Tux, I understand completely. I have tons and tons of female friends (including my best friend) of varying closeness, and I have about two or three really close guy friends, and no others who are very far past the 'Acquaintance' mark. I really don't know what it is, except just being a 'nice guy.'
And, I never thought I'd say/type it, but Conoisseur is right, in a way. Some of his advice is a bit extreme, but there are times when you do have to sort of...this is totally not the right phrase, but 'psych yourself up'...yeah, that's real wrong. *Looking for better choice of words...* There are times when you see a girl someplace, and you've never seen her before (or never talked to her before), and there's something about her. You just have to talk to her. Maybe, once in a while, one of these girls gives you "the look." And you know yourself--you know if it's left up to meek you, you're gonna stand there and let her wander off and never see her again. I know because I've done it very recently.
So sometimes when you find yourself before one of those girls that you have to talk to, you have to make something in your mind see her as a sort of target...not that this is any kind of hunt, but sometimes it helps to think about meeting her as an objective, then quickly run through the best ways of going about it. Select one, execute, and see what happens.
I could give another tip, I don't *think* I've mentioned this before, but I don't know how much it would help. I'm an actor, so every now and again when I feel too nervous to talk to a girl, I simply pretend I'm playing a role. Now, this is very delicate and hard to explain, because while I pretend I'm playing a part, it is *NOT* the same as pretending to be someone else. That's something that never, ever gets you very far...or screws you over in the end. Long story short, I have this thing, sort of a TV show idea, I guess, that I made up a long time ago (I also write) and I occasionally add to it...one of the characters is based on myself, pretty much looks like me, acts like me...only a few personality traits and things are different. For starters, he's bolder than I am most of the time. So, every now and again when I think I'll be too afraid to do something, I use the stuff I learned in Theater class, I get into this character's head (not hard since he's practically me, I made him, and so I know him inside-out), and I do what *he* would do in the situation. I'm still working on it...sometimes I break character and afraid me comes out and I screw up, but I'm getting better at it. And, when it's done, I don't feel bad because I'm not acting like someone else.
If any of that made sense--because I'm really not sure it did--maybe you could try something like that and see where it gets you. I'm REALLY not sure what I wrote made sense.