*

Palomine

  • Moderator
  • 24024
  • Modern Male Mammal, Linux enthusiast.
Though well-meaning fans of Chelsea Charms and Christina Model are the intended readers of this post, it applies to all those users who post dozens of images of a model as image attachments in forum threads.
 
Below,I have excerpted my reply this morning in another thread. Please read it and consider my request for the benefit of this site as a whole. Thanks!
 
-----------
 
OK, it's official: Photoclubs just contacted BEA admin re: the excessive posting of non-morphed Chelsea Charms pix at this site in general, and in THIS very forum thread in particular. They were, IMHO, much nicer about it than they could have been but the fact remains:  
 
When folks use forum threads as a gallery, taking the opportunity to circumvent UG size and duration limits so they can post dozens of images of a single model (often from a single source no less!) problems regarding copyright are BOUND to rear their head MUCH sooner than would otherwise be the case.  
 
It's not just this single thread of course (though it seems to have been the straw that broke the camel's back as far as Photoclubs is concerned) but the insistence by some users here on posting pic after pic after pic after pic of Chelsea, Christina and other models is going to have only one result: images of those models will ALSO eventually have to be banned at the BEA for legal/liability reasons. Comparing what happens here at the BEA with goings-on at Hooters.dk or anyplace else is MOOT!  "I'm not the only one stealing images" is not a valid legal defense for copyright infringement for a website any more than it is for individuals so accused.  
 
It seems like it is going to be necessary for this site to implement a posting limit (of pix attached to forum posts) so as to curtail this abuse of bandwidth (though that's the least aspect of the issue of course). Site ownership/admin and the mods are considering options in this regard. In the meantime,  I would ASK that ALL of our users please try to exercise some voluntary restraint insofar as attachments are concerned. ESPECIALLY as regards Chelsea and Christina, the two models most frequently attached now that Score and Nadine images have had to be prohibited here.  
 
Please take it easy with the attachments... why not consider trying to abide by a voluntary 3 IMAGE ATTACHMENTS PER USER PER THREAD limit and see how it goes? We'd all much rather have voluntary guidelines respected by all for the continued health of our community instead of hard-and-fast rules that if violated can result in serious trouble for this site (as well as in trouble for the offender).  
 
--------------------
 
   

*

St Stephan

  • Moderator
  • 2682
We mods have just been discussing this question, now brought to a head by Photoclubs' extremely restrained request.  For now, Palomine's suggestion is only voluntary, and to my mind somewhat too tolerant:  I would have proposed  one picture per person per thread per day - and also note that starting another thread on the same subject, simply in order to attach more pix, is oh-you-tee.  But since it's only voluntary - for now - let's just see how people behave.

0 ( ( o ! < J
 
Avatar with the gracious approval of the lovely Vanessa Montagne.
BEA members will find the full-sized (1.12 MB) animation,
cleansed of clumsy clowning claptrap by cloddish clerics, here.
For the original pictures, and thousands more, visit Vanessa.

*

DrHyde

  • Mad Scientist
  • 3469
I would be more than inclined to go with the 1PPUPT system....being that I generally don't post many pics anyway...3 might be excessive given the amount of members who regularly post. 2 might be a solid compromise, but it all really depends on the amount of people posting and the content which is being posted. As for me, I all for one pic per user per thread. It would also reduce in size some of the pic oriented threads.

*

Palomine

  • Moderator
  • 24024
  • Modern Male Mammal, Linux enthusiast.
Yes, mine was only a suggestion... if folks feel that some other proposal is in order, I'm happy to discuss it. Regardless, I DO think it would be in the best interests of the BEA to have a moratorium on Photoclubs content altogether.

Added later: in the few hours since my original post, news of another probably-soon-to-be-prohibited at the BEA model has come to light. Though this is not yet confirmed, it seems likely. And I can hear the clock ticking down on Christina images too... having so many posts of her seems akin to bull-baiting... almost daring the copyright holder to do something about it. Before still more total bans of particular models/publishers have to come into being, I think that we should probably institute a ONE image per person per thread per day rule for forum attachments as St. Stephan said. Better to live within self-imposed limits than to have to abide by total prohibitions under legal consequences.

Also, I think we need to make a better effort to make sure that users are aware of the current rules as they continue to evolve... many 'violations' (posts of Score and Nadine images months after those bans went into effect) were blamed on ignorance of the rules. Clearly, we should do something to insure all are aware of what can and can not be posted here, for the good of the community as a whole.

*

HeavyMetal1980

  • Banned User
  • 4843
What about Vixen?

Will she be free to post as many of her own pics as she likes?

I have noticed that she as well as many others seem to really love posting a lot in her massive thread.


She won't be limited will she?
 
"Listen to the Wind and dance with the Flames..."

~ HeavyMetal1980

*

MrHHH

  • L Cup
  • 2985
It's up to Vixen if she wants the pictures posted or not. You do realize that if she changes her mind, the whole vixen thread will be coming down.

Part of the problem is the forum software. There's no controls to prevent mass postings.
 
I have never, in the history of the Internet, NOT see a new fan post multiple pictures on this, or any other forum.

*

MrHHH

  • L Cup
  • 2985
Actually, now I'm upset. All this could easily be avoided if the concerned party took TWO SECONDS, got on the forum and said "Can you guys please not do that anymore.".

No, as soon as something like this happens they whips out the legal letters. For pete's sake. Are we so beneath their notice that we're not even worth talking to?
 

*

HeavyMetal1980

  • Banned User
  • 4843
Well, someone once told me:

 "I don't make the rules...I either follow them, or break them and suffer the consequences..."

 "It's not fair...it's the way life is..."


