*

maybeenuf4u

  • E Cup
  • 294
    • n/a
Re: What a Bitch
« Reply #30 on: September 14, 2003, 08:39:50 PM »
F-ing women huh? As Al Bundy said, "Women, you can't live with em, you can't shoot em."  

*

GizmoWidget

  • P Cup
  • 1577
Re: What a Bitch
« Reply #31 on: September 14, 2003, 08:53:50 PM »
Quote:

F-ing women huh? As Al Bundy said, "Women, you can't live with em, you can't shoot em."    




Actually, it was Gallagher who said it first.  
Put Buck O'Neal in the Major League Baseball Hall of Fame!!!

*

Kanodin

  • Banned User
  • 1325
Re: What a Bitch
« Reply #32 on: September 15, 2003, 05:38:27 AM »
I'm suprised how many people want to peg this is as a biological issue.  Of course, that would leave me attempting to explain it another way... well, I'll try.

My choice to attempting to explain this behavior centers around human communication theory.  There's this theory, called symbolic interactionism, which has been around in the communication theory field for at least a decade.  Symbolic interactionism revolves around three core concepts:

1) Individuals construct meaning through the communication process.
2) Self-fulfilling prophecies exist at a powerful level.
3) Culture and social processes influence the behavior of people.

We've obviously suggested that clothing is a form of communication which can showcase certain parts of the body for a very suggestive message.  I think that a woman getting irked when the 'wrong man' looks at her simply shows the woman's frustration that her attempt to communicate did not live up to her expectations; she wanted her cake and to eat it too.

Second of all, I think the persistence of the claim that women are more programmed to stay with one partner than men is a social construct.  I also think that the observation that 'women pick men' is limited to western cultures.  It's a sad fact that this behavior becomes inverted in eastern cultures.  Nobody knows why, but somehow the tenets of acceptable human behavior change from place to place.  We can probably come up with hundreds of examples, but one really obvious example comes from the answer to the question, "why don't any Japanese people like to shake hands?"  Some people have undergone a societal conditioning and they now exhibit some very peculiar behaviors.    

*

E_W

  • X Cup
  • 2225
Re: What a Bitch
« Reply #33 on: September 15, 2003, 06:02:28 AM »
It's important not to jump to conclusions about biological factors in social and reproductive behaviour.  There are studies that show that we treat boys and girls very differently from the day they are born, based on our own taught behaviour patterns.  Which pretty much spoils every argument that what we perceive as male and female behaviour has to be caused by biological factors rather then enviromental ones because "everyone" behaves like that.  I'm not saying it couldn't be biological to some degree, but this Mars <-> Venus thinking is overly simplifying and anti-progressive.  

*

GizmoWidget

  • P Cup
  • 1577
Re: What a Bitch
« Reply #34 on: September 15, 2003, 01:10:00 PM »
St. Weapon said;
Quote:

What I noticed about animal courting, it's the males that are flamboyant and extravagant. Humans have somehow reversed that. I mean, males attract females then, but we have it as females attract males.



You're confusing the mechanisms of attraction and competion here...  In all animals, the females attract males through various means... but males still must compete for the female they want.  I think the majority of the "attracting" that women do isn't so much as to attract a man, after all, any woman can find a man if she weren't choosy, but it's more to be more attractive than other women.  It's the old idea that women dress up to be impress/out do each other, than to attract a man.  The bottom line is that it's still the males who have to compete for the female of their choice.    

On the other hand, males compete for women not so much by be being attractive (though that is a consideration to women), but by being successful; i.e. a good paying job, big house, etc.  I have been the perfect example of this...  When I was in my early/mid 20's I had no problem meeting attractive women and having lots of fun, sexual and otherwise with them.  These women were usually 5 - 15 years my senior.  When none of them would get really seriously into a relationship with me, I began to wonder what the hell was going on...  One of them put it to me in no uncertain terms; "You're a man perfect for having a fling with, but you're not the kind of guy a woman who's interested in raising a family with would want to marry".  What matters to a woman about a man more than looks is how well he can provide for a family and create a stable and consistent environment.  Showing that ability is how men compete for women.    
Put Buck O'Neal in the Major League Baseball Hall of Fame!!!

*

GizmoWidget

  • P Cup
  • 1577
Re: What a Bitch
« Reply #35 on: September 15, 2003, 01:29:40 PM »
Kanodin said;
Quote:


3) Culture and social processes influence the behavior of people.



