*

geoffk

  • Banned User
  • 433
Quote:

...Comparing what happens here at the BEA with goings-on at Hooters.dk or anyplace else is MOOT!  "I'm not the only one stealing images" is not a valid legal defense for copyright infringement for a website any more than it is for individuals so accused.





Well, Ok, that's true enough legally.  But you have to ask yourself *why* copyright owners would be so pissed at the BEA as compared to any number of sites which are clearly much more egregious (Cough cough Joggs cough cough).  For example, I've seen numerous unauthorized Score postings at a site which is carrying Scoreland banner ads.  It's hard to believe that Score is unaware of this.  This site is also *much* worse thsn the BEA ever was with respect to Nadine postings.

Yes, speeding is illegal, and if everyone else on the highway is also speeding it's still illegal.  But why are we the only ones getting stopped?

Finally, I'd like to point out that the more rules (and banned individuals) you make, the more likely it is that the rule will be broken.  We went from "No Score and Nadine pix" to "No Score (unless morphed), ever appeared in Score, is affiliated with Score, Nadine (morphed or not), affiliated with Nadine, Chelsea Charms Photoclubs, other Photoclubs, other Chelsea, Christina".  Frankly, I'd have a hard time even telling if some pictures are in compliance or not at this point.  If the rules get much more complex than that, you're going to get to the point where you'll have a hard time posting *any* pictures without somebody complaining.
 

*

DrHyde

  • Mad Scientist
  • 3469
Oddly enough, for a fetish site, as the BEA is, I found it rather odd that we get do slammed quite frequently as we do. But this could probably be chalked up to the sheer size of this site. Its not JUST a forum, its a massive compendium of many smaller sites. And its just as easy for someone to say to a friend who might work for one of these "no-no girls" that "Hey, I seen some really awesome pics of this chick there."

OH, and that lovely brunette you speak of Palomine, is Annemarie. Magdalena is from busty.pl

*

Kenard

  • F Cup
  • 473
I think the 1 attachment per thread per day is right on the money.  At least for a while and see how it goes.  You have my support on this.  

Iv posted several times trying to get people aware that some of the picture floods were going to cause problems.  The majority of people here havent been the problem, Its really just been a few.  Still, here we are today.

Vixen is a differnt animal all together since she owns those photos.  (except for the DrMorpho ones, those are his even if Vixen is in them)

I hope that everyone can just use their head in the future and try to use good judgement in posting.  

 
Big Boobs to You!

*

jaytas

  • Good listener
  • 2537
The thing about issues is that they are never black and/or white. They are chock full of shades of grey.

My take is that greed pisses me off big time. It seems to be the root cause of so many bad things in life. From tiny things to big things.

So. If a company wants to save a few percentage points of their profit at the cost of good will so be it. But at that point I will exercise my right to have nothing to do with that company ever again.

As an example. Not saying it relates directly to the companies involved here. But if I make billions and then arc up about a few millions I am just a greedy son of a bitch. Just my take is all. I believe that in a democracy I am entitled to my own take not so? Well this is it then.

THE END.


*

Palomine

  • Moderator
  • 24024
  • Modern Male Mammal, Linux enthusiast.
I empathize with everyone's concern. Some more specific responses:

Geoffk:

Since I'm not intimately involved with any other adult sites, I have no way of knowing  whether the BEA is contacted re: copyright violations any more or less often than other sites. As has been mentioned, the BEA is fairly large for a fetish site, and since it's based in the US it is far easier for copyright holders to actually DO something about violations if they so choose. Frankly, I can't think of a site comparable to the BEA, thus even w/research it'd be hard to say whether we're getting slammed more than anyone else is.

As for the fact that you've personally witnessed other sites appearing to violate Score copyrights... join the club. Sites come and go, they change names, URLs, ownership, etc.... all of which makes them hard to identify consistently, let alone sue. Our site has been around for YEARS and it's URL and ownership have remained consistent. That, along with it's US-residence makes it an easy, visible target (thus, Hooters and Joggs to choose two examples are simply less likely to have to take cease-and-desist letters seriously). Also, though your mention of seeing Score-logod content at sites that also feature Score banner ads may have indicated image theft, let me point out that sites which provide advertising for Score are also usually permitted to display predetermined samples of Score content (as this site does). At some sites, I have the impression that despite the fact that they're hosting Score-content-provided-by-Score, they don't go out of their way to label the content as such... lending the impression that those pix are something unique to their site, thereby hoping to make their site more appealing as a paid-image-source to their users/customers.

