*

Palomine

  • Moderator
  • 24024
  • Modern Male Mammal, Linux enthusiast.

Flesh_Demon, in an effort to provide moderation in as fair and consistent a manner as possible, I'm posting publicly so that eveyone can understand your actions (which have recently violated BEA site policy and placed this site at risk) and our reactions (as moderators). Normally, I would continue to try to address things privately (as most moderation is done) but since you seem hell-bent on bringing more 'cease and desist' letters to this site's ownership, you've left me little choice. Hopefully, by airing this out in the open (which seems to be your preference) others will understand the fact that you are repeatedly placing this entire site at risk simply because you WANT to.

On 2/5/4, you violated site policy by attaching an image of a banned model in a thread. You did this IN SPITE of the fact that a similar post of this model was deleted earlier in that very thread, and DESPITE the fact that other posters explained (before your post) that pix of her weren't allowed here for legal reasons. You attitude was basically: fuck it, I'll post her if I want to.' Of course, by doing so you place this entire site at risk (this model is the most recent one to send off a threatening letter to the BEA Owner). Following your intentional site violation, the entire  thread was deleted. When I contacted you later via PM, you were generally aplogetic, presumably because it was indisputable that you CHOSE to break site policy, and didn't do so by accident (out of ignorance). Regardless, I sent you a link to the rules.

Just a couple of days later on 2/7/4 you then start a thread and promptly post 4 almost identical images of a clearly-logod Score model (with only her back to camera, making her actual identity difficult to ascertain, and thus the fact that the image has been morphed not readily apparent). Of course in doing so, you violate the 1-1-1-1 rule by posting 8 images in a single thread at once (condsidering your double posting of each image)... reason enough to delete the thread. The fact that all 8 images sport a great big Score logo doesn't help matters... the 1-1-1-1 rule applies to morphs as well as unmorphed images. This is your second INTENTIONAL violation of site policy in as many days.

Most recently on 2/8/4, you started yet another thread to publicly wail that your morph was so convincing that the mods foolishly deleted your 2/7/4 thread mistakenly thinking that the image was unmorphed. Conveniently, you choose NOT to point out the fact that you posted EIGHT images at once in a single thread, which is of course yet ANOTHER CLEAR and INTENTIONAL violation of site rules and sufficient reason to delete the thread. Whether the image was morphed or not was and is moot. Though another mod removed this thread, I've returned it to the GF (in the interests of full disclosure, despite the fact that no mod is required to publicly explain each and every act of moderation) and linked from it to this thread.

Behavior such as yours: repeatedly choosing to ignore site policies that exist only to protect this site and keep it available for it's thousands of users is, IMO, inexcusable. You post banned models. You post multiple images in a single thread at once. You do both things knowing full well that they are violations of site policies.... policies that exist solely to keep this site from being shut down.

If the BEA were forced to shut it's doors forever after years of service to this community as a result of legal actions prompted by your recent behavior, how would you feel? More importantly, how would the thousands of other users of this site feel (many of whom have visited daily for years and consider it their second home)? Perhaps then your recent signature line "Flesh Demon, Hated By All" will be painfully appropriate.



                 
 

*

DrHyde

  • Mad Scientist
  • 3469
Re: Flesh_Demon's continued intentional site policy violations...
« Reply #1 on: February 08, 2004, 08:24:54 PM »
Was he banned or is this a super warning and public **73**? I figure he was banned, but I wasn't sure. Not that I tend to violate many policies or any really, but I was curious whether this is setting a precident for more bannings to come for policy violations. Mainly since I've only remotely heard about a couple of bannings altogether.

*

Zorro

  • Zorro Cup
  • 6053
  • Morphs are updated each week!
    • Zorro" Zorromorphs @ Shutterfly
Re: Flesh_Demon's continued intentional site policy violations...
« Reply #2 on: February 08, 2004, 08:31:28 PM »
Ahhh........I see the light now!

And here I thought it was because it was taking so long to get his gallery going.

I know I would like to put my morphs in the forums, and I do do that in a way by making the pictures a collage. This way there are multiple images, but with just one picture.

I do not see this as an infraction, and since none were deleted I guess the moderators are permitting this way to display my attempts at morphing pictures.

Folks...........we have to obey the rules that are set forth here, because we do not need to cause any problems for the BEA.

This is the reason that I now try to either morph unknowns, or at least ask permission of the models and/or owners of the pictures in question.