This statement summarizes all that was said before it.  The key here is that these processes *influence* behavior, they do not *determine* behavior.  Now, I'll be the first to stand up for the philosophical claim that freedom of the will does exist.  However, this does not mean that our behavior does not have a biological basis.  I guarantee you (and I know this example will be disgusting, but I'm making a point, not actually advocating this as any kind of empirical research), that if you took a male and female pair of paternal twins, and altered them with hormonal and genetic treatments so that the female recieved male hormones and genetic expressions, and the male recieved female hormones and genetic expressions, they would not only develop as the opposite of their actual gender, but they would behave to a large extent the same as the opposite of their actual gender as well.  Of course, this says nothing about how psychologically damaged they'd be from such a treatment.  The bottom line is that while social constructs of gender do indeed influence our cognitions and our behavior, biology is the ultimate basis of those things.

Quote:

We've obviously suggested that clothing is a form of communication which can showcase certain parts of the body for a very suggestive message.  I think that a woman getting irked when the 'wrong man' looks at her simply shows the woman's frustration that her attempt to communicate did not live up to her expectations; she wanted her cake and to eat it too.



Yes, this has already been established in this thread.

Quote:

Second of all, I think the persistence of the claim that women are more programmed to stay with one partner than men is a social construct.



Not at all.  An example is the way some species of birds pair and mate.  Many species of birds pair for life; if a male of a pair is killed for what ever reason, the female of the pair will never take another mate, for the rest of her life.

Quote:

I also think that the observation that 'women pick men' is limited to western cultures.  It's a sad fact that this behavior becomes inverted in eastern cultures.  Nobody knows why, but somehow the tenets of acceptable human behavior change from place to place.



Yes, now this is an example of how social mores influence cognitions and behaviors.  Again, simply because social forces influence behavior doesn't mean there are no biological factors that determine behavior.

Quote:

We can probably come up with hundreds of examples, but one really obvious example comes from the answer to the question, "why don't any Japanese people like to shake hands?"  Some people have undergone a societal conditioning and they now exhibit some very peculiar behaviors.      



Peculiar to who?  Your value judgment here about such behavior is actually reinforcing your point, but again, it doesn't mean that there are no biological forces motivating behavior, as your entire post seems to be arguing.

The fact of the matter is that BOTH social and biological factors influence gender related behavior.  The trick is figuring out which force is motivating what behavior...

The bottom line is that biology is ultimately the strongest force.  While social constructs and conditioning can influence that behavior, it's ultimate basis is in our biology.  To claim otherwise would be to say something along the lines that the mind isn't a product of the brain.  If that were the case, then I should be able to remove your brain without it also removing your mind... and we all know that simply isn't the case.  
Put Buck O'Neal in the Major League Baseball Hall of Fame!!!

*

GizmoWidget

  • P Cup
  • 1577
Re: What a Bitch
« Reply #36 on: September 15, 2003, 01:40:40 PM »
EW said;
Quote:

It's important not to jump to conclusions about biological factors in social and reproductive behaviour.  There are studies that show that we treat boys and girls very differently from the day they are born, based on our own taught behaviour patterns.



Yes, but these have evolved over hundreds of thousands of years of human culture, which is where society arises from.  (Please note there are differing technical definitions of culture and society in anthropology.  Culture is the way a social group earn a living in the environment; it consists of the strategies of food gathering, finding shelter, etc.  Society on the other hand is how the individuals in a group relate to each other and understand the world and the culture they employ to survive in that world.  While they do interact, they are separate mechanisms.)

Quote:

Which pretty much spoils every argument that what we perceive as male and female behaviour has to be caused by biological factors rather then enviromental ones because "everyone" behaves like that.



Not at all... see my reply to Kanodin above about the hypothetical hormone/gene manipulation experiment.  What you say right here is basically that such an experiment wouldn't have any effect, which a great deal of medical research, mind you not just psychology or anthropology, has already proven to be scientific fact.

Quote:

I'm not saying it couldn't be biological to some degree, but this Mars <-> Venus thinking is overly simplifying and anti-progressive.



Well, what you say above does directly imply that biology isn't a factor at all.