I know that the list of prohibited models changes and those changes can be confusing to keep track of. Unfortunately, that list will probably never remain static for long, especially while some posters continue to tempt fate and upload scores of images of single source/models to the forum, where they remain visible for the public to see indefinitely. This is yet another reason why the bulk of image posts made at the BEA SHOULD BE MADE IN THE GALLERY: there, they quickly cycle out to a non-public area, and since they're arranged chronologically (rather than by subject, as grouped together in a forum thread) it's obviously MUCH harder for anyone to easily locate and identify significant numbers of images that could be a problem. I do not point this out in order to direct folks to violate site rules or copyrights by using the UG/MG... but merely to illustrate other factors that make image posting in threads more problematic for this site... if a Photoclubs rep wants to check in and see if/how many of their Chelsea pix are currently being hosted at the BEA, it's a lot easier if all they have to do is stop by the forum and peek in on the threads with Chelsea's name in them. By allowing users to post scores of such images in the forum, and by having the forums remain public and posts be durable, we are basically inviting abuse AND making it easy for copyright holders to identify that abuse. Thus, it's no wonder that Imaginos and the Owner get those unpleasant emails... frankly it's a wonder that they don't get MORE of them, MORE often!

As soon as the couple of current issues are decided upon (as mentioned, Imaginos has been busy) we will recompile a new list and post it someplace where everyone can see it. It is and WILL BE each user's responsibility to be aware of those policies and to abide by them.

BTW, your addition of Christina to the list of prohibited models is premature... though I have little doubt that her rep will eventually contact this site re: too much posting of her original pix if some of the participants in the image-heavy Christina threads don't give their mouse-hands a rest from all the constant uploading of non-morphed images of her.

DrHyde:

Thanks for the correct ID on Annemarie. Both she and Magdalena are gorgeous IMHO. I agree that this site's size (along with it's longevity and place of residence) simply makes it easier to take action against that is/would be the case for some other sites.

Kenard:

Yes, I agree with you and St. Stephan that ONE image post per user per day per thread is probably a more prudent rule than the 3 per day I originally suggested. As to whether exceptions to this rule will be adopted for posts by actual owners/creators such as Vixen, Keisha, etc... I don't know. I wouldn't have a cow personally if Imaginos DID let Vixen, etc... post as many images as she might like in a forum thread, but again, I have to repeat my earlier comment that a three-thousand-post-long thread is not the most effective way to share images or information, nor is it the best use of BEA forum resources. Much better IMHO, to set aside a gallery for Vixen, Keisha, Christine, Kurvsgirl, etc.. or any other models who might sometimes wish to share more than a few pictures with us (their grateful fans) at a time.

I echo your sentiment re: hoping more folks will use good judgement when they post, regardless of the letter of the rules at any given moment. If folks simply work within the "letter of the law" WITHOUT exercising common sense, I have little doubt that other trouble will follow... no set of rules, no matter how comprehensive they may seem, can insure a complete absence of trouble along these lines.

Jaytas:

I can certainly sympathize with your indignation at what some clearly feel is the unfair degree of harassment that this site seems to be subject to lately. And should you choose to exercise your rights as a consumer accordingly, and not patronize those business who you feel are 'cutting off their noses to spite their face' by alienating fans, more power to you. IMHO, in this country anyway, voting with your wallet by patronizing companies who's practices you approve of and by withholding your business from those you don't is the ONLY way to have any hope of really expressing yourself with any degree of meaning to such companies (ie: their 'bottom line').

 

*

TrapJaw

  • Moderator
  • 583
All I know is that this subject is occuring because things are very much out of hand. I honestly suggested that picture posting in the forum be turned OFF, just because it was the only way I as a moderator felt comfortable... If a decision comes down to limit posting to 1 or 3 a day or whatever you guys frankly should be jumping in glee. That's pretty relaxed in comparison to the alternative.

Whole situation sucks, but not a lot can be done but what has been attempted. Rest assured though, the BEA will take every request for picture removal VERY seriously, and I as a moderator am here every single day looking for the inevitable "naughty post" as I like to call them.

