*

adobeman10

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 18
I hope this isnt banning material, but I have to voice my concern.  I have been fine with the story updates coming infrequently and it has been some time since there have been 3 stories in a month.  And the quality of some of the recent stories have been subpar to say the least.  But I have kept my concerns to myself.

But when you blatently repost stories that have already been featured in Giantess club as new stories in BESTORY club, I feel you are taking advantage of your readers.  I am not a big giantess fan myself, but I subscribe to both because I like Portalcomics art and believe in supporting the club and hopefully others do the same.  But to repost a months old story that has already been featured in giantess club and advertising to Paying readers, it is wrong.

Your promise to the readers was two new stories a month.  Original stories, not ones featured elsewhere and reposted to save money.  If you cant deliver, then issue an apology to your readers and give them an extra month free of subscription.

I hope that you address this concern, because I am considering cancelling EVERY one of my subscriptions and never subscribing again if this is not addressed or simply glossed over.  I notice that you disabled the feedback for the story because I am guessing other subscribers feel like me as well.

This is not a slam, this is a criticism that I am voicing, nor should it be viewed as hate mail or anything else.

I hope You take care of your subscribers as this to me is the worst thing BESTORY club has done yet.

Thank You
Adobeman10

*

Bahamad

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 7
Re: I Feel BESTORY CLUB ripped us off this month with a reposting!
« Reply #1 on: July 18, 2010, 06:51:52 PM »
I agree with the sentiment as the posted work as being below what I'd expect, etc., and it's good to know this is duplicated material from another club.

However, on the topic of the feedback, I think it's actually a bug in the page.  The reason I say that is if I go back to previous stories and try to add a review, the button is missing (this is using Firefox 3.6.6 to view the content).  I've submitted a request to the BESC support address to take a look at the potential issue, and hopefully this will be resolved.

*

solvegas

  • ZZZ Cup
  • 83828
Re: I Feel BESTORY CLUB ripped us off this month with a reposting!
« Reply #2 on: July 18, 2010, 08:43:54 PM »
I've been a loyal supporter of the BEA for the last 9 years, paying for 8 years, and this stinks. I've seen the story in giantess and, while I liked the art and story, it doesn't belong here. Very diapointed.  >:(

*

robclassact

  • P Cup
  • 1891
    • RobClassact Writes
Re: I Feel BESTORY CLUB ripped us off this month with a reposting!
« Reply #3 on: July 18, 2010, 10:06:57 PM »
I must agree. I was pretty disappointed. This isn't original content, this is reposted content that I already have and have already paid for.

Really bad form, guys.
Website. - DeviantArt. - Twitter
Slow Growth & Mini Giantess Story Compilation Project. Check it out!

*

JH_

  • F Cup
  • 1044
Re: I Feel BESTORY CLUB ripped us off this month with a reposting!
« Reply #4 on: July 19, 2010, 04:41:21 AM »
Was the story perhaps submitted by the author to the BE Story Club without his mentioning that it had previously been published elsewhere? If so, that would have been very naughty of him. Those running the BE Story Club would (I assume) have had no way of knowing that the story had been previously published if they didn't happen themselves to be members of the Giantess Club.

I've just checked the guidelines for BE Story Club authors given by Prophet Tenebrae in another thread on this forum, and one of them says:

Q: So I can't post this story elsewhere?
A: No. Pre-existing stories may be bought if the author submits a new part of an existing story series (at 0.1 cent a word) but that's the exception rather than the rule.
« Last Edit: July 19, 2010, 04:53:31 AM by JH_ »
JH

Re: I Feel BESTORY CLUB ripped us off this month with a reposting!
« Reply #5 on: July 19, 2010, 06:09:56 AM »
Was the story perhaps submitted by the author to the BE Story Club without his mentioning that it had previously been published elsewhere? If so, that would have been very naughty of him. Those running the BE Story Club would (I assume) have had no way of knowing that the story had been previously published if they didn't happen themselves to be members of the Giantess Club.


I'm going to have to say, "I don't agree", becuase its the exact same comic right? If it is this to me smells of freeking desperation. The lack of content is not because no one is writing BE fiction... Its the Business Model, once this has been corrected then all will be good.

