*

salem

  • Moderator
  • 76817
Re: The New Doctor Who
« Reply #480 on: July 14, 2014, 03:52:42 AM »
I  have begun re-watching the Matt Smith era, I have a feeling that watching it in a shorter space of time will make everything seem a lot clearer!

First up we have 'The Eleventh Hour' a clever play on words introducing Matt Smith to the world in his first full adventure as the 11th Doctor.

As initial adventures go, it isn't bad. Unfortunately having to introduce a new companion AND a new Doctor in the same episode tends to detract a bit from the flow of storytelling, but as this episode was slightly longer (an hour rather than the usual 45 minutes) then I think it works out quite well, giving us a few nice scenes of the Doctor's quirkiness and his attempt at getting used to his new body. The scene where the Doctor tries to find something to eat that he likes was particularly good, showcasing not only Matt Smith's comic ability but also Caitlin Blackwood as a young Amy Pond.

We start off with the Doctor hanging from the open doors of the TARDIS as it flies erratically over London, and after a near miss with the Bell tower of Westminster Palace the TARDIS eventually crashes into a shed in the garden of young Amy Pond, who is in the middle of asking Santa's help with a crack in her wall. The Doctor, once fed, pops upstairs to examine the crack and seals it using his sonic screwdriver, but not before seeing a giant eyeball staring back at him and hearing the ominous phrase 'Prisoner Zero has escaped'.

The Doctor hears the cloister bell of the TARDIS and realises that he must stabilise the engines or his ship may blow up, promising young Amy a trip in the TARDIS once he has popped ahead a few minutes. Unfortunately, this 'few minutes' turns out to be 12 years and when the Doctor returns to Amy's garden he returns with a terrible knowledge of the escaped prisoner. Once inside Amy's house he is knocked **61** by a now adult Amy dressed in a Policewoman's uniform. After a brief exchange with the Doctor Amy realises that there is an extra room that she has forgotten about on the landing of her house, she enters the room against the Doctor's advice and gets his sonic screwdriver, which had rolled under the door, but also comes face to face with Prisoner Zero in the form of a snake like creature with sharp teeth.

When prisoner zero comes out of the room it is disguised as a man and his dog, but bizarrely, the man is the one barking. The Doctor and Amy escape after hearing a broadcast from an alien ship that states 'Prisoner Zero will vacate the human residence, or the human residence will be incinerated'. Once outside the Doctor realises that the 'human residence' is not Amy's house, but the entire planet and he has 20 minutes to save it.

All in all, not a bad debut story. Matt Smith is in fine form, and the stunningly beautiful Karen Gillan is also very good as Amy Pond. We also get our first look at Arthur Darvill as Amy's SO, Rory Williams and a nice little cameos from Annette Crosbie, Olivia Coleman and stargazer Patrick Moore.


Re: The New Doctor Who
« Reply #481 on: July 17, 2014, 02:41:45 AM »
Ooooh, a rewatch!  I've not joined in on one of those, could be fun!  :)
Though honestly, I have grave doubts that watching the 5th-7th seasons in a short timespan will do anything to improve or clarify the storylines...I'd think it'd make the flaws and plotholes more evident, as Moffat doesn't seem to be much bothered by inconsistencies and/or may have counted on the spread-out broadcasting span to help keep contradictory bits from being remembered too clearly by the audience.  Anyway, on to some thoughts of the episode:

There's very little establishing of character here, as once the Doctor timeskips over the 12 years it's pretty much all go-go-go, racing around and trying to stop the Earth from being broiled.  The bit before the timeskip is wonderful though, and being that it's not only a post-regen episode, it's also a showrunner-reboot and a promoted move to BBCAmerica (bringing in a whole new audience), so it's understandable to put an action-y adventure as the format, drawing in new viewers as they reboot the look of the show (new Doctor, Companion, TARDIS, Sonic, etc).  The Doctor's new characterization is "yes, I'm totally the Doctor, and totally all-new" yet "here's many ways in which I echo my predecessors", which is kind of all over the place, but Matt Smith's performance holds it together well enough.  Young Amelia is brave and curious, but Amy has a more fiesty-and-petulant combination, which can be entertaining but is also kind of a heavily-treaded character type/trope (especially in sitcoms, which is one of Moffat's previous showrunning experiences and may be relevant to later developments  ;) ).

