That logic seems a little odd -- even if payment to the creators has already been made for every existing story, the subscription fee will be going toward paying writers and artists for new content in the future. (But, of course, I do agree that if one wants to directly support a writer or artist, it's better to go to their own site to buy content there, or commission something, or even just make a PayPal contribution -- there's obviously a "middleman" involved with the BESC.)
I'll explain my logic. If there is a particular writer or artist on the BE Story Club that you like, maintaining a subscription to the club does not necessarily support that particular person, because there is no guarantee that person is ever going to submit anything new to the BE Story Club again. The only contributor who is almost certain to get some of your membership fee is Portal Comic--beyond that you're just pissing dollars into the wind and hoping management spends them wisely.
It's just my personal preference, but I like to approach sites like these the same way I would go to a grocery store--do they have what I want or not, end of story. I don't get the same rosy feeling from subscribing to them that I get when I pay a creator directly for something. Don't get me wrong, I'm a big advocate of patronizing ANY type of expansion genre site, preferably ones that are run well. The more people there are who can make money off this, the more good stuff there will be for B.E. fans to buy.
On the topic of this thread, I'm not a big fan of how the BESC is run. This forum has threads discussing their mistakes, missteps, and what appears to be an unpaid and unaccountable volunteer management structure.