*

Lightfoot

  • Wandering Artist
  • 2068
    • Pulse
Story Likes and Dislikes
« on: May 06, 2013, 12:13:39 AM »
I can't remember a thread like this here before.  I suspect that most people write stories for themselves, but just for fun maybe, what are the kinds of things you like and dislike in stories- comics or written maybe?  I often see stories where parts of it I like, and also ones where I like what's happening, and then suddenly it takes a turn I'm unhappy about.

This isn't meant as an attack at anyone.  It's meant as a survey, and not everyone has to agree.  It's also not meant to convince all writers to obey the majority opinion.  BUT maybe it could serve as a guide if someone was curious about the general consensus about things.

  • I don't like unhappy stories.  I like everyone to be at worst neutral about whatever is happening.
  • I don't really like revenge stories (which is different from a competition story).
  • I like happy endings.  Whatever at the end makes the characters happy.
  • I don't like "bimbo" stories, where the woman becomes stupid and is focused only on sex.
  • I don't like transgender stories.
  • I don't like multiple breasts.
  • I like short women, so it always bothers me when everyone becomes tall in a story, or when the short character(s) become tall.
  • I'd prefer stories with as few other fetishes as possible.
  • It doesn't bother me if the stories include sex or not.
  • I like variety in the characters and settings.  People from unusual places are always nice (especially Asian women).
  • There's a size limit somewhere, but I'm not sure what.  I think it has to seem somehow possible.
  • I think there's some balance between something that's three paragraphs, and something that is a novel, but I'm not sure what exactly.

*

JH_

  • F Cup
  • 1044
Re: Story Likes and Dislikes
« Reply #1 on: May 06, 2013, 04:48:14 AM »
Many of my likes and dislikes are the same as yours, though with a few pronounced differences:

• I like my central characters to be given a difficult time, which means that there is often unhappiness in the story. However I like my characters to keep fighting rather than to give up, so they are bloodied but unbowed if you like.
• I'm not usually keen on revenge stories either, especially as the revenge often seems to be wildly disproportional to the original offence. It often seems to descend into bullying.
• I too like happy endings, though the open-ended nature of most addventure story-lines means that a conclusion is often never reached.
• I'm not very keen on bimbo stories either, and especially the assumption that many writers seem to make that if a woman's breasts grow then she will automatically become stupider. Also many writers don't seem to distinguish between bimbodom and severe mental retardation. A woman with an IQ of 90 might be a bimbo, but a woman with an IQ of 60 ought to be in care for her own protection. I find intelligent women sexier than stupid women. Do some of the writers who like writing women as bimbos find intelligent women  threatening IRL (I'm sure it doesn't apply to all such writers)?
• I don't mind male into female transgender stories, but I'm not keen on the reverse.
• I have a number of other fetishes besides BE, in particular pregnancy, which I tend to introduce into stories given the slightest excuse. :) I also like stories with bondage, whichdon't crop up as often as one might expect.
• Like you, it doesn't bother me if the stories include sex or not. And I can't write a convincing sex scene myself.
• Like you, I like variety in the characters and settings.
• I agree that there's a size limit somewhere, whatever fetish we are talking about.  I have to be able to suspend my disbelief.
• I agree that stories - and especially addventure episodes - shouldn't be too long. Rather than write an enormous episode it's better to break it into several. At the other extreme, an episode that exists only to present a "shopping list" of one word options is very annoying. A very short episode can work if the options are imaginative and substantial, however.
• I like humour, although of course there are some stories where much in the way of humour wouldn't be appropriate.
• I don't know why, but I like stories written from the "victim's" (usually the main female character) POV.
« Last Edit: May 06, 2013, 06:02:43 AM by JH_ »
JH

*

TJ Hunter

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 25
Re: Story Likes and Dislikes
« Reply #2 on: May 09, 2013, 04:20:34 AM »
As a new writer to the BE site, this thread is exactly what I was looking for and wanted to read!  A mega thanks to Lightfoot and JH_ for posting these lists... it's greatly appreciated.

I've submitted a few comic scripts to the editors and I know that two were approved.  Looking at your lists...