And speaking of later developments...the Atraxi secure Prisoner Zero because Amy dreamt it into its true form; and Prisoner Zero only used Amy's mind/dream because it was forced to find a different form than one of those that Rory had photo'd with his phone.  Rory's pseudo-sleuthing and phone were crucial to the Doctor's plan to save the planet.  Without Rory, the Doctor would've had no way to expose Prisoner Zero to the Atraxi (the Doctor might've been able to set all counters to 0 but wouldn't have had the pics of the alternate forms).  So Rory's existence is vital to the Earth (and everyone on it, including the Doctor) not being burnt to cinders; if somehow that existence were removed or erased, the world should look radically different...  ;)

One other observation is that there's a definite start of a trend where the exact (or nearly so) amount of time for a deadline or timespan is cited.  The Doctor's timeskips are mentioned of course, but the bit that I found weird was the Doctor calculating that he had no more than 20 minutes to save the world.  I'm pretty sure that more than 20 minutes of runtime elapsed after that declaration, and that even leaves out the scene changes/edits where the Doctor is walking about town with Amy, or vehicles are being driven around to the hospital.  I don't know why there was that emphasis on the timing when it was then pretty well ignored; a simple "we haven't got much time" would work, or just make the Doctor's calculation turn out an hour or some other length of time that could plausibly cover all the action that gets skipped in between the go-go-go pacing of what's on screen.  It only bothered me a little bit here, but since there come along at least a few other instances of the Doctor citing specific timespans for reference, I figured I'd mention it at the outset.

All told, despite my picking at it, the Eleventh Hour was still a pretty fantastic way to kick off the everything-new-again 5th season.  The interaction with the Doctor and Amelia with the fish fingers and custard was clearly a memorable highlight (at least in terms of character moments), while the rest was a flurry of activity, which made for an exhilarating first outing.
be seeing you...

*

Breasts

  • P Cup
  • 3422
Re: The New Doctor Who
« Reply #482 on: August 23, 2014, 03:19:37 PM »
A good debut from the 12th Doctor. I think he'll do just fine. :)
01000010 01101001 01100111 01100111 01100101 01110010 00100000 01101001 01110011 00100000 01100010 01100101 01110100 01110100 01100101 01110010 00100001

*

Eliza D

  • A Cup
  • 2251
  • Eliza DewliDDil
    • Email
Re: The New Doctor Who
« Reply #483 on: August 23, 2014, 04:03:26 PM »
Still got about 3 hours to go here on the east coast.

Counting down the minutes!
It's all about the fantasy...
~ELIZA DewliDDil
                                        ALL PICTURES COPYRIGHT © ELIZA DEWLIDDIL

*

TheBoobGuy

  • The Definitive Article
  • 1092
Re: The New Doctor Who
« Reply #484 on: August 23, 2014, 04:08:55 PM »
I tried to avoid Hyping this too much in my head, and I am glad I did.

It was a good episode, a few shaky moment, but it happens. Lots of old references which fitted in alright without seeming too forced.
BustiBobbi and Serena_38N are all(c)TBG in addition to their respective owners.

*

toefoo

  • Sippy Cup
  • 64
Re: The New Doctor Who
« Reply #485 on: August 23, 2014, 06:47:13 PM »
If you download the hola extension for Chrome, it will make your browser think it's in the UK, then their bbc iPlayer will work. It got posted on their site about 3 hours ago.

*

salem

  • Moderator
  • 76817
Re: The New Doctor Who
« Reply #486 on: August 24, 2014, 07:03:59 AM »
A solid start for Capaldi, and we have Daleks next week. Talk about a baptism of fire! Saw it at the cinema, tickets were a bit overpriced but it was enjoyable watching it among true fans.