As for it being anti-progressive, that's a value judgment.  What is progressive such that the claim that the idea that biology plays a major role in gender behavior would be considered anti-progressive?  IMO the claim that everything is a social construct, a-la Derrida, Foucault, etc. is a crock.  The problem with deconstruction is that it assumes nothing is normative, so if nothing is normative, you have no absolutes to start from, and if you have nothing to start from, how do you have anything at all?  There must ultimately be a basis from which all culture and society starts from, and that is the physical fact of our biology and the mechanisms by which it functions.  
Put Buck O'Neal in the Major League Baseball Hall of Fame!!!

*

thcbl

  • G Cup
  • 1075
Re: What a Bitch
« Reply #37 on: September 15, 2003, 01:50:17 PM »
Basically ... it goes like this:

Men - never try to understand the female mind.
Ladies - never try to understand the male mind.

Women dress up to be looked at.

Men look.

Women get upset at men looking.

Men continue to look.

End of story. Repeat.

*

Kanodin

  • Banned User
  • 1325
Re: What's a Bitch?
« Reply #38 on: September 15, 2003, 07:58:37 PM »
There's nothing wrong with advocating for a modernist paradigm.  I would readily admit that genetics forms the starting point for how we, as a species, will end up.  This doesn't discount the function of communication and societal interations at all.  Genetics simply operates as a complex fractal instruction set which sets the direction that our bodies will develop.  You don't have a gene for a 'nose' per se, but you do have genes that cause your body to grow certain tissue patterns for a head, other shapes, including a shape that looks like a nose.  

The premise that genetics forms the beginning of human behavior is not irreconcilable with the role that culture and communication have in shaping that to unpredictable degrees.  If one wants a beginning, look for the genes.  If one wants to look for the emergent behavior, then that's a little bit more complicated.  Simply discounting such a function of human behavior with biological analogies from the animal kingdom creates no parallel examples; squirrels, birds, and apes do not live within a world of pronounced communication and socially enforced norms like people do.  Apes may have neighbors and the beginnings of rational thought, but do they have books, music, news, universities, or clothes?

I always get a kick out of anyone who makes the same desperate attempts to create some epistemological construct as thousands of modernists before them.  Here's where I think our behavior comes from.  It's not all genetics, not all culture, but you can at least see where I come from...

genetics -> biological phenotypes -> bodies
bodies + experiences = individual behavior

I would say we're a long way from knowing how much of any of this contributes to our ontology, but that doesn't stop any of us from guessing.  Is the truth out there?  Well, I don't know; billions of people interacting makes that a bit difficult.    

*

E_W

  • X Cup
  • 2225
Re: What a Bitch
« Reply #39 on: September 16, 2003, 02:46:02 AM »
Quote:


Men - never try to understand the female mind.
Ladies - never try to understand the male mind.

...

End of story. Repeat.  




This sort of fits my description of anti-progressive.  What I mean is that biology is often just a too convenient explanation.  "Women!" you say, end of discussion.  Throughout history, our definition of male and female behaviour has changed significantly.

GizmoWidget, I fail to see what your hypothetical experiment really implies, if anything.  The studies I mentioned clearly show that we treat children differently based on what sex we percieve them to be.  In other words, the enviroment would differ between the twins mentioned.  Our conservative education system works to reinforce differences.  Don't try and tell me boys and girls have the same expectations on them in school, at home, just about anywhere... what we call socially acceptable behaviour is very much a construct.

*

GizmoWidget

  • P Cup
  • 1577
Re: What a Bitch
« Reply #40 on: September 16, 2003, 05:58:56 AM »
EW said;
Quote:

GizmoWidget, I fail to see what your hypothetical experiment really implies, if anything.



I'm sorry that you've bought so deeply into this post-modern, deconstructivist dead end... it's blinding you to the fact that our biology plays a significant and determining role in our behavior.  Do you take over the counter medicines or meds prescribed by a doctor?  If you believe that biology plays no role in our cognitions or our behavior, or that it plays no role in how we percieve the world, why do you go to a doctor at all when you're sick?  According to the position you're defending, the idea that medicines treat illness on a biological level is incoherent.  In fact, to extend your argument to this example, the migraine headache you are experiencing is a social construct that is the result of years of the social conditioning you've been subjected to.  It doesn't have anything to do with the fact that biochemical changes in your brain have caused a constriction of the blood vessels in your head and neck.  Also, according to the position you're defending, everything is a placebo, the effect that medicine has on an illness is also a social construct.

