Based on some math off the top of my head, our hypothetical entertainer who pulls down $500 a shot is still making over 200K a year. Not too shabby IMHO.
Your points are well taken – however I like to avoid discussions of how someone with a good head on their shoulders could do better. I have met quite a few ladies in the porn/sex/adult industry – most have been pretty darn sharp. Kayla Kleevage comes to mind, she's in almost total control of her image (much like Danni Ashe).
IMHO, the choice comes down to can a person put up with the one stranger for 1 hour and pull down a guaranteed $500 or more, or does she prefer to dance on stage in front of (hopefully) 30 strangers, hoping to make half that much (appearance fees and all), or be even farther removed from her fan base and only run a website with every jerk on the internet stealing content. Some folks can deal with the "unplesantness" and some can't. Some don't see it that way and just enjoy it

More on topic, we all have to spend more $$$$ if we expect any new stars to come onto the scene. When a big bust entertainer comes to town, even if I know they don't provide private shows, I go and spend money with them. I know that I have too if I expect that type of entertainment to survive – i.e. the clubs won't have them back if there was no revenue. I make sure my friends go too.
If that same lady provides a one-on-one experience, even without sex, I'm usually setting up that time as well when they come to town or when I can travel to their area.
Also more on topic, Kayla is damn fabulous in person.