Sometimes on days where I show up and nothing has to be done I lean back in my chair and outloud say "Good job guys!".

I haven't been saying that a whole lot lately.  
READ OUR RULES...

The RULES

*

Keisha_Evans

  • G Cup
  • 1242
    • www.keishaevans.com
Hello All,

I'm very sorry to hear that the BEA has gotten so many complaints about over posting of content.  I can understand everyone's point of view and the concern generated.  My question here is simply in regards to my own content.  When I update, do I just need to post one pic now or can I continue to post two as I usually do?  I'd hate to violate the proposed rules of the Forum and cause problems.  I've uploaded to the UG in the past, but as fast as things cycle off, I'd like to give as many people a chance to see the pics as I can.  Does anyone have a solution or suggestion?  Thanks very much for your input.  

Kisses,
Keisha    
"There'll be time for introductions later, and maybe some sex. "

 www.keishaevans.com

*

Palomine

  • Moderator
  • 24024
  • Modern Male Mammal, Linux enthusiast.
Hi Keisha,

Happy to clarify as best I can. UG post rules haven't changed. At present, the idea about limiting forum image attachments to 1 per user per thread per day is simply a proposal, not yet a policy. So for the time being, users can still post more than 1 image (as many still do). Whether the new policy (in whatever form it takes) includes an exception permitting users to upload more than 1 attachment per, such as for users who actually produce their own images such as models, morphers, etc... remains to be seen.

We're just trying to come up with an approach that will let us all continue to enjoy this place w/o too much hassle for the owner/operator.

 

*

Aven

  • D Cup
  • 164
Although this doesn't really help out the Legal Problems, it may be a solution to any bandwidth problems that the BEA might be having or could have in the future. Another Forum I post on has a system where if people want to post pics, they must use their own web space. This could prove to be bad though, as with the amount of traffic that occurs here, a lot of free web space hosting companies might become shitty with the bandwidth that they are being hit for.

A suggestion anyway.
"I'm tired of all this nonsense about beauty being only skin-deep. That's deep enough. What do you want - an adorable pancreas?"
-Jean Kerr

*

Palomine

  • Moderator
  • 24024
  • Modern Male Mammal, Linux enthusiast.
Thanks for your suggestion Aven,

While excessive posting of images in the forums does consume the finite amt. of storage and bandwidth that this site is able to provide for free (non-member) services, that is as mentioned of lesser concern than the liability issues involved. When attaching an image to a forum post, users can host tha image on the BEA's server by uploading the image when posting, OR they can insert an image tag that contains a link to an image file hosted elsewhere on the web if they prefer (which is what I believe you were describing, if I understand you correctly).

I'm hoping that we'll have some revised policy that is comprehensive and concise soon, so that everyone will know where things stand. In the meantime, I continue to ask all of our users to exercise common sense when choosing what to post/link, especially in light of recent events.

Thanks again.

*

kalani

  • D Cup
  • 143
A thought:  The one-per-person-per-thread-per-day rule is probably a reasonable general rule, given that specific-topic image-fests ("Show us your favorite tight shirt shots" or "Wow, here's a super cleavage pic, got any more?" etc) tend to invite lots of attached images in response.  The need to add forethought to enthusiasm -- seems like the archetypal story of human nature.  

For content-owners (like Keisha), however, who wish to do a bit of self-promotion, a more liberal image limit may make better sense, because such posts don't necessarily invite the flooding response (at least they don't have to).  Additional pics in such threads are often a morph or two, and perhaps another sample or two on a subsequent day in reply to an enthusiastic response.  As long as the prospect of a flood is neither inherent in nor encouraged by the model's original post, then two or three images up front (ahem) will see parties on all sides (content-owner, BEA user, and the BEA website) well served.


   

*

HeavyMetal1980

  • Banned User
  • 4843
It seems to me that Nadine and Chelsea (or those in partnership with them) had a problem with the amount of pics being posted. So they wanted it put to an end.

Just like with Vanessa Montagne telling me to be sparing with posting her pics, I try to refrain as much as I can.

But Kiesha and Vixen CHOOSE to post their own pics. SHOULD they be limited, since in fact those are THEIR pics that they freely choose to share?

And if Vixen and Keisha no problem with their pics being posted, should their be a limit to the amount that can be posted, as long as the two of them agree with it?


