*

adobeman10

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 18
BESTORY Club this month-Late and awful!
« on: March 21, 2011, 05:08:01 PM »
Okay, i appreciate the fact that I have posted my comments in the past about threatening to cancel my subscription.  Congratulations, this was the month that pushed me to do so.  It seems that the latest stories have been truly awful, both in terms of story and art.  Usually if the art was poor; at least the story was readable.  This was the perfect melding of both to create one truly awful read.

This is an unimaginative, poorly rendered story.  Heres my review, which I posted-but which will be deleted or edited to the story section of the BEStory club.  I know their ratings of stars for the stories is false as they delete any posting which has an unfavorable review-even if it was thought out.

Its hard to post a review of this story as there is very little story and jut a few identical poses throughout.  A poor re-hash without any humor or wry sense of self-knowing in it. 

The art is truly horrendous as it is obvious most of the pictures are done via a wordpad on computer and thus have little to no detailing or identifying marks throughout.

The story did not advance one iota from last issue, and was read in less than 30 seconds.  It took longer for it to load than it did to read.

Additionally it did not come out on the 11th as stated and was very late being posted on the 21st.  My only regret is that I cannot post lower than a .5 review.


Anyway, Congratulations.  When my subscription period is up, I will no longer be renewing it again.  I sincerely hope changes are made.
If you have Portalcomic or some other Decent artist complete the stories.  You should have them for sale individually, as it is not worth purchasing the "crap" stories to get the good ones.

*

Darien_Shields

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 13
Re: BESTORY Club this month-Late and awful!
« Reply #1 on: March 21, 2011, 06:13:55 PM »
I just wanted to apologise for my part in this. I don't have nearly as much experience writing comic scripts as I do regular stories, and I strayed pretty far from my norm with this story. Instead of something light hearted and comedic I wound up trying to write something a little darker and scarier, and I think it just came off as slow and dumb. That said, if you have any advice or constructive criticism with regards to the writing, I'd love to hear it. I doubt I'll write for the BESC again, and I might never do another comic script, but I'd still like to know where I fell short.

As to everything else... I haven't seen the actual finished comic, but if it looks anything like the first issue then ouch. You're totally justified in dumping your membership. I would have too if I had one.

Sorry again for contributing to the perfect storm of fail.

EDIT: I submitted the first 5 issues together, so, for anyone still subscribed, 2 more updates worth of this to go. Sorry D: (There won't be a 6th issue written by me, though)
« Last Edit: March 21, 2011, 06:28:58 PM by Darien_Shields »

*

adobeman10

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 18
Re: BESTORY Club this month-Late and awful!
« Reply #2 on: March 22, 2011, 12:03:26 AM »
Im sorry Man, its nothing personal.  Im sure what you wrote and what came out on the page, my be very different.

If I had to offer my constructive criticism.  And please take it as that.  I was a writer for years and I when i first started, I took many complaints personally.  When these people didnt know me by name, they just knew my work.

1. Pacing of the story.  Honestly way too slow.  I kept waiting for something to happen.  Some growth, anything.  It just seemed to be what could be put on one page with dialogue spread out over twelve pages.
2. the content.  I see where you were going with it.  the problem is, its been done before.  Sad to say, Ive read soooo many breast expansion zombie stories.  So unless its unique or has some twist or some wry persepctive.  Its been done to death, and each copy pales in comparison to the original.  Its part of the, you may have done it a little better-but it pales in comparison because someone else done it first-tragic happenstance that many stories and movies fall prey to.
3. The art.  Now you obviously have had nothing to do with it.  But in the visual comic-medium.  A bad story can be saved by great art.  A great story will be destroyed by bad art.  Its unfair, but its true.  Some of Jim Lee's comic stories have suffered, but because of the great art, he redeemed it.  Now Mark Waid is an amazing writer, but some of his stories have been murdered by horrible artists.  So there is nothing you can do, when the art is done by a 5th grader.  If you were the artist, I would have some choice words for you, as the effort just isnt there.  From the poor "swiped" stances.  And what I mean by "swiped" is certain poses have obviously been stolen from other profesional comics.  And the artist either traced or poorly tried to replicate the work and pass it off as his own.  Its transparent and easily seen.

If I were to offer a few words of advice.  1. Throw something unique or a twist in, something that makes your story different.  Even if its a bad twist, its better than being bland.  2. Dont take this medium too serious, throw some humor in.  Remember to be tongue in cheek here, you arent going for a pulitzer so be a little goofy.  Again, if it doesnt work, you avoid the curse of being bland. 

Just my suggestions, you tried and if you did your best-then you have nothing to apologize for.  A good editor can repair pacing, fix mistakes and at least try to make it better.  A bad editor, and a bad artist, and you are pretty much screwed from the get go

Best of luck in the future man.  Its nothing personal for me to cancel my subscription, I vote with my wallet and I dont like it when people pass off poor material and still charge people for it.  Its bad customer service.

*

Darkstorm

  • E Cup
  • 423
    • -
Re: BESTORY Club this month-Late and awful!
« Reply #3 on: March 22, 2011, 02:37:23 AM »

Additionally it did not come out on the 11th as stated and was very late being posted on the 21st.  My only regret is that I cannot post lower than a .5 review.


Isn't this almost the third time in as many updates they've attempted to put up a blatantly false posted date (I seem to recall a memorable one for the 31st of November  ::) )
Lying by 10+ days is ridiculous - it certainly needs to be stopped immediately. It's not like it isn't being noticed!

As for leaving, it is sad to have to cancel, particularly when you are directly supporting products in our little niche. But there is no way to justify the depths to which the club has sunk. You will be joining a growing number of bitter ex-members. My only advice would be to save your hard earned money, and subscribe for one month every 6 months or so, and download the content then.

Personally, I'd prefer they switch to individual story sales too, but it's been shot down in the past.