There are so many beautiful women out there to choose from. TopHeavy.com has new uploads just about every week of not only unknowns, but also of their own models.

Plus there are what I like to refer to as "our girls" who have chosen to hang out here (Vixen, Bambi, Vanessa, etc.) even though they may have their own sites to generate an income.

With all of this abundant morph material the restrictions set by Imaginos/The BEA are not there to prevent us, both morphers/artists/storytellers and the like, from displaying our work, but to keep us safe, secure, and this site in operation.

Palomine, I commend you for taking the time to explain your side of this and hopefully incidents like these can be avoided in the future.

Let's "morph on" as I have seen in another's signature on here and enjoy both the work and each other's inputs.
   
WHEN STARTING OR ANSWERING THREADS/POSTS, LINKS ARE SHOWN TO PROVIDE SOURCE INFORMATION INSTEAD OF JUST COPYING/PASTING PERSONAL OPINIONS.

*

jayjay88

  • L Cup
  • 1917
    • none
Re: Flesh_Demon's continued intentional site policy violations...
« Reply #3 on: February 09, 2004, 07:26:03 AM »
There's no room at the BEA for people who CHOOSE to break the rules.  This site IS a second home to many of us, and its demise would be a disaster!
jayjay......
Once a bOOb man, always a BooB man...!

*

St Stephan

  • Moderator
  • 2682
Re: Flesh_Demon's continued intentional site policy violations...
« Reply #4 on: February 09, 2004, 08:07:31 AM »
I just want to append a note to say that Palomine is not acting on his own here - although he has the right and indeed the duty to do so.  The moderators discussed this case and we all agreed that Flesh_Demon was way beyond the pale - for reasons that have been clearly stated by Palomine - and had to be stopped, by banning if necessary.  Since he has taken it upon himself to leave, the matter has been peacefully resolved.  

0 ( ( o ! < J
 
Avatar with the gracious approval of the lovely Vanessa Montagne.
BEA members will find the full-sized (1.12 MB) animation,
cleansed of clumsy clowning claptrap by cloddish clerics, here.
For the original pictures, and thousands more, visit Vanessa.

*

Whink

  • ZZZ Cup
  • 4544
Re: Flesh_Demon's continued intentional site policy violations...
« Reply #5 on: February 09, 2004, 04:24:23 PM »
Imaginos, Palomine, St. Stephan, and Master Blaster;

The only problem here is that the standards do not apply equally to all.  The 1-1-1-1 rul, for example, go and review the "Introducing Bambi Blimps" thread and note the number of posts by her 'boyfriend/promoter/webmaster/sugar-daddy/etc'.

Copyright is one thing, but you all have to be equal and fair to everyone, wouldn't you agree?  Of course I could just shut up and be one of the sheep... but then I wouldn't be me.

Whink


Thanks to Morphemor for the latest Avatar!

*

TrapJaw

  • Moderator
  • 583
Re: Flesh_Demon's continued intentional site policy violations...
« Reply #6 on: February 09, 2004, 04:42:57 PM »
<------- chopped liver.  
READ OUR RULES...

The RULES

*

Jithero

  • F Cup
  • 641
Re: Flesh_Demon's continued intentional site policy violations...
« Reply #7 on: February 09, 2004, 06:24:19 PM »
Quote:

Imaginos, Palomine, St. Stephan, and Master Blaster;

The only problem here is that the standards do not apply equally to all.




Exactly.  Your authority is not going to be respected as long as you wield it arbitrarily.  It seems that certain "in" people have leeway to post as many images as they like.  And if it's bandwidth we're concerned about, what about those who (while not necessarily violating the 1-1-1-1 rule) post pictures just for the sake of posting pictures?  They have nothing to do with the thread itself.

I could also do without the insults/threats.

jayjay was lamenting about the BEA's demise.  Well from where I sit, it appears as if this site has already peaked and is slowly crawling toward it's death.  If it's not  killed directly via a lawsuit, it will be due to tighter and tighter restrictions about what we can and cannot do here.  It really IS too bad that the various legal parties involved choose not to view it as free advertising.  Eventually people will move on to somewhere with fewer rules and less visibility.

