*

mariano

Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« on: December 07, 2011, 12:28:56 PM »
Hi everyone!

Today we published Spells R Us - Dream Girl V as part of our promise to continue all the open series and most sucessfull comics and stories on the BE Story Club.

We hope you enjoy this release. There are more coming soon.

Mariano

Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #1 on: December 07, 2011, 01:38:53 PM »
After part IV I was hesitant to open this chapter, and I stopped halfway through this one. I really think this site should come up with some kind of warning for things like **03** or non-consensual sex the way other sites like The (prohibited O) do.

*

revofev

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 6
Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #2 on: December 08, 2011, 11:32:54 PM »
Please continue Boobpire

*

trainman

Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #3 on: December 09, 2011, 12:20:44 AM »
After part IV I was hesitant to open this chapter, and I stopped halfway through this one. I really think this site should come up with some kind of warning for things like **03** or non-consensual sex the way other sites like The (prohibited O) do.

The description on the stories list does include "...but not before one last humiliating experience as the new Liz," so it's certainly implied there.

Incidentally, I'm not currently subscribed to the BESC, and I'd given up on seeing a continuation of "Dream Girl," so this was obviously quite a surprise, and I might have even bought a subscription immediately -- except that I feel like I don't really need to read the story after it's basically entirely spelled out in that description. If it were more of a teaser rather than an entire summary of the chapter, I might have gotten more excited about it, which is of course the whole point of teasers.

*

Saburo_X

  • A Cup
  • 55
Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #4 on: December 09, 2011, 06:34:57 AM »
After part IV I was hesitant to open this chapter, and I stopped halfway through this one. I really think this site should come up with some kind of warning for things like **03** or non-consensual sex the way other sites like The (prohibited O) do.

Haven't read it myself, but yeah. Given how many negative comments I've seen about how dark that story got I'm a little surprised at the writer choice for the continuation. It fits given the previous tone, but it's not really one I'd think would really satisfy those complaints.

*

Zorlond

  • G Cup
  • 1052
Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #5 on: December 09, 2011, 06:52:39 PM »
It's also a 'Spells R Us' story... That universe isn't exactly known for happy endings... : /
"Don't you dare call me irrational! You <i>know</i> that makes me <b>CRAZY!!</b>"

*

Darien_Shields

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 13
Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #6 on: December 09, 2011, 09:19:18 PM »
I was surprised- and slightly pleased- to see that the BESC had put up another part of an old long running story. I also had a lot of trepidation. I read Dream Girl way back and the end of the last issue had struck me as absolutely horrible, I kind of have to wonder, has this new issue pulled it out of the gutter? Well, I guess not- I haven't read it, but I was given a plot summary by a friend and I was not crazy about it.

I'm a little confused; I've only ever heard negative feedback about the gruesome acts that take place in this comic, and yet it comes back with more of the same. The way I see it, there are two possibilities; the BESC doesn't know what its readers want... or more chillingly, maybe it does. Are the people who find this totally disgusting just a vocal minority? Are there still people flocking in droves to read this story because it features gang r*pe and (apparently now) inc*st? I really, really hope not.

But on the flip side, it does seem like the BESC is now listening to feedback (feedback: "Why is there no new Dream Girl?") and is willing to hand old stories over to new authors and take control away from the original authors who now have no interest. I think all things considered that's good. With that in mind I thought I might throw up the end to the story that occurred to me when I read the originals way back- no doubt I'm not the first person who thought this, but damned if I wouldn't like to see it:

The two main characters (IIRC their names are Liz and Ana) get new 'dream girl' potions made- but this time they drink each others', realising that they are just going to fall deeper and deeper into trouble being transformed by people who don't appreciate them. They both become strong and beautiful- but maybe rather busty as well- their adventure has given them both an appreciation for BE. Reality is rewritten to be less horrible and return them to something resembling their old lives, only better.

* shrug * That's my thoughts on the subject. I don't know. What would people rather see, gang r*pe and inc*st, or lesbianism? I know which I'd prefer...

EDIT: R*pe and Inc*st are censored terms on this forum. This strikes me as delightfully ironic; the contents of the comic are literally too horrible to get through the site's own language filter.