Here's a more substantial thing for you to try...  If you really believe that our biology doesn't effect our cognition, perception, and behavior, go down to your local hospital and ask them to do a full frontal lobotomy on you... if you're correct, it will have absolutely no effect on you at all, you'll continue on just as you were and you'll be fully capable of all the same things you are now, in the absolute same capacity... You'll even be aware that you had a full frontal lobotomy and that it had no effect on you...  Now, do you really believe that if a doctor cuts out half of your brain that it'll have no effect on your mind, your perceptions, or your behavior?  

Quote:

The studies I mentioned clearly show that we treat children differently based on what sex we percieve them to be.



Yes, of course, this is a fact.  However, such studies only show that social factors influence behavior.  They DO NOT SHOW that biology DOESN'T influence behavior.  If you think they do you really have a horrible misunderstanding of how science works.  If you find evidence in support of one hypothesis, that evidence does not necessarily show that a competing hypothesis is wrong.  You have to do a separate experiment to test that competing hypothesis.  In logic, what you are doing is arguing speciously... it's like saying, the good luck charm you're wearing keeps malaria carrying mosquitos away from you when you're in a geographic location where there are no malaria carrying mosquitos.  Do you understand now the faulty logic you are employing?

Quote:

In other words, the enviroment would differ between the twins mentioned.



No.  The social influences differ, not the environment.  The temperature, the humidity, the availablity of food and shelter, threats to one's physical well being... those vary.  Not how people react to them.  Again, you are conflating two different things as the same.  The physical environment is not the social context.

Quote:

Our conservative education system works to reinforce differences.  Don't try and tell me boys and girls have the same expectations on them in school, at home, just about anywhere... what we call socially acceptable behaviour is very much a construct.



Yes, appropriate behavior is a social construct.  But just because appropriate behavior is a social construct does not mean that biology has no influence on behavior.  Yet again, you are assuming that confirmation of one idea must and does mean that a competing idea is false.  That is faulty reasoning.  Let me give you another example...  Let's say I run out of gas in my car, yet I just filled the tank yesterday and I've driven very little.  What is the cause?  I check my car over and find a hole in my fuel line that causes a small leak.  So, I conclude that the leak is the cause of my running out of gas.  Yet, unknown to me is that the gas station I went to is cheating me, their pumps only give me a half a gallon for every gallon they say goes into my tank...  Simply because I find a leak in my fuel line does not automatically mean that the gas station is not cheating me.  Do you understand the problem in your reasoning now?  

I'm sorry EW, I don't mean to be insulting or belittling, or to talk down to you, but it's clear that you have failed to completely read and/or understand the full meaning of my previous posts.  I never said that social forces don't influence gender based behavior... go back and reread them.  I said that while social norms do have an influence in our behavior, I also said that it is not the only behavioral influence on gender roles.  Let me say it again in a different way... social influence is not the only influence on gender typical behavior.  I said that both influence behavior, and that biology is more deterministic than social influences.  This doesn't mean that social forces can't override instinctual impulses, which is what you seem to be arguing I'm saying.  I've said nothing of the sort.    
Put Buck O'Neal in the Major League Baseball Hall of Fame!!!

*

GizmoWidget

  • P Cup
  • 1577
Re: What's a Bitch?
« Reply #41 on: September 16, 2003, 06:38:42 AM »
Quote:

There's nothing wrong with advocating for a modernist paradigm.



The actual term for the philosophical position is post-modernism... but that's not a big deal.  The problem with it is that it assumes as a fundamental tenet of it's arguments that there is no such thing as an absolute.  If there is nothing that exists outside of our social interaction or is not a product of it, what is the basis for our social interaction?  If there is no external basis, how did it start?  Did human society just suddenly appear, sui generis?  The post modernists even argue that fundamental scientific concepts such as temperature or mass are purely social, that there is no such thing out there in the world that actually is or has mass or, or is or has temperature.  This idea is totally wrong headed, and I'll explain why...

Descartes method of radical doubt was to assume that everything was false.  This is logically isomorphic to the post-modern position that everything is a social construct.  However, in order for Descartes to doubt anything at all, an assumption must first be made that there is a background of truth against which something may be doubted.  If there were no truth in the first place, how can one have a doubt, any doubt, that something was truthful to begin with?  This is Wittgenstein's argument against scepticism...

Quote:

I would readily admit that genetics forms the starting point for how we, as a species, will end up.  This doesn't discount the function of communication and societal interations at all.



