Let's see, if I post awhile, maybe I'll even wind up saying something helpful, anything's possible ...
Overall nothing terribly wrong with the premise as stated. I might draw the line at the whole "must masturbate at dinner" requirement, as I see that as threatening to actually inhibit sex drive, in somewhat the same way a daily command of "tell mommy you love her" might undermine genuine love. If the whole idea is to set up scenes where you get to watch women masturbate, perhaps there are settings which might be more spontaneous and less awkward (I mean, you're handling your food, jeez).
Basically we're setting up an oasis of wide open sexuality in what I assume is our otherwise normal humdrum world. Three considerations leap to mind. One: the whole idea is to change Al's mind by immersing him. I think that all depends on what the whole story -- not just the handy word "swingers," because any swingers I can think of tend to prefer "open marriage" to actual bigamy -- is, and if there are any complications which might be deal-breakers. If the whole idea is to say "See, Al, sex is great," then there's really not much of a conversion process necessary, because OF COURSE sex is great. I need more of your cards on the table, because if there's anything on the horizon like, say, That Certain Anagram of the Word "Insect," then Al can still bolt outta there with some vindication.
Two: if this is indeed an "oasis," then the setup is fundamentally different from, say, the Polygyny Chronicles that you and I have been badmintoning for over a year now. (By my admittedly vague count, I think we've just hit 111 episodes!) Setups like this one, or your one for Polygyny, feel more accessible than others of yours because there's not quite so much highly specified minutiae a potential contributor has to agree to before signing on the proverbial dotted line. So -- can a small sexually wild community get along in something resembling our world? It would be interesting to try to handicap this in some ways. Case in point: wealth. In real life, Hugh Hefner has been free to do whatever the hell he wants, and in our Polygyny tale we have Beth and the handy Atwater estate. (I may as well finally tell you: I chose the name Atwater because it has "twat" in it, hawr hawr.) So, a rich family might be one go-to excuse. However, could you do without that? In fact, could these be lower-class folk driving well-to-do hoity-toity types crazy with all the fun they're having? Another consideration is power, which is not always wealth. These might be a "black sheep" branch of a dynasty that has always run a small town. There are all kinds of ways to anticipate easing them into the larger society.
Three: what I've liked about Polygyny is that it handily incorporates a basic law of porn -- that is, if the people are hot enough, who's honestly going to stop them? We started with your "extremely virile" Adam and I gave him the vague label "too-male," which I think sums up one hell of a lot of what we look for in porn in general. (This has of course begged the question of the existence of "too-females," but to my mind we already have those and their frontiers lie more in their embracing their sluttiness rather than their becoming any more beautiful -- I mean, so far as I can see, if she wasn't into Brad, Angelina Jolie could have truckloads of men dumped on her doorstep every day.) So an immediate consideration is the hotness of this group. It would in one sense be brave to not care so much about that, to allow characters to resemble the rather sallow people found throughout the 3-D comics of Crazy XXX World -- but I don't know if I'm that brave. So that's got to be considered. Something genetic is going on with the too-males of Polygyny -- might there be something genetic here as well? I remember a old dumb soap opera of a book called "The Mallen Streak," in which generations of Mallen men had a streak of white in their dark hair like a kind of curse, and they all engaged in scandalous behavior.
Wealth, power, hotness, DNA -- these details will at least need to get thought about, along with the whole issue of how far afield you're looking to veer in terms of taboo behavior, into anagram-of-insect or anything like that. It may also be advisable to cheat a little. I can understand and appreciate if you want to keep this utterly realistic, that could be interesting -- but, eh, a touch of ESP and/or a dash of magic, those might not hurt, just sayin'.
I suppose where I wind up is: how serious are you about this being some sort of wrenching choice for Al? Because as it is right now I'm seeing a dilemma with only one horn, namely wild sex on one side and a whole lotta nothin' on the other. Perhaps the stakes need to be raised, perhaps there is some particular price -- possibly as simple as "ordinary" people looking at Al kind of funny -- to be paid for indulging in this. This might make an interesting critique on the whole concept of love: Al holds out for this thing called love, but the world at large gives him no support and keeps puncturing that dream. As far as narrative goes, it might be interesting to see this as just one facet of an ever unfolding network. There may be a whole "underworld" of groups like this, but it takes until Al hits 18 before he begins to start uncovering the full story, first of his own group and then of others -- and there, you see, a kind of grand quest might be set in motion.
So I'll be interested to see how this develops -- and if there are any ideas to be knocked around concerning too-females, I may be interested in those as well.