First, I think the ranking system was so subjective and open to abuse or manipulation that it really lacked any credibility and therefore had little effect on my interpretation or interaction on the BEA. I was glad to see it go.
It is my opinion that what is at the base of this thread is not necessarily the ranking of individual posters (that does have merit) but rather the ranking of a thread as a whole when compared to the quality of the participants of that thread.
Lets keep the race for the record number of posts separate from the conversation for a bit.
Try this on for a suggestion -
Because this is called the BEA forum I will start with the premise that maximizing participation within the forum and more exactly, within a particular thread could be a good meter for the “quality” of that post and posters. A single post with say 3000 views, 150 posts, but only four or five contributors is not much of a post, regardless of the quality of the posters. That just smacks of a posting frenzy or another flame war or such.
My suggestion is to rank a post (not the posters) by a ratio of unique posters to that topic and then weight it to the number of views and combine that with some aspect of the thread rating data that appears at the bottom of the post. A post would have a high rate if it has only many unique contributors, is viewed many times, and has lets say been active for a long time.
That way one person posting 50 times to the same post does not help raise the post rank, but 50 people posting 1 time does. Or a post that stays active over several months (non-sticky type) on its own merits will rank well.
If we must rank individuals then we could rank them buy the number of high ranking posts they have contributed too versus the total number of posts they have made. That way some would be motivated to contribute to more “quality” threads, again reducing the urge to post massive numbers of one liners to a single post. (We could exclude the Off-topic section from the calculations because that sort of thing happens there a lot regardless of the “quality” of the post)
Bottom line - is to encourage participation across the board and in as many threads as possible without blindly rewarding mass posters or simply starting a bogus thread.
Also - lets rank across a range of say 10 and not 4 or 5.
Just some ideas to kick around.
Now who is going to put the bell on this cat's collar?