*

Adama

  • G Cup
  • 1724
  • Addventure Master
Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #15 on: December 11, 2011, 09:47:47 PM »
Agreed, Adama.   I guess guys like you and I will just have to write our own stories and finagle some way to get them included at the BESC- or make 'em available elsewhere.
Right, if you don't care about illustration or payment then you can just write it and upload to (prohibited O).
Adama, Addventure mega-geek

*

Lightfoot

  • Wandering Artist
  • 2068
    • Pulse
Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #16 on: December 12, 2011, 03:19:36 AM »
I've only read the first chapter, and nothing since, but I knew people where unhappy with the direction of the story.  But, from another point of view, is it possible for the story to have moved in another direction suddenly?  Maybe it's just going to take more than a chapter to turn around?

There's a lot of unknowns here- Who decides what stories are produced and why?  Did/Does PortalComics decide the order of comics?  Is any story accepted as long as it doesn't include certain elements?  Do they hold more stories than they can produce for a business reason?  How many authors started long series and then faded away without finishing them?  Do they focus more on short stories because many of the long series are missing endings?  (Although most of us agree in this thread,) What kind of stories are best liked by the average BESC reader?  We might be a minority, especially if you look at the average BE text story, which generally are full of ugly, unhappy events.

It seems like for years and years almost every post here about the BESC winds up either being full of complaints (either too many/few text stories, too many/few comics, series not being completed, etc), or full of confused people trying to make sense of it's inner workings.

*

Saburo_X

  • A Cup
  • 55
Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #17 on: December 14, 2011, 07:49:33 PM »
I've only read the first chapter, and nothing since, but I knew people where unhappy with the direction of the story.  But, from another point of view, is it possible for the story to have moved in another direction suddenly?  Maybe it's just going to take more than a chapter to turn around?

There's a lot of unknowns here- Who decides what stories are produced and why?  Did/Does PortalComics decide the order of comics?  Is any story accepted as long as it doesn't include certain elements?  Do they hold more stories than they can produce for a business reason?  How many authors started long series and then faded away without finishing them?  Do they focus more on short stories because many of the long series are missing endings?  (Although most of us agree in this thread,) What kind of stories are best liked by the average BESC reader?  We might be a minority, especially if you look at the average BE text story, which generally are full of ugly, unhappy events.

It seems like for years and years almost every post here about the BESC winds up either being full of complaints (either too many/few text stories, too many/few comics, series not being completed, etc), or full of confused people trying to make sense of it's inner workings.


As far as the average BE text story goes, I'm curious if the actual math on that is accurate. And if so, if it's straightforward. All it takes is one prolific author to radically shift it one way or the other.

In the past they didn't really turn down anything, and there was a lot of miscommunication, which kind of explains how we got where we are now. I am curious as to the exact power structure though in terms of who makes what decisions. Especially since there's new management, which complicates it further.

(It does seem like Portalcomic works more for the Giantess Club now though.)

*

Lightfoot

  • Wandering Artist
  • 2068
    • Pulse
Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #18 on: December 15, 2011, 02:21:46 AM »
As far as the average BE text story goes, I'm curious if the actual math on that is accurate. And if so, if it's straightforward. All it takes is one prolific author to radically shift it one way or the other.

Maybe I overstated it, but it's very common to have unhappy BE stories.  Much more common than I would have expected.

My point was that I thought that the small amount of people posting here might not be an effective sample.

*

mariano

Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #19 on: December 19, 2011, 01:27:23 PM »
Thank you very much for the comments. We appreciate very much all the feedback because it help us to improve.

My name is Mariano and I am the marketing manager in charge of the production process and marketing of the BE Story Club and Giantess Club.

In order to void assumptions I would like to share with you some of the actions that we are taking since I entered on the company in march and our future plans:

1. Finish all the unfinished series. This particular comic "Spells R Us" was continued by Kris P. Kreme. He contacted the original author so he could get the original feeling about this story and continue as it was ment. He worked on a new chapter (part 6) which is completely original and will debut shortly. It continues the Spells R Us storyline, but with new characters.

