The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« on: October 04, 2003, 12:13:42 AM »
I was just reading another thread regarding number of posts.  In my opinion, this is one of the most lame metrics to rate the quality of participation of a user.  As I stated in that thread, it is the equivalent of a "pissing contest", inspiring people to just post post post, giving very little regard to what they are saying.

When this forum was upgraded a few months back, what seemed to be a default function became available: the ability to rank other users using a star-based system.  A four-star ranking being highest, one-star being lowest.  This system was deactivated by the administrators of this site.

This precipitates my question.  Do you think the BEA needs some other sort of metric to rate users on quality of their participation besides raw number of posts, ie reenacting this star-based system?  Would it make your own reading and participation easier here?  Do you think it would simply cause animus in this forum?  Please post your thoughts, I would like to know what others think.  Following is a poll posing the question of reinstituting a metric allowing users to rate their peers.




Consider this post half tempered / half rant.  I hate to overreact, but some of the posts here that come from users, some who have thousands of posts, are in my opinion seriously lacking.  They are constantly off topic, seriously annoying, and bring nothing to the conversational table.  I am sure I am not alone in having these sentiments.  In my opinion, if these users were to be graded, perhaps they would think about what the post more often and not just go for quantity, but seriously consider quality as well.  That is my motivation for this thread.

Thank you very much, and I am very much looking forward to your input.  I really would like to hear what the administrators and moderators have to say on this issue as well.  

*

Sadistyk

  • Oh My God Cup
  • 10601
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #1 on: October 04, 2003, 12:43:06 AM »
Okay, I know you are talking about me in the terms of post quality vs quantity.  But I'm not upset, just curious.  Do you actually remember a few months ago before the forum got upgraded?  Do you remember all the tension that was caused by that stupid star-rating system?  Do you remeber that the star-system was the one thing here we we're all happy to see die off?  Now you want it back?!?

If you want stars so much, got to the bottom of each thread and click on the 'still useable' thread rating stars.  As far as contributing, I'm post here to thank those who put up pics, morphs, etc.  I also enjoy the fact that I can correspond with a few big-bust starlets while I'm here.  Just because my posts aren't always the most elaborately written pieces of text around here does not mean they are useless or unworthy of being here.

I have urged people here to delurk, much like you have, with a few results.  I respect you for who you are and all that you have done for these forums, and the BEA.  But man, please let the thought of the star system or any other ranking system die off.  We have the cups/taglines...let's just stick with them.

Also, keep in mind that these forums are for fun and we should all enjoy using them in our own ways.

Hope I didn't offend you, just stating my side, that's all.

Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #2 on: October 04, 2003, 01:01:01 AM »
No offense taken man.  You gave your opinion, and I'm glad you did.  That's all I was hoping for.

I believe in the philosophy that people only get pissed off by the truth.  If something is false, they have no reason to be mad at it being said.  They should just dismiss it.  I think the same should be said for ratings.  If someone gives you a poor rating, you can do one of two things: either dismiss it as being false, or work to improve it because it is in fact true.  Pretty simple in my opinion.

Quote:

 Just because my posts aren't always the most elaborately written pieces of text around here does not mean they are useless or unworthy of being here.





I never said or implied any such thing.  Every user here and their respective posts have the same right as their peers to have a presence here.  However, people should be able to decide for themselves which users they happen to appreciate and which user's posts suck.  Plain and simple.  Think of it in a democratic sense.

My point is that the cup size thing is absolutely stupid.  It seems you realize as well that there are people here that post simply to accrue posts, nothing else.  It seems to me that people here see it as some badge of authority or trophy.  Since it serves no purpose, then we should do away with the post totals of each user as well then, right?

I see the situation two ways: either keep the post totals of each user and add the star-ranking, OR get rid of the post totals and do not add the ranking.  Both should decrease junk posts and make things a little more informative/content rich around here.    

*

Seelie

  • G Cup
  • 739
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #3 on: October 04, 2003, 01:09:25 AM »
I think the most amusing thing the bust-size rating system ever inspired was a lurker de-lurking to ask why we thought a b-cupper like the then recently-augmented Christine Allure deserved to be considered a "big bust star" hehe. Man that cracked me up.

As I see it, those who go around posting tons of off-topic and pointless posts to get to a high rating end up being ignored except by people with little to no self-control who end up doing the same thing in response. Regulars and old-timers see it happen, shrug it off, and go on with our visit. The wholepost-count thing is just for fun. Those, like say Palomine and St. Stephen who've been here for years and often have valuable things to say get respect based on what they say and how they say it, not their post count. Those who have nothing valuable to add never get respect regardless of their post count. All in all it causes no harm and is a little fun. More importantly, it's very in keeping with the nature of the site itself: Breast Enlargement. I say, keep it.

The real downside of any attempt to rate quality is that they don't work. Look at eBay for example. Have you ever tried giving someone an honest grade? Like "average" or something? Man, expect a negative in response. THOSE systems become pising contests real fast. People come to expect a certain level of reward no matter how they act. If tehy don't get it, they get pissed off and ruin things for other people. I'd rather not see anything like that come here. A nice, innocent, completely irrelevant rating system tied to breast growth is perfect for us.

In my not at all humble opinion.

And to address your request for admins and mods, I was a moderator for the forum (originally just the Plume then later for the whole forum) for about two years. Stopped due to time constraints keeping me away for way too long. That was a bit after Owner started calling himself Webmaster (If I recal correctly). If that means anything to you (having an ex-mod respond I mean, I'm not trying to brag or anything). If not, probably at least one of the current mods will post eventually.
-----
Hmm, I guess I'm not as omniscient as I thought.

Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #4 on: October 04, 2003, 01:12:21 AM »
Appreciated, thanks.  But is the breast-growth label a rating system?  I think thats the underlying issue here.  In my opinion, it is not.  

*

Sadistyk

  • Oh My God Cup
  • 10601
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #5 on: October 04, 2003, 01:16:11 AM »
I think the cup thing is in no way a status marker around here.  It's just for fun.  That's the way I look at it anyway.  I lurked here for years before finally joining and I have to say that I've seen the system change a few times.  Some of the changes were good while others were not.  The forum as it stands now, is what I would call the happy medium.  It's got it's own quirks that we all take for granted.  I just don't want to see anything 'new' get implemented around here anytime soon, that's all.  But as the old saying goes, "you can't please everybody all the time" or something to that context.


Oh, BTW...glad it wasn't me you were talking about.

*

MunchWolf

  • What Tagline?
  • 11463
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #6 on: October 04, 2003, 01:18:43 AM »
hmmm ...

interesting question, but I'm not sure the poll is worded right ...

 
Quote:

 Do you think the BEA needs some other sort of metric to rate users on quality of their participation besides raw number of posts




This implies quantity of posts currently is used to measure quality ... which I don't believe is the case (and it seems you don't believe should be the case either) ...

Personally I think how long someone has been posting is more important ... but again isn't a determining factor .. some of my favorite posters have yet to break a hundred ...

The previous star system was a joke ... an individual was lucky to get at least 10 people to vote for them .. and even then, one person marking a zero knocked you down a star  (and it went to 5 btw, but you could only keep a 5 if you had a perfect score) ...

I think the best method to determine the quality of your words is to judge the responses to your posts ... so to that extent if you agree with someone or like what they say, you should speak up and let them know (or send them a PM) ... likewise for the reverse ...

-Munch "you know you can still rate threads?" Wolf

*

MrHHH

  • L Cup
  • 2985
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #7 on: October 04, 2003, 01:20:19 AM »
I liked the star system

And good luck getting ANY innovative system installed here. Unless you happen to be the BEA programmer.
 

*

Sadistyk

  • Oh My God Cup
  • 10601
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #8 on: October 04, 2003, 01:20:48 AM »
*stands up and applauds*

Great post Seelie!  Great to have you back here again too!

Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #9 on: October 04, 2003, 01:29:07 AM »
The star system definitely had its flaws.  One was the mathematics behind calculation of the rating (seems like it was never rounded, always floored).  Another was what you mention, in that you were lucky to get a few people to rate you.  Too bad a rating is not required if you are replying to someone's post; that would be the easiest way to force a rating I suppose.

Thanks for the input Munch.  

Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #10 on: October 04, 2003, 01:34:33 AM »
Also, please be sure to cast a vote in the poll!  I think thats the best way for people to express their opinion, even if they do not want to make it known it is coming from them.  

*

Seelie

  • G Cup
  • 739
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #11 on: October 04, 2003, 01:41:02 AM »
Quote:

Appreciated, thanks.


Welcome.  
Quote:

But is the breast-growth label a rating system? I think thats the underlying issue here. In my opinion, it is not.



Clearly it is not a rating system. It is, however, a ranking system. One based on the theme of the site, and intended for amusement. Does it mean we take people with 10,000 posts more seriously? Nope. It matters who does the talking. Take my all-time favorite contributer to the BE community, Bust Artist. He's got, lemme check to be totally accurate, 70 posts. I assure you that should he make post #71 it'd get a HELL of a lot of notice. Same with Elliot James' posts. He's only got 82. The only ones who really consider it a rating system are the ones we tend to ignore 'cause they have nothing much to say.

The real question is does their posting for bust-size actually hurt anyone's feelings or take away the fun of the forum?

Howdy Sadistyk. I'm still catching up. Interesting to see the new people and to find out who hasn't posted in a while.
-----
Hmm, I guess I'm not as omniscient as I thought.

*

MunchWolf

  • What Tagline?
  • 11463
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #12 on: October 04, 2003, 01:44:00 AM »
wow .. that's what I get for watching Josie and the Pussycats ... five replies between when I started my post and when I finished it ...

-Munch "sometimes I feel my posts aren't very informative   or is that too informative " Wolf

Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #13 on: October 04, 2003, 01:48:27 AM »
I agree to some extent.  However, I do not think it is either a rating or ranking system.  Ranking connotes some progression (or degression for that matter), allocating worth.  Number of posts should not dictate any kind of worthiness.

When I see that Elliot James has posted, I too make it a point to beeline directly to his post.  The same goes for some other favorite users of mine with minimal posting habits.  These users would get high rankings in my opinion, simply because of the quality of their posts, not because they post irregularly.  Same would go for posters who post a lot of high quality posts.    

*

Seelie

  • G Cup
  • 739
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #14 on: October 04, 2003, 02:33:26 AM »
Ranking doesn't necessarily imply worth, though I admit it often does. Rating does. Though perhaps I should have used the term sorting. Either way, I still feel the most important issue is for how many people besides yourself does the activity of those trolls who post simply to increase their bust size harm the experience at the forum. After that it gets to the deeper issue of, is the correct solution to alter the motive or to deal with the transgressors directly.

In my opinion, if it is determined that a high number of people are bothered by the post-count-trolls, then something needs to be done. However, I feel that removing the breast-expansion theme as a way of dealing with them is resorting to a lowest-common-denominator. And whenever you do that, you necessarily get a product that is low and common. I'd rather see such behavior altered, than the forum altered. But we'll need to let your poll collect votes for a day or so to see how the behavior of the vocal minority affects the community. I admit I'm rather curious what the numbers will read by Monday evening.
-----
Hmm, I guess I'm not as omniscient as I thought.