I mostly ignore the "ratings;" the number of posts someone has made has minimal correlation with whether any given message from that person is worthwhile.
If BEA were to go to some kind of moderation, I'd suggest taking a serious look at how slashdot (
http://slashdot.org/) does it. They've gone through a LOT of stuff trying to get it right, and even then it's not clear that they have.
The problem is that there is a certain class of jerk who gets his jollies from trying to wreck things for everybody else. The question is: which is more disruptive: the current level of trolls and flamage, or the level that will be generated by such jerks when they set out to subvert whatever form of moderation BEA adopts?
Add to that the necessarily subjective nature of the subject matter here, and I'm not sure that moderation in the slashdot style will work. I would instead recommend that individual users (or perhaps members only, if you want to give people an additional nudge towards subscribing...) be allowed to set up their own rating system that would control what messages they see and what order they show up in.
Just to give an example: I personally adore Vixen and Keisha Evans (note: that does
not imply that I don't adore other women who post here!), enjoy extreme morphs, and also have fantasies about giantesses, long hair, long legs, and large nipples. I'd want a message about a computer generated video depicting Vixen and Keisha as twelve feet tall with eight foot long legs, hair down to their ankles, and breasts the size of semi trailers to show up at the top of the list in 144 point Cooper Black. Others...probably wouldn't

.
If the selection were up to the individual, we could skip the furry wars; people who want to see morphs depicting shemales with enormous breasts and penises fellating themselves could discuss things without bothering anyone, and C*****n C**********d would receive well-deserved oblivion.