2. I am in charge of the decisions of who writes and illustrate for our websites and I also decide the publications. If there is any feedback that you would like to share with me using the forum or the reviews available on each site, you will be very welcome.

3. We start working on the illustrations of a comic or a story if we already bought all the chapters because we do not want to have unfinished series anymore.

4. Portalcomic is still working with us, so are working several new illustrators that we hire and we are still hiring so we can offer diverse styles, as requested by many of you.

5. We intend to publish material from different authors besides of Kris P. Kreme. We are working on that.

6. We are worried about readers want so we are migrating our sites with a new technology so you can review and post your comments easily. The forum and BE Story Club are not very well to collect and analyize feedback.

7. To finish the unfinished series, we tried to contact the original authors in all cases. If we are not lucky in a reasonable time (2 weeks), we follow it up with somebody else, but the original author has always the priority.

8. We will have in mind that you don't like bimbofication and humiliation. We appreciate this particular comment.

9. We are limitating the intake of stories to avoid building up a backlog. We already have a huge backlog.

10. We want to void the editorial control. As tastes are diverse, we prefer that the community manifest what they like and what don`t so we can get back to the authors and illustrators and change the course or correct the mistakes on future releases. The community prevails for us so please, give us all the feedback that you can.

11. We published Welcome to Chastity V as requested. We hope you enjoy it.
« Last Edit: December 19, 2011, 07:33:17 PM by gonZo »

*

chaotik74

  • A Cup
  • 2
Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #20 on: December 21, 2011, 02:28:32 AM »
i have to agree with wha ti think is the prevailing opinion..the ending was more than a bit of a downer. If the girls had actively embraced thier new lives, that's one thing..but it was made pretty clear right up till the end that they had no choice..it was all under compulsion, thier bodies and mouths acting on auto pilot. I think some sort of epologue..maybe where the girls find the shop agian and get another potion that makes the boys thier changes are connected to think what they WANT them to think would be nice.   SOMETHING more than a half-hearted "oh well" form Ana and Liz still a prisoner in her own body.

Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #21 on: February 11, 2012, 02:48:16 PM »
Dark and darker...   While I understand that many people may've been disturbed by where Dream girl went, I honestly didn't expect another chapter, but, I'll take the irony on how it ended.  As far as what Mariano just mentioned, having been one of those oddball new guys that finished off a comic (Unstable Assets), it's not as easy as it sounds to take someone's creative vision and run with it, making it your own while still keeping to the original spirit of the story.  Unstable Assets and Dream Girl were both rather dark stories to begin with and I'm actually amazed how well Dream Girl turned it.  I didn't know about the back log, though this is explains much, and given the rest of my life, a welcome reprieve until I can get it settled.

Quote
6. We are worried about readers want so we are migrating our sites with a new technology so you can review and post your comments easily. The forum and BE Story Club are not very well to collect and analyize feedback.

Yeah.  I seriously cannot WAIT for this to kick in.  From an author's standpoint, I don't know if what I'm writing is something that the BE Story Club's customers, which, in turn, are sort of my customers, want out of my stories.  I cannot say enough how important feedback is from readers.  Being paid is nice, but, for me, it's hearing about what others think about the story that keeps me going.  If I know there was something people liked, I tend to incorporate it more.  It's that simple.

On that note, I'm personally looking forward to what's to come.

Fahzbehn
I allow to no one that I cannot succeed based on my own talent, effort, perseverance and by the grace of God.

*

Belle

  • B Cup
  • 296
Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #22 on: February 13, 2012, 08:36:07 AM »
Hey Mariano,

You can use any of my stories, past present or future for the BESC for FREE.  And.. the women in my stories don't become brainless bimbos.

Check me out at TOFB.