  • I'm not doing revenge stories.  Also my tales have high stakes, but tend to be lighthearted.
  • Most of my stories are from the heroine's point of view.  I also like smart girls, not stupid ones (which you can tell by the brainiac lead character Brooke in the already published Beelzebabe series).
  • I'm relieved that sex in every issue is not a necessity.  I try to make sure there is at least nudity in each issue and usually first issues only have masturbation in it.  But good sex scenes do pop up in the series (it is tough to do full stories in issues of only 10 pages!).
  • I am a huge fan in variety of characters and settings.  Many different hair colors, races, body types, etc. - I love them all and that will hopefully be represented well in my BE stories.

Hopefully the finished comics from my scripts will start popping up on the site in a few months.  I hope you guys and gals enjoy the stories.

P.S. If anyone else wants to share a list of what they like, dislike, and look for in BE comics I would love to see your thoughts!
BE Club writer of Bee Stings and Milk Blasters & other comics including Beelzebabe, Sexual Tension, & Vela.

*

DruulEmpire

  • Freakin' Huge!
  • 12880
Re: Story Likes and Dislikes
« Reply #3 on: May 09, 2013, 06:23:13 AM »
TJ: Welcome to the asylum! 8)

Lightfoot: My final contribution to the TPC thread -- The Polygyny Chronicles -- was a triple wedding.  I suppose you don't get a more Shakespearean-classic happy ending than that.

(It was rather non-Shakespearean in being named "Three Weddings and a Blowjob.")

JH_: CONVINCING sex scenes!?  In the Addventure!?  I daresay you could get away with just about any attempt. ;)
« Last Edit: May 09, 2013, 06:24:58 AM by DruulEmpire »

Re: Story Likes and Dislikes
« Reply #4 on: May 16, 2013, 12:37:28 PM »
With the exception of bimbofication, which I'm 50/50 on (it helps if it's done to a character that deserves it), I'm pretty much spot on with the lists above.  I think and hope that any, if not all, of my upcoming "Guaranteed as Advertised" comics will be to your liking.
I allow to no one that I cannot succeed based on my own talent, effort, perseverance and by the grace of God.

*

  • E Cup
  • 326
    • http://www.flyingrabbits.tv/
Re: Story Likes and Dislikes
« Reply #5 on: July 09, 2013, 11:40:38 AM »
Interesting thread & thanks to earlier contributors.

For me (In no particular order):-

Likes

Happy endings
Variety in persons & locations
Breastsmothering
Measuring & statistics
Slow growth (Weeks +)
Breasts being used as cup holders, distractions & implements of persuasion
Teasing
Milking
Sequels (To get to know characters better)
Light heartedness / comedy (Even some silliness!)
Tall women (But not a must by any means)
Some 'superpowers' (Including some things like 'super' lactation as well as some of the more 'traditional' ones)


Dislikes

Unhappy stories (Agreed. Characters should be at least neutral about events)
Transgender
Multiple breasts (ie more than two)
Fast growth (Hours)
Bondage (Other than in roleplay) & anything involving pain
Very short stories (Don't ask me to quantify that!)


Neutral / Other

Revenge stories (OK if they don't go too far...)
Bimbo stories (So long as they stay neutral - or, preferably, happy they're OK)
Height (To a point. Not much below 5')
Other fetishes (Depends on what they are I suppose...)
I feel surprised at myself saying it but, yes, the sex can be optional
Yes, I suppose there is a size limit but its difficult to quantify (Certainly bigger than anyone has ever been)
Difficult time (But prefer a win through at the end)
Pregnancy (OK if not too dominant a theme)
I am Albert Brennerman.



http://www.flyingrabbits.tv

Re: Story Likes and Dislikes
« Reply #6 on: July 19, 2013, 04:36:22 PM »
I like this thread very much.
I myself often find it most irritating that once I started to like an Adventure storyline, they often eventually are destroyed by (dislikes):
  • transgender events
  • multiple breasts >2
  • totally illogical events, not having to do with the previous story, alt. chosen continuation link
  • To short posts, i.e. one sentence or less than a full paragraph
  • "shopping list" choices
  • characters that turn into animals or dead objects
  • over all length/size growth (giant/giantess)
  • instant/explosive and/or to big at a time growth
  • lack of understanding bra/bust sizing. Please check Wikipedia first

Instead, I like the stories to
  • evolve over several posts, perhaps being long as normal stories in the end
  • have a "something else" option
  • involve both breast and dick growth
  • have growth size that is somewhat reasonable. Think world record x2, ore something similar
  • have slower growth speed, e.g. over the course of weeks, months or years. Have yet not seen a neverending, really slow (like "natural-like" "puberty speed".


