*

Prophet_Tenebrae

  • Breast Prophet
  • 4113
  • Prophet Of Darkness
    • FTF10 - FTF Superblog
Comic Contest 2008 - RESULTS!
« on: November 10, 2008, 06:08:51 PM »
Ok… about time I posted this up – I know at least 7 people will want to know the results of this year’s comic contest.

Overall, the quality of the entries was very good… so, as you might guess – the ranking process was not easy. Manic dropped out – due to other commitments but there were still four judges… myself included.

Right, let’s cover the entries – in no particular order…

Bill Pratt’s Three Wish War

Pretty much an epic in terms of length (and it’s just part ONE) – has a nice Genie and his master get up to the kind of hijinks you’d expect people in a Bill Pratt story to get upto.

SaburoX’s A Pirate’s Life

All female pirates… and a bunch of sexy potentially cursed artefacts? You might be surprised to find out breasts start growing.

Dan Standing’s Spritely

A nymph grants wishes to her reluctant rescuers… and surprisingly, they’re turn upon our heroines!

Laelia’s Personal Growth

A subliminal motivational CD leads to (un)expected consequences for a girl.

Clovis’s The Great Emulation

A princess is cursed to be exceptional because of her overprotective father and the women of the nation strive to emulate her, so she fits in.

Catfish’s Big Dreams

A woman finds herself having strange dreams where her co-workers transforms her.

Yuka Takeuchi Fan’s Garremont Gaiden Returns

Growing breasts do wonders for a girl’s self-confident in Garremont Gaiden

Ok… so, rankings…

GI John’s:

# 1     The Great Emulation  
# 2     Three Wish War
# 3     A Pirate’s Life  
# 4     Personal Growth  
# 5     Garremont Gaiden Returns
# 6     Big Dreams  
# 7     Spritely    

Ryohji’s:

#1    The Great Emulation
#2    Spritely
#3    A Pirates’s Life Life
#4    Garremont Gaiden Returns
#5    Personal Growth
#6    Big Dreams
#7    Three Wish War

Chievous’s:

#1    A Pirate’s Life
#2    Three Wish War
#3    The Great Emulation
#4    Spritely
#5    Personal Growth
#6    Garremont Gaiden Returns
#7    Big Dreams

Prophet’s:

#1    The Great Emulation
#2    A Pirate’s Life
#3    Personal Growth
#4    Three Wish War
#5    Garremont Gaiden
#6    Big Dreams
#7    Spritely

Final Scores:

#1 The Great Emulation 6
#2 A Pirate’s Life 9
#3 Three Wish War 15
#4 Personal Growth 17
#5 Spritely 20
#6 Garremont Gaiden Returns 20
#7 Big Dreams 25

Anyways, congratulations to Clovis, SaburoX and Bill Pratt…

It seems Bill is destined to be a perennial winner... but then, there were only 7 entries. Still commiserations to the losers and the best of luck next year... and of course, thanks to GI John, Ryohji and Miss Chievous for their time... which is rewarded only by my thanks and gratitude...

*

G_I_John

  • Oh My God Cup
  • 6884
    • gijohn.deviantart.com/
Re: Comic Contest 2008 - RESULTS!
« Reply #1 on: November 10, 2008, 06:39:06 PM »
What?, no guest appearance?, come onnnnn, it'll be fun

Fine fine, congrats to the winners from me as well... I look forward to shiny new comics someday
What's better than one woman having really large implants?... a forum full of them ^_^

*

Laelia

  • D Cup
  • 217
Re: Comic Contest 2008 - RESULTS!
« Reply #2 on: November 10, 2008, 08:15:01 PM »
Just out of the money...sigh. So...which ones will the Club be using?

*

Catfish

Re: Comic Contest 2008 - RESULTS!
« Reply #3 on: November 10, 2008, 10:10:45 PM »
Quote:

Laelia said:So...which ones will the Club be using?




Not mine, I have to assume.  I may rework it as a short story one of these days.

