Let me try to be a little more eloquent than that...
I'm using this possible change (and today's news about the upcoming shutdown of Google Reader) to remind myself that I don't own the websites I use, even the ones for which I've created content; they're always subject to switch to paying-member-only, or be taken down temporarily, or disappear forever, without even an explanation.
That said, if it is the case that the Addventure is going members-only, it certainly seems a bit, well, arbitrary and capricious to make that switch now, after almost 15 years. I can definitely understand why the BEA ownership/management might want to make the change, hoping that some significant fraction of the regular Addventure contributors could be persuaded to pony up for membership, or even drawing in new members with the promise of being able to read the existing almost-15-years' worth of content that hits not only BE, but pretty much every possible other fetish.
However, it seems to me the better way to handle it -- and I know this has been suggested before -- would be to merely make some of the Addventure's advanced features members-only; that is, either existing features (such as the tree view or the chain view) or new features (things like an Addventure search engine, or the ability to add new choices to existing episodes). Something like that would keep most if not all of the existing contributors on board providing the all-important new content, while still providing decent added value to drive membership sign-ups.