-Jithero
"A patriot must always be ready to defend his country against his government." - Edward Abbey

*

DrCurvy

  • D Cup
  • 156
    • http://www.bambiblaze.com
Re: Flesh_Demon's continued intentional site policy violations...
« Reply #8 on: February 09, 2004, 06:31:20 PM »
Windinkler,
 I think if you go to the discussions thread you will see that the 1 post per day is a request not a rule. I resent the boyfriend/sugar daddy implications that you suggested in your post. You know not a damn thing about Bambi or myself to make such a statement. I've been a contributing artist of this site from the begining and have never broken the rules. Bambi is a breath of fresh air here at the BEA. You should take a moment to chat with her before you pass judgement. Maybe we don't want Beautiful, Busty women into our fetish hanging around.    

*

Highlander

  • G Cup
  • 729
Re: Flesh_Demon's continued intentional site policy violations...
« Reply #9 on: February 09, 2004, 07:02:37 PM »
Quote:

 I think if you go to the discussions thread you will see that the 1 post per day is a request not a rule.




This was something that has been bothering me for some time now... It seems that this only applies as a rule to those new members or those who are not seen as really big contributors to the comunity and only in the general discussion threads... if you go to the other parts of the forum, you'll still see that people post more then one picture per thread per day... Like, for example, on the tv/vcr allerts, some people post various caps of the particular program/movie... I'm not here to question how moderation is being done, or what criterias are being used...

It also seems that pictures are being deleted without previous warning to the posters... some posts require more then one picture to be posted in one day in order for it to make sence, like for example, a post showing some before/after or something like that... It would be nice if moderators warned the posters that they shold try to keep their picture posting down to the 1-1-1-1 thing...

And another thing: can any of the moderators explain here, once and for all, how this 1-1-1-1 thing works? is it a law, a rule, a request or what? and how does it work? I know it reads "one picture per thread per user per day". But, as far as I can remember, on the red sticky on this forum, it says that it would be nice if people had their picture posting down to maximum of 2 pictures per thread per day... I don't remember any other place or any other post from the moderators saying that is prohibited to post more then that (and if you are against the word 'prohibited', then you should have errased the pictures posted, cuz for me that looks like a punishment for the wrong doing. If 'prohibited' is the intended word, then disconsider this)...

One picture per thread per user per day, in my understanding, means that each user may post per day one picture per thread, or, in each thread he may post one picture... So, lets say that he posts in 5 different threads, he may post 5 different pictures... as long as they are for different threads... is that correct? If not, then gOOber may only post once per day, since in ALL his posts he attaches an image... (I particularly appreciate his contributions and I wouldn't like to see this decreased down to 1 post per day for him).

So, can any moderator explain here how this works? can we post in different threads different pictures or not? And can they give the reasons? Is it for copyright reasons or bandwidth?

I want to keep participating in this forum... I really do... and I also understand that for that to happen, there must be some rules... And those rules must also be explicit and understandable... The main problem is that sometimes these rules may have double meaning and/or interpretation and it happens that one moderator reads it differently then it was originally intended to be and it all starts working like that... And I'm not blaming anyone here... it's normal for that to happen (unless you're some kind of evil robot)...

So, before this post becomes long and boring, can anyone explain it? Or can all moderators talk about it and come to a reasonable concensus about the picture posting pollicy here?

Thanks and I'm sorry if I offended anyone... It was not intended...  
............../.....................The Highlander
............./
O[\\\\\\(O):::<=================================-
.............\
..............\................"There can be only one"

*

DrHyde

  • Mad Scientist
  • 3469
Re: Flesh_Demon's continued intentional site policy violations...
« Reply #10 on: February 09, 2004, 07:09:59 PM »
I generally never post more than one image at any time, but I would definitely like some clarity on this subject as well. I know 1-1-1-1 rule sounds as blunt as possible, but sometimes things can get confusing. Oddly enough, it seems the less complicated something is to understand, the more confusing it is. Must be human nature. Either that or I'm just stupid.

*

Highlander

  • G Cup
  • 729
Re: Flesh_Demon's continued intentional site policy violations...
« Reply #11 on: February 09, 2004, 07:11:11 PM »
And now I have a request that would make things easier: can the moderators post a reason why something is deleted? It's not nice to go to a thread and all of a sudden find a post that says just says "post deleted by MODERATOR" and nothing else... we wouldn't know if they broke a copyright thing or were rude or they asked it to be deleted... It would help us to learn what kind of things we cannot post!

(I know that some moderators do that, like deleting a picture and writing "Picture deleted for breaking the 1-1-1-1 rule"...)
............../.....................The Highlander
............./
O[\\\\\\(O):::<=================================-
.............\
..............\................"There can be only one"

*

Palomine

  • Moderator
  • 24024
  • Modern Male Mammal, Linux enthusiast.
Re: Flesh_Demon's continued intentional site policy violations...
« Reply #12 on: February 09, 2004, 10:29:04 PM »
OK, I will try to clarify some of the points raised above as best I can...