The use of "alternative timelines", i.e. where, trough the use of magic, the rest of the world doesn't react to the change event, is quite interesting, and have been used with good results in some BESC stories. I'd like to see more of this in future stories. Perhaps mostly in the comics.

I also like the use of characters with power, or misusing power. A good story should have both a protagonist and an antagonist.

These lists (where applicable) also goes with BESC stories.

*

MisterL

  • B Cup
  • 72
Re: Story Likes and Dislikes
« Reply #7 on: July 20, 2013, 11:09:22 AM »
I like

-slow grow (hours, days, months or also years)
-sizes from like Beshine to sizes of houses, maybe stadion size.
-hair grow (down to knees)
-happyendings (girl likes her new life)
-mind changing (from horror cause of the grow to like to be big)
-how the girl have to change her daylife for her bigger tits
-grow out of her clothes (more or less)
-a little bit off hip/ass grow (only to Jlo-size)
-waist shrink (to an realistic size maybe 20 inch)
-size grow in high but onla a little maybe max to 7 feet (cause of longer legs e.g.)
-slight lip grow
-nipple grow big, huge, freaky
-pussy grow big, huge, freaky
-penis and/or testis grow big, huge, freaky, immobile (for the malepart in the story)
-muscle grow big, huge, freaky, immobile (both parts male and female)
-older becomes younger
-sex m/f m/f/f or f/f
-size competition
-size envy
-it would be nice to read about the reason that causes the grow
-plastic sugery
-lactation

i could accept

-pregnancy
-fast grow (minutes)
-filling by water or other fluids
-futanari
-no happyend
-transgender (only male to female)


i dislike

-no legal age
-earth size or more
-fat (only if the bad person from the story get his/her punishment)
-multiple (breast, arms, legs, etc)
-sm
-dead
-aliens (except if they causes the grow)
-tentacles
-filling with air or helium
-animals or antro (transform from/to or sex with)
-gigantess
-makro


I think it´s all, sorry for my english, it´s not my main language... ;)

« Last Edit: July 20, 2013, 11:40:04 AM by MisterL »

*

TJ Hunter

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 25
Re: Story Likes and Dislikes
« Reply #8 on: July 24, 2013, 03:40:00 PM »
Very interesting lists!  I am seeing a lot of themes, patterns, and similarities in your lists.  This is very helpful for when I begin my next stories.  For now two of my comics have their first chapters/issues added to the site.  I think you guys will enjoy Bee Stings and Milk Blasters.  Plus more comics are on the way!  Any comments you have for these stories would also be helpful!
BE Club writer of Bee Stings and Milk Blasters & other comics including Beelzebabe, Sexual Tension, & Vela.

*

ThatMan

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 19
Re: Story Likes and Dislikes
« Reply #9 on: July 25, 2013, 08:54:50 AM »
As a reader, my main interest is male-to-female sex-change that isn't based on the limitations of reality. I make a distinction between sex-change and transgender, because the latter suggests that they want to be the opposite sex, whereas the former could happen to anyone. I like it that way for the potential character development and fish out of water elements. If a story has an appreciable amount of that, I'll read anything that doesn't insult my intelligence, relieve me of my suspension of disbelief, doesn't become too cliche, and isn't too focused on getting someone's rocks off.

Basically, I don't have many kinks, but if used well enough in a given scenario I can certainly enjoy a great many things.

As a writer, it's a bit different. While I still have that one preference, I'm a bit more flexible because I try to take other writers and readers into account, if I happen to be writing in a place like this. It can present a bit of a challenge, and sometimes I feel the need to be challenged, but I figure that I shouldn't think only of myself in a public venue, and that I should try to make some effort to go beyond my zone of comfort and interest every now and again for the sake of others.

