I was just reading another thread regarding number of posts. In my opinion, this is one of the most lame metrics to rate the quality of participation of a user. As I stated in that thread, it is the equivalent of a "pissing contest", inspiring people to just post post post, giving very little regard to what they are saying.
When this forum was upgraded a few months back, what seemed to be a default function became available: the ability to rank other users using a star-based system. A four-star ranking being highest, one-star being lowest. This system was deactivated by the administrators of this site.
This precipitates my question. Do you think the BEA needs some other sort of metric to rate users on quality of their participation besides raw number of posts, ie reenacting this star-based system? Would it make your own reading and participation easier here? Do you think it would simply cause animus in this forum? Please post your thoughts, I would like to know what others think. Following is a poll posing the question of reinstituting a metric allowing users to rate their peers.
Consider this post half tempered / half rant. I hate to overreact, but some of the posts here that come from users, some who have thousands of posts, are in my opinion seriously lacking. They are constantly off topic, seriously annoying, and bring nothing to the conversational table. I am sure I am not alone in having these sentiments. In my opinion, if these users were to be graded, perhaps they would think about what the post more often and not just go for quantity, but seriously consider quality as well. That is my motivation for this thread.
Thank you very much, and I am very much looking forward to your input. I really would like to hear what the administrators and moderators have to say on this issue as well.