Flesh_Demon, by his own actions, was begging to be banned: he was repeatedly and intentionally violating site rules that he clearly knew existed and by doing so, placed this site at risk at least twice in as many days. As far as I am aware he has not yet been banned (I haven't banned him and none of the other mods has said that they have). St. Stephan says he has left of his own accord though I don't know anything more about this... if he simply stopped taunting copyright holders who've already made clear their intention to sue the BEA re: more infringement of their content, I'd have been satisfied. Please note: if a user DOES get banned, they will not simply be able to create a new user acct... their IP addy is permanently barred from this site.

Zorro's habit of creating single-image montages of multiple images to advertise new morphs is one that I am personally very fond of: it lets me know what new wonders he's come up with and if I want I can then go get the full-size invidual images. This is an excellent way of working within the rules IMHO and one that other image posters (those who might want to show a 'before and after' for example) who simply can't wait 24 hours to post image #2 ought to consider.

Whindinkler: we do the best that we can to apply the site rules as evenly as possible. Without doubt, there are times where some more than 1-1-1-1 posts have not been deleted... in some cases they're simply missed (remember there are hundreds of new forum posts to check every day and only 4 moderators). In other cases however, there is the feeling among some mods that it's reasonable to make an exception to the 1-1-1-1 rule if the content being posted is actually clearly the copyrighted property of the person who posted it (ie: models posting their own images, artists posting their drawings, etc... which is not to say that they can post an infinite number of attachments, but that if it's a reasonable sum some mods are inclined to leave that content alone as it doesn't invite lawsuits and actually is enjoyed by many BEA users (Keisha pix are just one example) which seems to justify the bandwidth used. Of course, some kinds of posts lend themselves to a gray area when it comes to reasonable 1-1-1-1 exceptions: vid caps and morphs for example. These images are probably not the copyrighted property of the poster, though they may at times not present a legal liabilty to the site (vidcaps are probably safe in this regard... morphs are probably not.... Imaginos and the BEA Owner HAVE decided to enforce even-no-morphs in relation to some banned models such as Barbie Griffin... presumably with legal reason having been applied).

Though it started off as a request (which was happily obliged by some users and totally ignored by others), the 1-1-1-1 rule (1 image attachment per user per forum thread per day) IS A RULE, and the phrase 'request' has been removed from it's explanation in the rules thread: http://forum.bearchive.com/showflat.php?Cat=&Board=UBB1&Number=165591&page=0&view=collapsed&sb=5&o=&fpart=1 ...EVERY SINGLE PERSON USING THE BEA FORUMS AGREES TO ABIDE BY THESE RULES WHEN USING THE FORUMS, PERIOD. Not knowing the rules is not an excuse... the link is pinned right there.... don't understand a rule, then ask. But those are the rules and they're there for a reason.

Jithero, authority is not wielded arbitrarily, nor are long-timers favored when it comes to rule application. As I explained, there IS some grey area when it comes to 1-1-1-1 and what might constitute a reasonable exception. As soon as Imaginos, the BEA Owner and the mods can come to an agreement about EXACTLY what qualifies as a 1-1-1-1 exception, you can be sure that clarification will be added to the rule thread. Bear in mind that if 1-1-1-1 is deemed to have to be applied to EVERYBODY IN EVERY CASE, we will then be discouraging contributors such as Keisha, Christine, etc... from sharing their pix with us... I'm sure that MOST BEA users would consider THAT to be a foolish decision (if it comes).

As for insults/threats: if you're referring to my dialog directed at Flesh_Demon, then I must take exception with your characterization... as mentioned, I'd have preferred to keep my moderation efforts in his case private (which is how they started out, like most such efforts) but he insisted on making the whole thing public, even going so far as to pullquote from my PMs to him (which at the very least is in extrememly poor taste... a PM is a PRIVATE message... like most folks I type things in PMs specifically because I DON'T want to do so in public for whatever reason). As for the comments left by mods when something has been deleted... of course in some cases the comment will specify the possible consequences of continued violation... it's only natural. Sadly, some folks seem to need to have it spelled out for them: purposely place the BEA at risk and you will be banned.