By the way, I just wanted to be clear, is it that we can't post ANY pics of Chelsea Charms, or just the PhotoClubs ones?


Of course I understand what Palomine is saying and i apologise for posting a PhotoClubs pic of her in the "women with Glasses" thread.

But should Kiesha and Vixen be limited to post their own pics?


Just wondering.    
"Listen to the Wind and dance with the Flames..."

~ HeavyMetal1980

*

Palomine

  • Moderator
  • 24024
  • Modern Male Mammal, Linux enthusiast.
HM,

Presently, it is just Photoclubs images of Chelsea that can't be posted. But before anyone runs out and starts a new thread flooded with pix of her from another source, I'd simply ask that he/she please exercise restraint, or we'll simply have to add yet another source to the prohibited list... this is what the proposed forum attachment limits are inteded to avoid (more bans on models and sources).

The Galleries are where images are intended to be hosted at the BEA. This is a better place for them for a variety of reasons (already stated). If a user is just in the mood to share a new pic of a model (or 5 new pix, as that's the daily upload limit in the UG) there's really not a heck of a lot of justification to start a forum thread to do so... just post it in the UG as G-d and the BEA owner/operator all intended.

Thanks.

As far as having different attachment limits for content producers posting their own images (such as models like Keisha and Vixen, or for morphers, etc...) than for other users, that's something that Imaginos will have to decide.

AGAIN, if anyone has a suggestion as to how they think any new policy should be designed/implemented, I urge you to PM Imaginos as the final decision is up to him... posting a suggestion in this or any other thread (even one titled "Hey Imaginos" is not necessarily going to get read by him. Though he's busy, he will eventually get to all his PMs... so if you want to have some input BEFORE new rules/limits are put into place, now's your chance.

*

HeavyMetal1980

  • Banned User
  • 4843
Quote:


Presently, it is just Photoclubs images of Chelsea that can't be posted. But before anyone runs out and starts a new thread flooded with pix of her from another source, I'd simply ask that he/she please exercise restraint, or we'll simply have to add yet another source to the prohibited list... this is what the proposed forum attachment limits are inteded to avoid (more bans on models and sources).




OK, I gotcha.

NON-PhotoClubs pics are OK, but give them the "Vanessa Montagne" treatment.

No problem.

Quote:

As far as having different attachment limits for content producers posting their own images (such as models like Keisha and Vixen, or for morphers, etc...) than for other users, that's something that Imaginos will have to decide.




Well, I just feel that as long as Keisha and Vixen are not offended, and everyone doesn't screw up the system with too much content, that they should be free to share as much as they like...well, as much as  THEY  not  WE  like, I should say.


Only reason I say that is because from reading Vixen's massive thread, she seems tickled to death to get that kind of attention, and most everyone I believe that posts on that thread seems to be having a ball.

I just wouldn't want to see a good thing crash and burn, that's all.


I know I for one really like the fact that Vixen and Keisha are so generous. That doesn't appear to be true with EVERY woman now days.


But, as you said Palomine, Imaginos ultimately will be the judge on this, so perhaps (as you suggested) I should just PM him about it.


I do have one idea though. Perhaps I can share it with the others here first.

What if you somehow some way (I'm not a wiz with computers myself) found a way so that after a pre-set limit of say 5 pics or so was posted on a particular thread, no more could be posted until the following day, or perhaps a lock that is engaged after 5-7 pics are posted, which can only be unlocked after a moderator "unlocks" it after he has had a chance to review it? People could STILL post, just not add more attachments.


I don't know...like I said, I'm not a wiz with computers so I don't know if that could be done or if it's fair or not as it would imply a "first come, first serve" type of arrangement.


Hmmm...maybe it's a stupid idea, I just kind of made it up and tossed it out in the open.


I just figured I would say it now before I forgot about it.


Oh, well, it's an idea...maybe not a good one...but it's an idea. Only damn thing i could think of at the moment.

Criticism is more than welcome.  
"Listen to the Wind and dance with the Flames..."

~ HeavyMetal1980

*

Keisha_Evans

  • G Cup
  • 1242
    • www.keishaevans.com
Hiya,

Thank you very much for the info.    Hopefully everything will sort out in the end for the best for all of us.  I appreciate the responses.  Thanks all.

Kisses,
Keisha  
"There'll be time for introductions later, and maybe some sex. "

 www.keishaevans.com