Till then feel free to load up a whole bunch of "Suck-IT" on your way out. 
Breasts grow - that's BE... what happens after that is irrelevant.
--Prophet Tenebrae---

*

RandomX

  • ZZZ Cup
  • 5718
    • www.overflowingforum.com
Re: I Feel BESTORY CLUB ripped us off this month with a reposting!
« Reply #6 on: July 19, 2010, 06:11:06 AM »
To play semi-devil's advocate here:

What do you expect at this point? A quick search of the forum for the BE story club proves that they don't update, they're bad at communicating and (a new post by Ten), they allow (or at least overlook) plagiarism. They aren't exactly holding a gleaming record right now.

It's tough to provide such a specific genre twice a month every month. That doesn't mean they should be doing this to their paying customers. However, with their current track record are you really THAT surprised?
100% real woman, with notarized documents and witnesses to back this claim up.

*

robclassact

  • P Cup
  • 1891
    • RobClassact Writes
Re: I Feel BESTORY CLUB ripped us off this month with a reposting!
« Reply #7 on: July 19, 2010, 10:46:42 AM »
To play semi-devil's advocate here:

What do you expect at this point? A quick search of the forum for the BE story club proves that they don't update, they're bad at communicating and (a new post by Ten), they allow (or at least overlook) plagiarism. They aren't exactly holding a gleaming record right now.

It's tough to provide such a specific genre twice a month every month. That doesn't mean they should be doing this to their paying customers. However, with their current track record are you really THAT surprised?

Definitely not surprised, but this is a new low, really. It's one thing to not update regularly but still make an effort to push out new content. Flat out pushing out recycled content? That's unacceptable.
Website. - DeviantArt. - Twitter
Slow Growth & Mini Giantess Story Compilation Project. Check it out!

*

XStorm

  • A Cup
  • 3
Re: I Feel BESTORY CLUB ripped us off this month with a reposting!
« Reply #8 on: July 19, 2010, 11:26:59 AM »
Was the story perhaps submitted by the author to the BE Story Club without his mentioning that it had previously been published elsewhere? If so, that would have been very naughty of him. Those running the BE Story Club would (I assume) have had no way of knowing that the story had been previously published if they didn't happen themselves to be members of the Giantess Club

Here's the announcement to the story this month:

"Announcements & Updates: July 17, 2010
PROGRESS
Uploaded Progress by Serric and Portal Comics. If you'd like to see more comics with involving giantess themes go ahead and check out www.giantessclub.com. "

I'd say they had a pretty good idea what was at the giantess club considering it was mentioned quite clearly in the announcement - this was just an advert for the club. Nothing but filler material.  >:(

This is truly sad.... I'd hope for my money back, but I doubt there'll even be an apology, let alone a refund. Heaven forbid we even see 2 BE stories this month!

At least I got my review in before they locked out the story....

*

Prophet_Tenebrae

  • Breast Prophet
  • 4113
  • Prophet Of Darkness
    • FTF10 - FTF Superblog
Re: I Feel BESTORY CLUB ripped us off this month with a reposting!
« Reply #9 on: July 21, 2010, 10:28:32 AM »
To play semi-devil's advocate here:

What do you expect at this point? A quick search of the forum for the BE story club proves that they don't update, they're bad at communicating and (a new post by Ten), they allow (or at least overlook) plagiarism. They aren't exactly holding a gleaming record right now.

Wait, wait, wait - what are you saying I did or didn't do?

*

adobeman10

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 18
Re: I Feel BESTORY CLUB ripped us off this month with a reposting!
« Reply #10 on: July 22, 2010, 12:36:20 AM »
Well it has been several days since they have passed this blatent rip-off to the loyal subscribers.
The fact that they even disabled the reviews, and its quite obvious they did, has only made me lose a lot of respect for the editors of these websites.
I have made a decision myself.  If they do not remedy this with an apology and at least two decent stories (Portalcomics), I will be dropping my subscription to both the Giantess Club and the BEstory club, and I will not be renewing with them again. Sure I will deprive myself of the rare gem of a good story.  And they have had some amazing stuff in the past I will say, this is why I was a loyal supporter.
But I cannot in good conciense support the actions of reposting stuff and ripping off subscribers. I cannot stomach people who take advantage of their clientale, and I will be making my voice heard and urging others to do so as well, in the form of withholding my dollar.  Its democracy, and companies that take care of their consumers thrive, others perish.  