As for your perception of this site's downward curve being due to posting restrictions: I respectfully disagree.... I've been here a long time and in terms of activity, enthusiasm and participation I've noticed the curve go up AND down AND up AND down ad infinitum. If this site were hosted outside of the US (and thus much more difficult to sue) or it was owned by a free-info philanthropist who had nothing better to do with his cash than to spend it fighting off lawsuits, then the rules COULD be different here. But in our reality, the relatively modest set of rules that we have here we have because we must. And of those, at least a third of the bans probably wouldn't even exist right now if folks had just exercised some restraint when posting floods of attachments in threads during the past half-year... by doing so, various models/copyright holders were effectively being DARED to assert their ownership rights. You may see such posts as 'free advertising' but given the realities, it's the opinion of the person holding the copyright that matters... if Daktari Lorenz doesn't think letting folks redistribute his property serves his interests, he can by law insist that the behavior be stopped. He did, and the BEA Owner agreed to enforce such a ban (Nadine, etc...) rather than get sued. It's that simple.

Dr. Curvy, etc...: as mentioned, the 1-1-1-1 thing is NOT a request, it has become a rule. Right at this moment, there are some exceptions to the rule (such as images of models posted by their owner) but that may change as well. Regardless of agreed-upon exceptions, I'd ask ALL forum users to THINK before they POST in ADDITION to abiding by the rules... it's just common sense and common courtesy... if we'd had a little more of both, chances are we'd have at least a couple fewer rules in the list right now.

Highlander: as I stated above, the 1-1-1-1 rule exceptions are not based on an in-crowd, or on longevity, etc...  I've attempted to explain the cases in which a moderator might consider some more-than-1-1-1-1 posts to be acceptable (models, artists, vidcappers, etc...). I ABSOLUTELY AGREE that the EXACT NATURE of the 1-1-1-1 rule ought to be spelled out so all can understand it's application... as soon as that happens, I'll be sure to let you know.

As for mods explaining WHY something was deleted... from what I've seen the mod usually DOES explain why or else the reason is clear (multi-posts for example... if you see 3 deleted attachments in a row, posted by the same orignal user within a 24 hour period... it's clear that the deletions resulted from the 1-1-1-1 rule). I personally usually attempt to let the affected poster know both privately (via PM as a courtesy) AND in a more brief fashion also PUBLICLY, specifically for public info reasons and for whatever deterrent value that it might have. Of course, a mod is not obligated to explain every act of moderation... in some cases keeping the lowest possible profile seems best... it's a case-by-case thing based on individual judgement. In my case, I generally choose to explain (some folks probably feel I explain too much)... other mods may feel otherwise at other times.

Once again, the 1-1-1-1 rule works like this:

1 image attachment PER user PER thread PER day (24 hour period). Yes, users can post more than 1 attachment per day if they're posting 1 each in multiple threads, but that DOESN'T mean that a user can start 5 threads on the same topic just to be able to post 5 pix at once.... that kind of workaround invites deletion... the intent of this rule is pretty clear it seems to me... presently, mods MAY provide exceptions to enforcement of the 1-1-1-1 rule as mentioned above: for content creators owning the copyright to what they post... and there may be other exceptions which will be considered on a case by case basis with nothing but the continued well-being of this site and comunity in mind. IF and WHEN the 1-1-1-1 rule exceptions are written in stone, you can be sure that clarification will be added to the rule thread.

Again, the rule thread is HERE: http://forum.bearchive.com/showflat.php?Cat=&Board=UBB1&Number=165591&page=0&view=collapsed&sb=5&o=&fpart=1

*

gOOber

  • Pic-O-Matic
  • 25236
Re: Flesh_Demon's continued intentional site policy violations...
« Reply #13 on: February 09, 2004, 11:58:34 PM »
   It looks like we need to be more careful with images, everybody. I have seen the weapons the moderators use. It isn`t pretty.  

     
....rejoicing in the fullness thereof....

*

Highlander

  • G Cup
  • 729
Re: Flesh_Demon's continued intentional site policy violations...
« Reply #14 on: February 10, 2004, 12:40:07 AM »
I thak Palomine for clarifying A LOT of what's been going on... I must confess that, even tho I read the rules before even signing in, some were somewhat "obscure"... now, it's much better...

As for me, I'll try my best not to break the rules, and if I eventually do, I appologize, since I dont want this site to have any troubles...
............../.....................The Highlander
............./
O[\\\\\\(O):::<=================================-
.............\
..............\................"There can be only one"