*

BillPratt

  • E Cup
  • 325
    • Email
Re: Comic Contest 2008 - RESULTS!
« Reply #4 on: November 11, 2008, 12:10:07 AM »
Clearly I need more amazon women and Catgirls next time. Ah well.

When are we going to draft Sutibaru to draw Educating Momoko?
Who let the walrus out?
Coo Coo Cachoo!

*

Prophet_Tenebrae

  • Breast Prophet
  • 4113
  • Prophet Of Darkness
    • FTF10 - FTF Superblog
Re: Comic Contest 2008 - RESULTS!
« Reply #5 on: November 11, 2008, 09:34:21 AM »
As I said - the standard was pretty high, so I figure that they'll all be used... if you want to rework your comic though, Catfish - feel free...

I have to say, I did like your idea Laelia... but I think we all seemed to think it could do with more than just ten pages... It should still look though.

And catgirls and Amazons would probably have improved things, Bill because the script while up to your usual high standards felt rather too "same old, same old". Which I suppose a one-noter like me shouldn't berate people for but what can I say, I'm a flaming hypocrite and not remotely apologetic about it.

I'm very glad that The Great Emulation came first - as it was definitely the most worthy... but no one should walk away feeling  they did badly.

*

Laelia

  • D Cup
  • 217
Re: Comic Contest 2008 - RESULTS!
« Reply #6 on: November 11, 2008, 06:10:52 PM »
Quote:

Prophet_Tenebrae said:I have to say, I did like your idea Laelia... but I think we all seemed to think it could do with more than just ten pages




I may have made an unwarranted assumption extrapolating from some comments by the readership about too many storylines open-ended at once. I supposed that the occasional "done-in-one-episode" story would help give you, Matt, and Gabe a bit of welcome flexibility on that score. Certainly you are correct that, e.g. by expanding the exposition of the material of page 6 and page 9, a much sexier two-episode treatment could have been presented.

*

clovis

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 10
Re: Comic Contest 2008 - RESULTS!
« Reply #7 on: November 11, 2008, 07:10:57 PM »
Wow... my thanks to the voters, I'm glad you liked my script.  Honestly, I thought this story was going to be a hard sell.  

I'm looking forward to seeing everyone else's comics when they're released.  Pirate girls sounds like an especially fun idea.  Bill Pratt- please tell me you started your epic long before the contest was announced because I was writing frantically on the last night to get my thirty page script finished.
 

Prophet, I was wondering if the scripts had been sent off to the artist yet.  If not, I'd like to take a quick look at mine.  Now that I've had another script illustrated, I would like to take some of what I've learned at apply it here (just minor tweaks and editing- also, please let me know if any details were unclear.)  

Thanks again, and I hope when the finished product is released the readers will feel it deserved to win.

Clovis

*

Catfish

Re: Comic Contest 2008 - RESULTS!
« Reply #8 on: November 12, 2008, 12:02:38 AM »
Quote:

Prophet_Tenebrae said:
As I said - the standard was pretty high, so I figure that they'll all be used... if you want to rework your comic though, Catfish - feel free...




Hey, if you think it's workable as a comic as-is, I'll keep my grubby paws off it for now.  (Wait, catfish don't have paws.  Grubby fins?)  Might be a little different once someone has to actually, you know, turn my demented scrawlings into actual pictures and dialogue balloons.

*

Prophet_Tenebrae

  • Breast Prophet
  • 4113
  • Prophet Of Darkness
    • FTF10 - FTF Superblog
Re: Comic Contest 2008 - RESULTS!
« Reply #9 on: November 16, 2008, 10:03:29 AM »
Not been sent off yet... but as I said, if anyone wants to edit them before that happens, you've got a little while... so, by all means, clovis.

*

clovis

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 10
Re: Comic Contest 2008 - RESULTS!
« Reply #10 on: November 19, 2008, 10:16:12 PM »
Great, I'll just need a few days.  Just going to edit for clarity.

clovis