I'm not defending the story (which I haven't seen), but standards in the BEA forum don't necessarily apply to other areas of the BEA site, much less autonomous sites like the Story Club.
« Last Edit: December 10, 2011, 08:31:30 AM by gonZo »

*

Clovis_rw

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 37
    • Deviant Art
Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #7 on: December 10, 2011, 12:09:24 AM »
This topic has me wondering what the preferred style of comic story is for these sites.  Are fully conceived and scripted stories with definite endings better than open-ended scenarios that can evolve and continue based on reader response?  I enjoy well crafted plots, but I have to admit that when dealing with ten page chapters, these can often deliver some pretty disappointing installments while some of the more simplistic comics have delivered some of the best scenes and art.  Does the site actually accept open-ended scripts (I know that it did, but does it now?  Should it?) 

As far as Dream Girl is concerned, I also have not seen the latest chapter, nor did I enjoy where the previous chapters went.  I feel this stories status is owed more to the fact that it was the first Portal Comic comic, not because of the subject matter.  While it is not possible to say what the readers actually do or do not like, I agree with what Darien says about content that is not appropriate for the forum probably not being appropriate for the story club. 

*

Adama

  • G Cup
  • 1724
  • Addventure Master
Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #8 on: December 10, 2011, 01:57:53 AM »
Might as well chime in here.  I _have_ read the latest installment.

Like many, I found the previous chapter really unpleasant and a turn-off.  This new chapter isn't as bad, but it does continue the ideas of the previous chapter -- that the story is that of the degradation of the one girl in contrast to the elevation of her friend.  It's not a happy or pleasant ending, but at least it's consistent with what's happened before.  Though I admit that I too was hoping that she would be "rescued" from her fate eventually.

But it's not like Dream Girl is unique in that respect.  Quite a lot of transformation stories, including SRU stories, end badly for their victims.  I prefer happy endings myself, but it's the author's choice.

I prefer open-ended stories, or at least open-ended concepts.  I think part of the appeal of Dream Girl was the "anything can happen" type of transformation involved, not necessarily what specifically happened to these girls (though PortalComic illos helped!).  New authors could easily write their own sequels which show other characters making the same purchase at SRU, and how they might handle it differently.
Adama, Addventure mega-geek

*

Darkstorm

  • E Cup
  • 423
    • -
Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #9 on: December 11, 2011, 12:11:47 AM »
But it's not like Dream Girl is unique in that respect.  Quite a lot of transformation stories, including SRU stories, end badly for their victims.  I prefer happy endings myself, but it's the author's choice.

I'm afraid much of the new content to be published by the BE Story club will fall into this category. Kris P Kreme is a prolific writer at both the MC story archive and now the BE club (having authored 14 of the last 20 publications!); While very talented, he has a very established preference for bimbofication and humiliation.

Personally I find these very much off-putting - in my opinion, big breasts do not equate to stupidity, nor do I enjoy or need to have control over someone (at least in terms of submissive roles, rather than BE :) ). I don't see this preference in Kris P's writing likely to change anytime soon, and if he continues being the primary source of tales for the club, much of the content will reflect this preference.

I would much prefer a happier ending to the stories, one in which the women DON'T become mindless playthings.

*

Dan Standing

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 41
    • ESCarchive
Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #10 on: December 11, 2011, 08:38:46 AM »
I would much prefer a happier ending to the stories, one in which the women DON'T become mindless playthings.

My general preference as well.

*

Eyeguy

  • E Cup
  • 1034
Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #11 on: December 11, 2011, 06:25:47 PM »
Agreed, Adama.   I guess guys like you and I will just have to write our own stories and finagle some way to get them included at the BESC- or make 'em available elsewhere.
People should not fear their government, a Government should fear its people.

TANSTAAFL: There ain't no such thing as a free lunch

I am a confirmed vag-itarian.