BB47/Belle

*

JH_

  • F Cup
  • 1044
Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #23 on: February 14, 2012, 12:16:29 PM »
....the women in my stories don't become brainless bimbos.

That's definitely a plus AFAIAC. I don't mind the occasional bimbo, but I do find that it can get a bit tedious that so many writers in the addventure seem to think that breast size and intelligence are inversely proportional, and that an increase in the former must lead to a decrease in the latter. IMO intelligent women are generally sexier than stupid ones. Also I'd expect the typical bimbo to have an IQ of maybe 85-90, but many writers seem to think that they are going to have an intelligence that is so low that they'd almost certainly be living in an institution for their own protection.
JH

*

Zorlond

  • G Cup
  • 1052
Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #24 on: February 14, 2012, 12:48:52 PM »
In my opinion, 'bimbo' has less to do with a woman's IQ test score, and having the knowledge/skills/will to do or be anything other than some guy's 'girl'. A true bimbo simply doesn't have the mental ability to make it on her own, and her IQ, which is likely low as you said JH, would seriously hamper her chances of making it without someone's help. This is a far rarer state than porn would have us believe, of course. : /
"Don't you dare call me irrational! You <i>know</i> that makes me <b>CRAZY!!</b>"

*

Belle

  • B Cup
  • 296
Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #25 on: February 14, 2012, 02:08:25 PM »
What is more alluring?  A woman who is intelligent, superbusty and wants you or a woman who is excruciatingly ditzy to the point of co-dependency, superbusty who wants you?

*

BillPratt

  • E Cup
  • 325
    • Email
Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #26 on: February 14, 2012, 08:33:01 PM »
What is more alluring?  A woman who is intelligent, superbusty and wants you or a woman who is excruciatingly ditzy to the point of co-dependency, superbusty who wants you?
Smart woman, hands down. Creativity is golden and it's really nice to be able to talk.
Who let the walrus out?
Coo Coo Cachoo!

*

Zorlond

  • G Cup
  • 1052
Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #27 on: February 15, 2012, 06:22:06 AM »
Smart woman, hands down. Creativity is golden and it's really nice to be able to talk.
Very agreed. Bimbos get very boring very fast, plus if a serious non-sexual situation comes up, I'd like to have a girl who'll be a great partner in handling it. (as opposed to a clingy, whimpering mess)
"Don't you dare call me irrational! You <i>know</i> that makes me <b>CRAZY!!</b>"

Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #28 on: February 15, 2012, 10:36:31 AM »
I kind of find this amusing as, of the stories I've had published, the highest rated were the ones I did with a bimbo theme.  The lowest had smart female protagonists.  I wonder why this is.
I allow to no one that I cannot succeed based on my own talent, effort, perseverance and by the grace of God.

*

Belle

  • B Cup
  • 296
Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #29 on: February 15, 2012, 11:51:32 AM »
There could be various reasons.  First, did you post it on a site?  If so, was it in the first position for a long time before another story bumped it?  Did you post it during a holiday or not?  There are different traffic times where you will get more hits and less hits depending on the time of year.

I've had more feedback from my STX series than any of my other stories combined.. however, I've also had the lowest traffic on that series than any other series.  Why?  Because of the content?  Nah.. it's because of the timing, the placement, the other stories surrounding it at the time, etc.

Another reason could be you.  You could be BETTER at writing bimbo than intelligent.

There's also different ways of writing bimbo.  There's the cute, ditzy, busty bimbo who is fun and great to be around.. And then there's the mc/slave.

Now don't get me wrong.  The MC/slave bimbo can be extremely erotic at times.  However, the feeling that I'm getting is that the BESC girls are depressing.  These aren't happy, sexy fun stories filled with girls who naturally enjoy being busty and gorgeous.. but instead girls that are being forced into it and forced into liking it..  which is why many think it has gone south.  People show up for big boobs.. not for defeatism.