I hate it when people say that...no matter how true it is.  
"Listen to the Wind and dance with the Flames..."

~ HeavyMetal1980

*

rtpoe

  • Old Fart
  • 12428
The problems of success.....

rtpoe
rtpoe

The snapping of pitch from a burning log,
The faint scent of pine filling the room.
Flames leaping about as if it were a ballet
Performing for its audience.
The soft, comforting glow of candlelight,
Bringing with it serenity and quiet thoughts.

Linda Christensen, Autumn's Beauty

*

HeavyMetal1980

  • Banned User
  • 4843
Too much "love" CAN be a bad thing.  
"Listen to the Wind and dance with the Flames..."

~ HeavyMetal1980

*

Sadistyk

  • Oh My God Cup
  • 10601
I was actually wondering how long that thread was going to continue before we heard from somebody about the pics on it.  I could see trouble coming a mile away.

*

Zorro

  • Zorro Cup
  • 6053
  • Morphs are updated each week!
    • Zorro" Zorromorphs @ Shutterfly
One of the methods I have recently tried was making a collage of my morphs, and making one post only in the "Update" and "User Gallery" forums when I upload something.

This way the users here get a sample of about 5 or 6 pictures at one time, instead of many uploads to one forum.

Also, since I seldom use the "known" models, except for Vixen and an occasional other I suggest that my method be approved or at least allowed and that others, either gallery owners and/or guests etc. do the same.

I hope this suggestion has some merit and will be considered favorably.  
WHEN STARTING OR ANSWERING THREADS/POSTS, LINKS ARE SHOWN TO PROVIDE SOURCE INFORMATION INSTEAD OF JUST COPYING/PASTING PERSONAL OPINIONS.

*

HeavyMetal1980

  • Banned User
  • 4843
Well, shit.

At least there are always new pretty faces surfacing right?  
"Listen to the Wind and dance with the Flames..."

~ HeavyMetal1980

*

Palomine

  • Moderator
  • 24024
  • Modern Male Mammal, Linux enthusiast.
OK, just my gut response to a couple of points above:

Re: limiting Vixen's personal posts or the posts of others in her 3K+ post thread. While I suppose that there could be an exception to the 1 post per person per thread per day limit if the poster is the actual bona fide owner of the copyrights to the images in question, I'd like to point out that a 3K+ long thread is so lengthy and linear as to be basically unreadable for all practical purposes. It is basically a chunk of forum space and bandwidth being used as a single-subject gallery, and as a blog. Thus, it is probably more sensible to have such content in a section of it's own, such as a dedicated gallery, rather than squeezed into a forum thread.

Don't get me wrong... I think Vixen is absolutely the cat's meow. But if it were put to a vote (which of course it will not be... the final word on any site policy belongs to Imaginos and the Owner) I WOULD vote to include ALL forum participants in the 1 post per person per thread per day limit regardless of whether they actually own the content being posted. I think that this site would be lucky to include Vixen's images in a separate gallery, and that's where I happen to think such images would best be served to all. Again, this is just my opinion, not a BEA rule as yet.

Re: Mr. HHH's feelings about how he'd prefer that pissed-off copyright holders post an initial request in the forum before taking the legal threat route. Well, if I were the copyright owner in question, I doubt that I'd feel like making a request to an indeterminate (but large) group of anonymous individuals in a public forum, especially when most or all of them are unlikely to bear any personal liability for the site where my stolen content is being distributed. Thus, I (the fictional content owner) would probably prefer to direct my inquiry/threat/request/whatever to the ownership of the site, with the presumption that the ownership would be empowered to make/enforce site rules AND have the legal motivation (liability) to do so. Thus, when a Score rep or Nadine's webmaster or someone else sends an email or a PM to Imaginos or the Owner or sometimes to a moderator, it seems to me THAT is the path that makes the most sense for everyone involved. And in defense of our most recent incident, the folks at Photoclubs were VERY NICE about their request... there was no threat of legal action but it was clear of course that they were enforcing their ownership rights. As is their perogative.

On a related note, it seems that when the no-Nadine-pix (even morphs at present) rule went into effect some weeks ago, it was meant to also include content from the same producer, i.e.: Bettie, Leo, Dana, Daisy, etc... all those lush European natural models that fall under Bettie's umbrella (including that lovely brunette... is her name Magdalena?). Though this wasn't explicitly stated in the initial Nadine statement as it was relayed to me, apparently it was implied. As soon as Imaginos has time we'll probably have a new 'master list' of prohibited content, and it WILL be the responsibility of each and every user to be aware of and to abide by those revised rules. Failure to exercise restraint has played a part in bringing these rules into being... failure to follow them from this point on could have far more severe consequences for our community.

Personally, aside from the whole foolishness (IMHO) of using forum threads as gallery space, I just wish that folks would exercise some self-control when posting.... how anyone could rationalize that multiple posts of a single subject WOULDN'T invite trouble is beyond me.

 

*

MunchWolf

  • What Tagline?
  • 11463
Quote:

Actually, now I'm upset. All this could easily be avoided if the concerned party took TWO SECONDS, got on the forum and said "Can you guys please not do that anymore.".

No, as soon as something like this happens they whips out the legal letters. For pete's sake. Are we so beneath their notice that we're not even worth talking to?
   




I know Palomine covered this .. but I would like to toss in two cents from a different angle ...

One thing that bothers me is when someone DOES post that they don't want their content posted .. and then days or weeks go by .. and someone pops up and posts their content ... and when told not to do it .. refutes by saying they didn't see the original request not to post .. and that it should be made AGAIN ...

-Munch "Responsibilty should be on the thread poster, not on the content holder" Wolf