*

Clovis_rw

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 37
    • Deviant Art
Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #12 on: December 11, 2011, 06:45:40 PM »
I guess guys like you and I will just have to write our own stories and finagle some way to get them included at the BESC- or make 'em available elsewhere.
Is the site currently in need of scripts?  It seems as if they have more than enough as the latest newsletter shows none of the remaining "Welcome to Chastity" chapters coming soon.  The site often seems to stick with single authors, currently Krip P Kreme dominates, as did Great Dragoon a few years ago.  I know they are always on the search for artists, but authors don't seem to be any problem.  This may also be the reason the site seems more focused on short stories instead of comics. 
Currently I am (slowly) putting together a script for the GiantessClub.  The story is a response to a need posted by the editor- something he felt the site was lacking.  If the BESC is finding itself tilted too heavily towards one aspect of the fetish, perhaps the editor should put a call out for specific story types to even out the selection.  Setting up a poll might be a good idea as well- asking what might be over or under represented.

 

*

Darien_Shields

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 13
Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #13 on: December 11, 2011, 07:30:54 PM »
Is the site currently in need of scripts?  It seems as if they have more than enough as the latest newsletter shows none of the remaining "Welcome to Chastity" chapters coming soon.  The site often seems to stick with single authors, currently Krip P Kreme dominates, as did Great Dragoon a few years ago.  I know they are always on the search for artists, but authors don't seem to be any problem.  This may also be the reason the site seems more focused on short stories instead of comics.  
Currently I am (slowly) putting together a script for the GiantessClub.  The story is a response to a need posted by the editor- something he felt the site was lacking.  If the BESC is finding itself tilted too heavily towards one aspect of the fetish, perhaps the editor should put a call out for specific story types to even out the selection.  Setting up a poll might be a good idea as well- asking what might be over or under represented.

Couple of things...

I think a little while ago (6 months?) there was a change in management/editor at the BESC which was for the better. The current editor (I'm not sure if that's his exact job title, but it seems appropriate) has taken much more of an active role in running and organising the BESC, keeping in touch with writers and apparently having open ears for feedback (I believe he's responsible for assigning a new writer to Dream Girl, instead of leaving it to languish in obscurity even longer).

That said, I think more could be done.

At present it seems like the BESC accepts a lot of comic scripts and story manuscripts in bulk, stacking up a huge quantity of them if someone submits a lot all at once (Great Dragon AD, Kris P Kreme). I have heard that currently they are not accepting comic scripts and possibly not accepting stories period because of a backlog, but this is the first time I've heard them implement such a strategy.

Personally, I think that the BESC should limit its intake of stories and avoid building up a backlog. Measure the turnaround on stories- say it takes 2 months to properly illustrate and format a story- then the BESC should only accept stories say six weeks in advance, and should not buy scripts that they won't be able to use for 3 or 4 months to avoid "warehousing" them. That way they leave themselves less open to the prospect of buying 10 stories from a single writer and then finding out that everyone hates his first 5 stories- but still having paid for 5 more that aren't going anywhere.

But I don't know anything about business...

Still glad to see people saying no to bimboification and bad endings for women. I really can't stand it.

EDIT: Also, I think that the BESC shouldn't be scared to exert a little editorial control on writers and say "could you put more BE in this story" or "could you take this element out because it doesn't fit in with the site". I know different writers will react differently, but I think I probably consider myself more of an 'artist' than most of the writers for the BESC, and I'd be happy if they laid down the law once in a while to establish more coherency.
« Last Edit: December 11, 2011, 07:46:43 PM by Darien_Shields »

*

Saburo_X

  • A Cup
  • 55
Re: Spells R Us - Dream Girl V published today on BE Story Club!
« Reply #14 on: December 11, 2011, 07:54:28 PM »
Is the site currently in need of scripts?  It seems as if they have more than enough as the latest newsletter shows none of the remaining "Welcome to Chastity" chapters coming soon.  The site often seems to stick with single authors, currently Krip P Kreme dominates, as did Great Dragoon a few years ago.  I know they are always on the search for artists, but authors don't seem to be any problem.  This may also be the reason the site seems more focused on short stories instead of comics. 

 

I'm flattered you're waiting for Welcome to Chastity. (And by the way, I'm a big fan of your writing for the BESC. Loved Great Emulation) but at this point it looks like we're in for more of the same for a while. It might just be sensible for people cancel, save their money, and go by the summaries to tell if and when there's enough content that's more their "speed" to justify a renewal.