*

Djoser

  • X Cup
  • 8329
Re: Story Likes and Dislikes
« Reply #10 on: July 25, 2013, 06:30:58 PM »
Great thread idea!

So this is for my particular interests (sorry, copy paste from brianm's post, with some changes lol)

Likes

Implants! (for two reasons: growth feels more real and the perky gravity defying shape is awesome IMO)
CompeTITion and size envy (when characters try to outgrow each other's bustlines)
Sociopolitic status = breast size
Happy endings
Variety in persons & locations
Breastsmothering
Measuring & statistics (I love it, so much, numbers are so hot)
Slow growth (days and above, although for implants minutes as long as the skin holds) I like faster growth too but i prefer it slower, feels way more real
Breasts being used as cup holders, distractions & implements of persuasion
Teasing
Milking
Sequels
Light heartedness / comedy (Even some silliness!)
Tall women
Girl on girl sex
I like absurd ginormic sizes
Mary Sue girl characters that get bigger boobs
Trait absorbtion (like stealing bustsize)

Dislikes

Explicit sex when a male is involved (implicit sex, i can resist it)
Non consensual
When thgirl is unhappy most of the story (as way too much hentai out there)
Transgender
Multiple breasts (ie more than two)
Bondage & anything involving pain
Very short stories
Breasts that stay less than 20 000 ccs in volume (this applies for natural and artificially enhanced breasts. If i wanted reallistic sized breasts i'd stick with reality!)
Weight gain in any part besides the breasts
Cuckolding
Incorrect stats/measurements (it kills my mood when someone says a girl is slim but has a 300 zzz bra,because that belongs to an incredibly obese woman, you can instead say the bustline and then the bra size, )

If i haven't included a topic in the list it is either because i am neutral (as is growth method, giantess or others) or because i ignore its existence.


MisterL i have a question, are you German? your tastes seem german lol
« Last Edit: July 25, 2013, 06:42:12 PM by Djoser »
Welcome to the internet, where men are men, women are men, and childr3n are the FBI

If it hurts, it means that you're still living

Avatar: beshine, morphed by uutexray, avatarized by AgentDee

*

MisterL

  • B Cup
  • 72
Re: Story Likes and Dislikes
« Reply #11 on: July 25, 2013, 11:12:59 PM »
Quote
MisterL i have a question, are you German?

Yes. I´m sorry, but i didn´t choose it...  ;D

*

TJ Hunter

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 25
Re: Story Likes and Dislikes
« Reply #12 on: July 26, 2013, 11:27:32 AM »
A lot of these seem obvious or automatically go into my line of thinking concerning BE stories.

I am surprised that many people don't like multiple breasts.  It's not one of my usual kinks, but it's fun for a story or two (like an upcoming Beelzebabe story on a different site).  Is there any reason multiple breasts aren't desired as a usual thing?  No judgement, I am just curious.
BE Club writer of Bee Stings and Milk Blasters & other comics including Beelzebabe, Sexual Tension, & Vela.

*

BillPratt

  • E Cup
  • 325
    • Email
Re: Story Likes and Dislikes
« Reply #13 on: July 26, 2013, 09:39:12 PM »
I have to say I like multiple breasts, too. One boob just looks weird on a woman.
Who let the walrus out?
Coo Coo Cachoo!

*

Djoser

  • X Cup
  • 8329
Re: Story Likes and Dislikes
« Reply #14 on: July 29, 2013, 01:34:05 AM »
A lot of these seem obvious or automatically go into my line of thinking concerning BE stories.

I am surprised that many people don't like multiple breasts.  It's not one of my usual kinks, but it's fun for a story or two (like an upcoming Beelzebabe story on a different site).  Is there any reason multiple breasts aren't desired as a usual thing?  No judgement, I am just curious.

I think that if most humans liked multiple breasts maybe humans would have more than two...maybe lol


Yes. I´m sorry, but i didn´t choose it...  ;D

Lol I'll be honest, most germans I know have a good taste for beer and women lol
Welcome to the internet, where men are men, women are men, and childr3n are the FBI

If it hurts, it means that you're still living

Avatar: beshine, morphed by uutexray, avatarized by AgentDee