I've gotten a few more question in email so I'll answer here in a non-satisfactory way, because I'm an arrogant bastard.
Seriously though, what really happened in that other place that made me angry wasn't so much the cut and paste job. When people start out online, myself included, issues of privacy, copyright, etc. are intangibles. For the record, I did two posted morphs from Score magazine long before the bea existed. To give away my age I did them on an Amiga 500 with 512K of memory. And posting them mean about 15 people might see it on a little known FTP site shared among a very few of us. The copyright issues didn't seem *quite* as profound then. No, I do not like my work cut apart and assembled into other pictures that take characters I spent a LOT of time making look as tangible as I could and putting them in the context never intended.
Imagine it like this. Suppose you said: "I think that people need more respect for the law, and that applies to people of all races and religious beliefs. Whites, blacks, asians, Christian and Jews alike need to come together and stamp out the differences that create stereotypes that some especially uneducated individuals use to justify bigotry and propagate ignorance."
Now imagine someone took your statement and quoted you like this:
"I think that people need more respect for the law, and that applies to blacks and Jews, especially uneducated individuals."
I didn’t change a single word, all I did was Cut and Paste a selected part of it. That was how I saw my artwork being used. It was just cut and pasted into a different context, like that last statement.
What made me and other special acquaintances who may or may not have been involved with this comic angry was the vigorous defense that followed someone pointing out that it was a cut and paste job. So long as people thought more work using derivatives from what I had done might be coming they didn’t care how it got there, as long as it just kept coming. I felt bad for the poor guy that put together what he probably thought was a good collage! The argument began that once the work I had done was posted, all rights to it were gone. My simple response was “I guess you can see it that way, I can’t control what is done with it once it’s posted. All I can do is promise to not allow the posting of any more to prevent future occurrences...”
Whoaboy! Talk about backpedaling, some of the people left skidmarks. Suddenly I was being bombed with emails supporting me, including a couple from people who had argued the OTHER SIDE only a day before! Until then I hadn’t told anyone I was the artist because I really didn’t want the extra attention, but once people realized that given a choice of the other guy posting more art taken from mine and others, or me not allowing anymore from the comic that caused such a stir over there - they switched sides faster than the ex-president changed his mind about whether or not he’d had relations with a certain intern. They turned on a guy they were defending, and it just showed me that the arguments had nothing to do with a moral or ethical stand, but only which argument would get them more pictures to download. And I have a problem with hypocrisy. If you think I’m bad you should talk with my partner in crime who was even more disgusted. So thanks to that the project just kind of fell apart, and left the people who created the idea uninterested in creating more of something that was publicly promised to be chopped up and used for whatever someone else felt like.
So to sum up yet another overly long post… to those that think that an artist has no rights to anything they post online, you may have a philosophical argument. The price of it is that you just stop getting the raw materials from people like myself. And people who were willing to contribute heavily for me to continue are now no longer willing to. Sadly, I need to work on projects that provide little things like money for other things like food and gas, and something as time consuming as this comic no longer falls into that category. If I get time someday I might finish it out, ink the rest, but what I fear will more likely happen is that someone else will take it where it was left off and do their own version, and further justify all the reasons why the backers pulled out in the first place.
Oh, and to answer a question posted here. Yes, there was much juicing in the next issue.
Johnny “I really gotta take a class in brevity” Swell