*

Jack

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 29
Feedback for Other Earth
« on: August 18, 2010, 10:28:23 PM »
Don't know how many people still have subscriptions to the BESC what with all the complaining that I've read about them lately, but... If anyone HAS read it, I'd love to hear what people thought of it. I'm a bit of a feedback whore (good feedback or bad feedback, don't care), and as far as I know this is the best place to get it for a BESC story.

On a related note, at the end of the story I hinted at a sequel. At the time, I had every intention of writing one. But, uh... that was over a year ago; this story was from the 2009 contest. Without having really heard any promising news since then (almost no news whatsoever, in fact), my motivation to write that sequel is very low at this point. If you liked this one enough to want a sequel, you'll have to let me know so that I feel motivated again.

*

Jack

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 29
Re: Feedback for Other Earth
« Reply #1 on: September 22, 2010, 06:19:07 PM »
What, no one read it? Oh, good, I'll get started right away on part 2!  ;)

*

solvegas

  • ZZZ Cup
  • 83829
Re: Feedback for Other Earth
« Reply #2 on: September 22, 2010, 09:10:49 PM »
I read it. I liked it. If only the breasts were bigger ..... much, much BIGGER !!!  ;D ( can't help myself ).

*

Verrucktzer

  • A Cup
  • 2
Re: Feedback for Other Earth
« Reply #3 on: October 03, 2010, 12:27:30 PM »
[delurking]

Where is the story?

[relurking]

*

trainman

Re: Feedback for Other Earth
« Reply #4 on: October 04, 2010, 10:20:53 PM »
Where is the story?

Available on the BE Story Club.

My comments: good "wish fulfillment"-type story, with well-written sex/BE scenes.

I know it's all a plot device and this isn't exactly "hard" science fiction, but I'm a little dubious on the science -- seems like if they have the technology to use nanites to heal numerous aspects of someone's physiology, and (even if this one is experimental) can transform one species into another -- from alien into "normal," no less -- surely they would have some ideas about the declining birth rate.

One thing I did like is one of my favorite things to see in sci-fi: of course the other planet is going to be called something akin to "Earth." I love Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy (see my signature), but it gets that wrong; you're not gonna call your own planet "(name of star) (number)."

*

Jack

  • A Cup
  • *
  • 29
Re: Feedback for Other Earth
« Reply #5 on: October 05, 2010, 02:21:14 PM »
Thanks for the comments.

Yeah, physiological sciences aren't my forte, but it's a good point you bring up. If I remember correctly - it's literally been almost a year and a half since I wrote this story - I think I said they know it's a genetic defect, but they simply can't find it. The genetic make-up between the aliens and the humans is incredible similar, which is really the only reason she was able to alter his species. I know I didn't mention that within the story (because I just thought of it), but it makes sense. To me at least. Probably it's a highly experimental treatment that she didn't have government-sponsored approval for. Fixing genetic defects however, is probably much more within their capabilities, so once his DNA had been altered, she could find the mistake and fix it rather quickly. But then again, like I said, my logic is always flimsy in this regard, so... I do the best I can.

And I agree, generally speaking, the natural inhabitants of a planet would call it something similar to "Earth". Possibly not, however, if they colonized a planet more recently, like if it's not their home planet; they'd need to name it something else.

On a related note, I personally despise the title of this story. I'm just bad at coming up with titles and couldn't think of something better.

*

trainman

Re: Feedback for Other Earth
« Reply #6 on: October 05, 2010, 11:45:58 PM »
Oh, and I probably should have said that I would definitely be interested in reading a sequel, if that helps you get motivated to write one.