I dont feel like paying over $20 this month for ONE new story.  Thats ridiculous, and I will not stand for it.

So editors if you are reading.  Please take note, I am probably not the last person to do this as well.  I have been a paying customer since almost the beginning; if your readers do not matter to you, then I will no longer support it.   I urge you on behalf of myself and the rest of the other supporters of Bestory club.  Please fix this.

Apologize for the reposting, and give us two New original stories this month.  And not cheap crap with B-authors, and F-artists either.  Show your subscribers you care about them and take care of their concerns and complaints.

Sincerely
Adobeman10
« Last Edit: July 22, 2010, 12:40:02 AM by adobeman10 »

*

- matt -

  • Customer Care Manager - BEA
  • 485
    • http://www.bearchive.com
Re: I Feel BESTORY CLUB ripped us off this month with a reposting!
« Reply #11 on: July 22, 2010, 12:00:38 PM »
Hi everyone, I heard about this, checked it by myself, and detected the error.

So, first accept my apologies on behalf of the sites, and second accept a compensation:

Any member who has accounts on the BEstoryclub & on the Giantessclub will get a 15-day extension to compensate this system error.

This also means that this won't happen again, as I just made very clear it was an ERROR, instead of a new policy.

To get the compensation you just need to ask for it, sending an e-mail with the subject "COMIC COMPENSATION", including all the information we need from your 2 accounts, that is:
username, password, e-mail address used to create the account, first & last name.

Thanks, and again, sorry for this inconvenience.
(¯`v´¯) Matt (¯`v´¯)
___________________
General Manager
www.bearchive.com
www.bestoryclub.com
www.giantessclub.com
__________________________
Avatar: Morphermor's (Thx M!)

*

RandomX

  • ZZZ Cup
  • 5718
    • www.overflowingforum.com
Re: I Feel BESTORY CLUB ripped us off this month with a reposting!
« Reply #12 on: July 22, 2010, 06:59:11 PM »
Wait, wait, wait - what are you saying I did or didn't do?

Oops. It should have had the word in. IN a new post by Ten. I'm not accusing you of anything besides being wronged! I just apparently fail at the English language.
100% real woman, with notarized documents and witnesses to back this claim up.

*

Angelus

  • X Cup
  • 2931
Re: I Feel BESTORY CLUB ripped us off this month with a reposting!
« Reply #13 on: July 23, 2010, 09:25:20 AM »
Oops. It should have had the word in. IN a new post by Ten. I'm not accusing you of anything besides being wronged! I just apparently fail at the English language.

The plagiarism you are referencing has to do with someone plagiarizing material on the BE Story Club, not the BE Story club posting plagiarized material.

Ten's post isn't that clear on the subject, and to be honest, Ten channeled Fox News in putting that up.  He basically blasted Bambi and Curvy for putting up plagiarized material, when he acts like he expects both of them to know every single frame of art that the Story Club puts up.

The blame in this falls squarely on the "artist" who ripped off Portal and took the material to a competing website and getting paid for it.


*

Prophet_Tenebrae

  • Breast Prophet
  • 4113
  • Prophet Of Darkness
    • FTF10 - FTF Superblog
Re: I Feel BESTORY CLUB ripped us off this month with a reposting!
« Reply #14 on: July 23, 2010, 06:33:00 PM »
Ten's post isn't that clear on the subject, and to be honest, Ten channeled Fox News in putting that up.  He basically blasted Bambi and Curvy for putting up plagiarized material, when he acts like he expects both of them to know every single frame of art that the Story Club puts up.

The blame in this falls squarely on the "artist" who ripped off Portal and took the material to a competing website and getting paid for it.

Yes, that's why I repeatedly said I thought the artist was at fault and said that it was not important to point fingers but RATHER that we, as a community, were aware that were people doing this.

So, clearly - we totally agree. If this is FOX, you're Beck to my O'Reilly, I guess, old chap.