</font><blockquote><font class="small">Quote:</font><hr />
My advice would be not to have "gripe sessions" in the first place. Why are they worth the trouble?
<hr /></blockquote><font class="post">
I don't know... letting people like me blow off steam without wrecking someone else's work (even if the part I'm annoyed it is someone <i>else</i> wrecking the work) seems like a pretty good reason to me. I realize I'm not offering constructive criticism here... I even said, up-front, that I was griping about it. The most constructive criticism I could <i>give</i> to that author is, "read the whole thread, not just the previous chapter." In the case in point, the thread isn't even that long - only 4 chapters, I believe.
</font><blockquote><font class="small">Quote:</font><hr />
Remember, the other authors are your <i>collaborators</i>. The addventure only works if the authors want to write a good story, not if they want to make the other authors look bad.
<hr /></blockquote><font class="post">
But there are some authors who don't <i>care</i> about writing a good story, as long as they can stick their fetish of choice into it. And some are just as happy wrecking the story altogether (I've seen several instances where a episode had <i>absolutely no relation</i> to the parent episode, with completely different characters - and I'm not talking about "Magic Reset" episodes, where the reset is clearly stated).
</font><blockquote><font class="small">Quote:</font><hr />
If you've got to get your frustrations with your collaborators off your chest, please find some other way to do it than by arguing with them in public.
<hr /></blockquote><font class="post">
And I'm pretty sure you're aware that most of the people who have contributed to the BEAddVenture no longer participate, and/or are completely unaware of the Plume. Besides that, the BEAddVenture rules even suggest coming here for that:
<i><b>4. No flame wars.</b> Avoid using the Addventure to "write" to other authors. That's what the Plume Forum is for. Especially no flaming of previous authors. Don't like what they wrote? Then either don't follow its links, or write a branch from it that goes in a direction you want to go. Do NOT write text in your episode about how dumb a previous author was, or how they ignored part of a story, or what-have-you.</i>
So that's what I'm doing, exactly as requested by the admins.
</font><blockquote><font class="small">Quote:</font><hr />
I'm not personally going to follow up on any of those branches, but I could imagine any number of opening sentences that would start a more interesting story than, "The place gets raided on her first day on the job."
<hr /></blockquote><font class="post">
I didn't say that I'd use that as an <i>opening sentence.</i> That would be shallow and meaningless. I'd be strongly tempted to use that as the theme for the chapter though, if I even wrote one at all.
As for your suggestions:
<ul type="square"><li>I'm not familiar with the "Mr. Black" character that you use in several of your examples. I've seen a few episodes that referenced him (Usually in connection with Sharon), but I don't have enough of a grasp on the character to think about using him in an <i>unrelated</i> thread. I gather that he's a pretty stereotypical villain, though.
Mod edit to remove references to a m1nor. No content involving m1nors is allowed anywhere at the BEA including the Plume forum or Addventure itself. If anyone sees some, they should PM a forum mod IMMEDIATELY so it can be removed. Thank you. -Palomine
</ul>
I could even run with the "porn actress" theme, since it <i>is</i> stated that she's horny and ready to be fucked... nothing in the thread up until then suggests that it has to be a <i>legitimate</i> porn studio. But the others (strip club, sex shop, lesbian bar) are too stationary, by necessity, to be able to pull off an "underground illicit" routine.
Heck, I might do that (the porn actress thread) tonight. =^_^=
When I'm writing for a collaborative work like this, I'll take enough care to maintain the characters' personalities as they've developed <i>in that thread.</i> In a story/game like this, the "Jim" from one thread can be an overweight loser science nerd, while a different thread portrays him as a somewhat-competent guy with a girlfriend. That's part of the whole <i>concept</i> of the AddVenture (At least, I <i>think</i> it is, unless I've missed something somewhere...). That's why there's no coherent "Guide to Jim." Right from the beginning, he fragments into completely different characters.
I'm willing to be respectful with other writers' work when they're respectful of the people who wrote before <i>them,</i> but people who don't even bother to go back <i>two chapters</i> for more insight into the characters - or, even worse, <i>completely</i> disregard anything that might be going on in the current thread - don't deserve a polite little note.
Note, however, that there are exceptions:
1.) Sometimes, a story thread devolves so badly that it <i>needs</i> to be, "laid to rest," and restarted.
2.) Sometimes the choices offered at the end of a chapter <i>should</i> include a few options that are out of character for the people involved, just to shake things up a little and put a new spin, and a different direction, on the story.
Maybe I'm not as friendly as you might like. But I'm not an utter bastard with a stick up his ass, either... I realize that total order is just as bad for this sort of thing as total chaos. The best line is somewhere in the middle. And I realize that most of my posts so far have been complaints... but that's because I can see <i>how fuckin' good this thing could be!</i>
I've read some of the other posts, discussing either a restart, or a second BE collaborative story-thing (whether it be based on the AddVenture or some other similar program). I think it's a good idea. Personally, I'd vote to leave the existing BEAddVenture intact and still working - there's some good shit in there, after all, and some ripe threads waiting for someone to develop them - alongside the new one. And I think that most of the suggestions made (adding new choices after the fact, allowing for author editing with limits, and so on) are good ideas. The only idea I <i>don't</i> agree with is the "Comments" section on each chapter. In places that I've seen things like that implemented, they often turn into rolling flamefests, even when useful commentary is offered.
If the majority of the regulars (or even a single Admin) wants me to shut the hell up, I'll do that. But I think that I can be a valuable voice here. I just ask for the ability to vent about some of the idiocies in the storyline where someone might care, or even have a clue as to what I'm talking about.
Nekojin =^_^=