I never, never, never said that social factors don't influence behavior... please go back and reread my previous posts.

Quote:

Genetics simply operates as a complex fractal instruction set which sets the direction that our bodies will develop.  You don't have a gene for a 'nose' per se, but you do have genes that cause your body to grow certain tissue patterns for a head, other shapes, including a shape that looks like a nose.



The analogy that genetic information is fractal like in it's complexity is a false one to use.  Biologists working on the human genome project have coded the four basic molecules that go into a DNA molecule and how they combine with their possible combinations.  In terms of total bits of information, the entire human genome is a little less than 700 MB of data.  The entire genome for our species as a whole basically fits onto a CD ROM.


Quote:

The premise that genetics forms the beginning of human behavior is not irreconcilable with the role that culture and communication have in shaping that to unpredictable degrees.  If one wants a beginning, look for the genes.  If one wants to look for the emergent behavior, then that's a little bit more complicated.



Yes, this is what I've been trying to say... I'm sorry if I haven't been clear, but I've done my best.

Quote:

Simply discounting such a function of human behavior with biological analogies from the animal kingdom creates no parallel examples; squirrels, birds, and apes do not live within a world of pronounced communication and socially enforced norms like people do.  Apes may have neighbors and the beginnings of rational thought, but do they have books, music, news, universities, or clothes?



Now you're contradicting yourself here.  Just because less evolutionarily derived species than ourselves don't have books, or other forms of abstract representation and cognition doesn't mean the don't have social structures that influence their behavior.  Also, just because they don't have those things doesn't mean examples drawn from their behavior and biology doesn't mean that those same principles don't apply to us.  If you think that's the case, then how come we don't have two radically different forms of biology on our planet, one for highly derived species with complex social constructs, and one for those organisms that don't?  The fact of the matter is that the biological process that are the basis of life are the same in all organisms.  The process of mitosis or the krebs cycle in you are virtually identical to those that occur in an ape, a squirrel, or a paramecium.

Quote:

I always get a kick out of anyone who makes the same desperate attempts to create some epistemological construct as thousands of modernists before them.  Here's where I think our behavior comes from.  It's not all genetics, not all culture, but you can at least see where I come from...




Yes. I agree exactly.  Behavior is a synthesis of biological and social factors.  This is what I've been saying in just about every post I've made in this thread, and which EW seems to be arguing is not the case, that everything is social, and there is not biological influence at all.

Quote:

I would say we're a long way from knowing how much of any of this contributes to our ontology, but that doesn't stop any of us from guessing.  Is the truth out there?  Well, I don't know; billions of people interacting makes that a bit difficult.



This is why I study what I do... psychophysics, in the vein of Helmholtz, Ebbinghaus, and the progenitors of experimental cognitive psychology.  I study reflexive mechanisms of vision, and what subjective phenomenological experiences are created by these basic biological mechanisms.  We are a long way away from separating the influences that society and biology each have on a person's behavior.  In fact I'd say they cannot be separately studied in humans, which is why studying animal behavior is so important.  After all, Jane Goodall's work is considered to be just as important for the light it sheds on our own society and behavior, as well as the information about chimps it provides...

The bottom line is that the brain and our physiological and biological mechanisms are the basis of our behavior, and from these and their interaction with the environment culture and society arise.  Unfortunately, EW seems to think that even basic things like the fact that it's 78 degrees farenheit outside is a purely social construct, and that there is no underlying physical mechanism in the world in the physical behavior of matter that is the physical manifestation of what we understand as it being 78 degrees farenheit outside...  Hopefully, he'll see the points we've made here, and come to realize that the world is a combination of environment and society.    
Put Buck O'Neal in the Major League Baseball Hall of Fame!!!

*

E_W

  • X Cup
  • 2225
Re: What a Bitch
« Reply #42 on: September 16, 2003, 11:35:17 AM »
I'm not a die-hard modernist, you know.  You're putting words in my mouth.  All I'm trying to say is that blaming everything on biology isn't the way to get a better understanding of each other.  Of course there are biological factors in our behaviour, our cognition, whatever.  But in order to establish the connection between our genes and our behaviour there's a lot of work left to do.  Is there such a thing as a male brain or a female brain, and if so, what are the differences and exactly what causes them?  No serious researcher would say that he or she can answer those questions even remotely accurately.  The day we actually can, society as a whole is probably going to see a great deal of change.  

