*

naken

  • B Cup
  • 99
Addventure Wiki Spam
« on: September 16, 2010, 11:41:06 PM »
I see the Addventure Wiki has been under sustained attack by spammers lately. Maybe it’s worth mentioning some tactics I’ve seen used on other wikis:
  • Only allowing registered users to create new pages
  • Only allowing user registration with a CAPTCHA. And possibly also **77** them to enter a CAPTCHA along with their edits for the first few days.

*

Adama

  • G Cup
  • 1724
  • Addventure Master
Re: Addventure Wiki Spam
« Reply #1 on: September 17, 2010, 02:35:10 AM »
A fair point... I think something like that needs to be investigated.
Adama, Addventure mega-geek

*

JH_

  • F Cup
  • 1044
Re: Addventure Wiki Spam
« Reply #2 on: September 19, 2010, 02:45:47 PM »
I think either of those two things could only be implemented by the owner, ie Prophet Tenebrae. Alathough he gave Adama and myself admin status, I don't think that it's something that we are able to do.

I wonder how Wikipedia itself manages. It doesn't do either of those two things IIRC, but I've never seen a spammed page there. It may just be that if a spammer created a page from scratch there, I wouldn't be likely to ever stumble on it.

JH

*

Adama

  • G Cup
  • 1724
  • Addventure Master
Re: Addventure Wiki Spam
« Reply #3 on: September 19, 2010, 10:05:37 PM »
Since Naken's post, Prophet Tenebrae has made changes to the Wiki so that unregistered users cannot create or edit pages (point 1).

That doesn't fix the problem of auto-create users which are then used to create spam (point 2).  To quote him, "honestly, I switched off FTF10 registration because all I ever got were spammers and that had a recaptcha on it."  Sounds like CAPTCHA may not be good enough...
Adama, Addventure mega-geek

*

JH_

  • F Cup
  • 1044
Re: Addventure Wiki Spam
« Reply #4 on: September 20, 2010, 03:54:50 AM »
Since Naken's post, Prophet Tenebrae has made changes to the Wiki so that unregistered users cannot create or edit pages (point 1).

That doesn't fix the problem of auto-create users which are then used to create spam (point 2).  To quote him, "honestly, I switched off FTF10 registration because all I ever got were spammers and that had a recaptcha on it."  Sounds like CAPTCHA may not be good enough...

I'm surprised, as I'd have thought that a bot wouldn't be able to manage a CAPTCHA-protected sign-up/login. Even as a human being, I've sometimes found it far from clear what all the characters were in a CAPTCHA string.
JH

*

Adama

  • G Cup
  • 1724
  • Addventure Master
Re: Addventure Wiki Spam
« Reply #5 on: September 21, 2010, 08:25:58 PM »
Me too.  I wonder if there was a bug in his login software which let the captcha be bypassed?
Adama, Addventure mega-geek

*

Prophet_Tenebrae

  • Breast Prophet
  • 4113
  • Prophet Of Darkness
    • FTF10 - FTF Superblog
Re: Addventure Wiki Spam
« Reply #6 on: October 01, 2010, 02:48:16 AM »
I'm surprised, as I'd have thought that a bot wouldn't be able to manage a CAPTCHA-protected sign-up/login. Even as a human being, I've sometimes found it far from clear what all the characters were in a CAPTCHA string.

For some, signing up on sites and spamming endlessly is apparently a career... FTF10 had a vulnerability that led to literally THOUSANDS of users being able to register - get what you pay for - and spam links a few years back but even once that issue was resolved, I still apparently had people signing up specifically to post about Indian brides... Perhaps I'm just underestimating the love of enormous breasts, amazons and female transformation on the subcontinent? Somehow, I doubt it.

But yes, while one might make a system fool proof - to make it immune to malicious tampering is immune. More is the pity.

*

JH_

  • F Cup
  • 1044
Re: Addventure Wiki Spam
« Reply #7 on: October 01, 2010, 12:32:09 PM »
I suspect that most - though not all - of those signing up are bots. Anyway, so far - touch wood - the requirement for users to register seems to have done the trick. I haven't seen a single piece of spam since that was introduced.
JH