped build up her community.
She even offered to make me a moderator, but I felt that I lose my cool too much and declined. She appreciated my honesty and thus respected me more.
And just so you know, I have had posts edited or deleted for flaming or being off-topic too much. So anytime I start to think I am special and can do what I want, The moderators are quick to tell me different.
As far as the BEA goes, yes, I originally came here to respond to the comments and such about Anekee, but in talking (or typing as you will) I found some great people here and have settled down with the "Noble Crusade". I accept NOW that people will believe what they want and that flame wars are just silly as in the end, no one changes their mind and believes what they did before the arguement even started. I refer to flame wars in a light-hearted way and look at them as just a way to vent and discuss things that may be bothering someone.
Of course, I expect a mod to delete, lock, or edit when things get out of hand, so I am careful to mention that any smart-ass comments (for the most part) aren't taken too seriously.
I post when I have something to say. Important, funny, or otherwise. A really funny remark, or some nice pics, or even a derailed thread that leads to something more fun, can be just as much a joy to read as a carefully well written novel.
I am not TRYING to increase cup sizes, just respond to all the threads that interest me, and the BEA has MANY! I haven't even began to scratch the surface of the latest threads as of yet. As to older threads, if they are ignored, I assume they are ignored for a reason and don't reply unless I feel there is a good reason to (which for the most part, I haven't) or maybe just to comment on something funny someone else wrote.
Well, that's my opinion anyway.
I thought it might have value to listen to someone who originally trashed the BEA for being a bunch of wanking perverts (my first impression) and hateful people (refering to Anekee), only to dig deeper and try to figure you guys out...getting to know and accept you in the process.
I believe the cup system should stay as a fun way of keeping track of post count, and that if anyone has a specific title or honor, then they should be dubbed by the administrator, moderators, and so forth.
And when someone is out of line for too long, then should lose their title, and when they REALLY get out of hand, to simply be banned (as I saw in the banned from the BEA thread).
OK, I said everything I could think of, now I prepare to be questioned, responded to, agreed or disagreed with, and so forth.