*

thcbl

  • G Cup
  • 1075
Re: What a Bitch
« Reply #43 on: September 16, 2003, 12:32:26 PM »
Hey now ... all these big words are in play ... you guys gotta remember that I'm just the stereotypical stupid Canadian pothead.

Can we dumb it down a bit for me here?

Like ...

Women with nice boobies are good to look at but don't always like being looked at because of soical stigmas and learned discrimination?

Oh ... wait ... that was kinda wordy at the end.

How about we just go with: Yay boobies!

*

GizmoWidget

  • P Cup
  • 1577
Re: What a Bitch
« Reply #44 on: September 16, 2003, 12:49:39 PM »
Quote:

I'm not a die-hard modernist, you know.  You're putting words in my mouth.



I'm not putting words in your mouth.  Up until this post you've not been willing to acknowledge at all that biology plays a role in our behavior.  What I've done is taken what you said and drawn conclusions that follow logically from those claims, nothing more.  You've invoked the idea of post-modernism, and claimed repeatedly that social influences trump biological influences.  Thus come the conclusions from the tenets you argue from.

Quote:

All I'm trying to say is that blaming everything on biology isn't the way to get a better understanding of each other.



Oh jeez... Please, please, please go back and reread my previous posts.  I have not once said that biology is the only influence on our behavior, gender oriented or otherwise.  In fact, I've said that behavior is a synthesis of social and biological influences.  Why are you still claiming that I'm saying that it's only biology and nothing else?

Quote:

Of course there are biological factors in our behaviour, our cognition, whatever.



Unless I've misread your posts, this if the very first time in this thread you've accepted this point as having any truth what so ever.

Quote:

But in order to establish the connection between our genes and our behaviour there's a lot of work left to do.



*Sigh*... once again, you aren't understanding the role of genetics in behavior.  Genes are biological, yes, but they are not all of biology or physiology.  Our genetic code is a blueprint, that shows how to go about making certain things.  It does not specify *the process* by which those things are made.  This is the distinction between phenotype and genotype in biology.  Genotype is the specific genes combinations that code for a particular physical trait, such as blue eyes, or black hair.  These traits are expressed phenotypically by the organism interacting with the context of the environment.  A perfect example of this is Tay-Sachs disease.  If not found and left untreated, infants born with this genetic disorder die withing 12 to 18 mos. of birth.  However, if it is caught, an appropriate treatment is nothing more than a modification to diet that completely prevents the disorder from manifesting and causing illness.  Thus, while our genotype specifies the functional parameters of biological mechanisms, it does not specify how they are to be produced and implemented.  That is done by the actual biological mechanisms of physiology and biochemistry, and the resources the environment brings to the organism that can be used to implement these mechanisms.

Quote:

Is there such a thing as a male brain or a female brain, and if so, what are the differences and exactly what causes them?



Yes.  There are documented structural and functional differences between male and female brain structures.  It's quite complex, so I won't attempt to go into it here.  But, it is a documented biological and medical fact that male and female brains are structurally and therefore functionally different in their information processing.


Quote:

No serious researcher would say that he or she can answer those questions even remotely accurately.



*Sigh again*...  I never said any such thing.  Again, you are ignoring what I've said in my previous posts in this thread.  In fact I said I don't think we'll ever be able to completely separate the social from the biological influences in explaining behavior.  Please, please go back and reread what I've already said.  Either you still aren't understanding what I've said, or you haven't read it.

Quote:

The day we actually can, society as a whole is probably going to see a great deal of change.



This is a deep philosophical issue that underlies much of biological and genetic research.  Our moral assumptions and practices will be severely tested by new developments and discoveries in medicine, biology, genetics, and neuroscience.  The biggest question is how can one be a determinist in biophysics and biochemistry, and also subscribe to the idea of free will in philosophy and psychology?  But, that's the beauty of the critical process... science is only a tool of understanding.  It is not exhaustive and all inclusive...  The biggest mistake a lot of physical scientists make is to assume that if something cannot be explained deterministically and mathematcially by science, that it simply doesn't exist.  I have tried to demonstrate that I don't fall into this camp in what I've said in this thread.  I'm sorry I haven't done a good enough job at explaining that to you.

So can we agree at this point that both biology and social context influence behavior, that they are a synergistic process, and that genetics are not deterministic for behavior?  That's all I've been trying to say all along...  
Put Buck O'Neal in the Major League Baseball Hall of Fame!!!