Re: The New Doctor Who
« Reply #487 on: August 25, 2014, 12:58:28 AM »
Capaldi was great, but I also liked the scene of Clara's interrogation, where she turned it around on the robot and demonstrated faith in the new Doctor.  It was an important character moment for her (especially since there've been so few of them previously, there'd been too much hung up on the "impossible girl" mystery).  I think the series will have a sort of haunted/grim feeling for the tone and the Doctor, which'd echo Eccleston's season somewhat...but I hope it doesn't get too bogged down in that, the general lighthearted/fun sensibility of the show was always its best feature.
be seeing you...

*

TheBoobGuy

  • The Definitive Article
  • 1092
Re: The New Doctor Who
« Reply #488 on: August 25, 2014, 03:46:43 AM »
This doctor is going to be darker. Moffat has said that.

I have a personal theory that this is actually the first Doctor again. The new regenerations that he got where the ones he had already had. It would explain why he couldn't fly the TARDIS, why he left Clara to be locked in the room, his age and a few other things. He is the first Doctor again, but with all the memories of the previous Doctors, hence his confusion and struggling to remember things.
BustiBobbi and Serena_38N are all(c)TBG in addition to their respective owners.

*

salem

  • Moderator
  • 76817
Re: The New Doctor Who
« Reply #489 on: August 26, 2014, 07:52:59 PM »
Well he is flying his TARDIS with a teacher from Coal Hill School (soon to be two teachers from Coal Hill School), just like he did in 1963. Nice sense of symmetry.

*

salem

  • Moderator
  • 76817
Re: The New Doctor Who
« Reply #490 on: August 30, 2014, 12:39:14 PM »
Episode 2: Into the Dalek


They are coming.....

*

Breasts

  • P Cup
  • 3422
Re: The New Doctor Who
« Reply #491 on: August 30, 2014, 06:06:11 PM »
That was really very good! ;D
01000010 01101001 01100111 01100111 01100101 01110010 00100000 01101001 01110011 00100000 01100010 01100101 01110100 01110100 01100101 01110010 00100001

*

rtpoe

  • Old Fart
  • 12426
Re: The New Doctor Who
« Reply #492 on: August 30, 2014, 10:48:08 PM »
Getting the obligatory Dalek episode out of the way, I see.....
rtpoe

The snapping of pitch from a burning log,
The faint scent of pine filling the room.
Flames leaping about as if it were a ballet
Performing for its audience.
The soft, comforting glow of candlelight,
Bringing with it serenity and quiet thoughts.

Linda Christensen, Autumn's Beauty

*

salem

  • Moderator
  • 76817
Re: The New Doctor Who
« Reply #493 on: August 31, 2014, 01:45:17 AM »
It's good when a new Doctor faces the Daleks early, you get to see what they are really made of. Again (coincidence) the original Doctor faced off against the Daleks in his second adventure too....

Re: The New Doctor Who
« Reply #494 on: September 03, 2014, 01:50:43 AM »
Maybe not so much of a coincidence...

Clara's an English teacher from Coal Hill, and the other teacher she's flirting with is a Math teacher (Barbara & Ian were History & Science).
The teacher Clara's flirting with has the last name Pink, and the soldier the Doctor rejects in the future has the last name Blue.
The first soldier that dies in the Dalek doesn't get any special notice, but the second one announces her name to the Doctor with the clear intention that she's sacrificing herself to stop the onslaught of Daleks...she ends up in "Heaven" with that strange woman.  It suggests that in the previous episode, the half-faced clockwork droid might have chosen to voluntarily throw himself out of the balloon and sacrifice himself, thereby arriving in "Heaven" as well.
Also, soldier Blue is on the verge of death at the episode's start and seems to get vaporized, only to be revealed as having arrived on the Doctor's TARDIS via the materialization trick he's used before.  It may suggest some sort of parallel with whatever's happening with the weird "Heaven" scenes and the strange "Missy" woman there.

Overall, I'm much more liking this season than the last couple.  The ongoing mystery is being built much better than just getting a picture of the glowing Crack shoved at us each episode, and there's some really good characterization for Clara (and I'm presuming Mr. Pink will be joining shortly, as he's getting some good buildup too).
be seeing you...