*

MunchWolf

  • What Tagline?
  • 11463
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #30 on: October 04, 2003, 03:53:03 PM »
course the other downside to posting so much .. say goodbye to any political ambitions ...

-Munch "Not the poster [censored] of family values here ... divorced ... biggest poster on a porn site ... helped an ex-gf get an abortion ... currently has no [censored] .... wiccan ... BUT ... vote for me in 2008 " Wolf

*

Rafe

  • Coito Ergo Sum
  • 1284
    • Digital Discipline
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #31 on: October 04, 2003, 04:51:30 PM »
Quote:

course the other downside to posting so much .. say goodbye to any political ambitions ...




http://www.wildturkeyparty.org

[./shameless plug]

I didn't vote, because I don't care.  My biggest gripe with the system is that you couldn't kick some jackass down below one star, because, if you ask me [i notice nobody has. heh], there are a couple of contributors who warrant a big fat zero.

but there was so much angst and drama whenever someone would ding that fifth star off of a "beloved" poster, either out of petty spite or honest criticism that it just got to be a fiasco.

I like the notion of "earning" the ability to have a byline or title by, essentially, not being a complete fuckup and asking Imaginos nicely for one.

[no participants in the above thread are implied by my comments here, so anyone who wants to play martyr, we have a flame thread if you want me to kick you in the rhetorical nuts with a buick *g*]
<i>
Prince of Darkness seeks Willing Wench.
Flexible hours, shoddy pay.
Should possess improbable bustline and liquor store.</i>

*

ElmerFudd

  • Z Cup
  • 2746
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #32 on: October 04, 2003, 05:03:33 PM »
Quote:

course the other downside to posting so much .. say goodbye to any political ambitions ...

-Munch "Not the poster [censored] of family values here ... divorced ... biggest poster on a porn site ... helped an ex-gf get an abortion ... currently has no [censored] .... wiccan ... BUT ... vote for me in 2008 " Wolf  




You'd get props for honesty.  How that affects your election chances, "that honesty plus a $1.50 will get you a cup of coffee" (that last kind of appropriate for a Washington State resident!).

Hey, and having an Avatar of you, and mini-you, as the Mad Hatter can't help either! (Though certain morphs you've posted might prove more troubling).    

*

TheHerald

  • Ink & Paint Club Outcast
  • 3862
  • Ink & Paint Club Outcast
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #33 on: October 04, 2003, 06:32:35 PM »
Quote:

 certain morphs you've posted might prove more troubling


Out of that entire list, THAT's the skeleton in MW's closet that will keep him out of office.  

Wait a minute, if his opponent shows the ChelseaMunch photo to the media in an effort to muddy his reputation (whatever that is) ..they could wind up losing the vote, too. After all,  they  exposed the image to an unsuspecting public.    
Thank you for your patience as I indulge my need to share.

*

ElmerFudd

  • Z Cup
  • 2746
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #34 on: October 04, 2003, 07:18:20 PM »
O.K., where's that thread derailed stamp when you need it?

Gee, funny how Munch was involved.

Though I notice I'm an enabler.  

*

RandomX

  • ZZZ Cup
  • 5718
    • www.overflowingforum.com
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #35 on: October 04, 2003, 11:00:36 PM »
I'm not paying attention...falalala  

 
100% real woman, with notarized documents and witnesses to back this claim up.

*

HeavyMetal1980

  • Banned User
  • 4843
Re: The Star Derailling System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #36 on: October 05, 2003, 11:33:54 AM »
Derailed yet another one...and I wasn't a part of it!

Question...are topics derailed because of:

A. They are boring or seem to be going no where.

B. Question was answered and it's time to move on.

or

C. It's just that much damn fun!


Hmmm....

 
"Listen to the Wind and dance with the Flames..."

~ HeavyMetal1980

*

TheHerald

  • Ink & Paint Club Outcast
  • 3862
  • Ink & Paint Club Outcast
Re: The Star Derailling System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #37 on: October 05, 2003, 11:41:16 AM »
Definitely C.
I don't think boring has anything to do with a post getting derailed and many questions have not been  answered  before derailment begins.  
Thank you for your patience as I indulge my need to share.

*

DruulEmpire

  • Freakin' Huge!
  • 12880
Re: The Star Derailling System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #38 on: October 05, 2003, 11:46:18 AM »
Looks like the moral here is: all roads may lead to Rome, but all threads end with Sadistyk, RandomX, and HeavyMetal1980.

*

Nimrod

  • KC Strip Artist
  • 2175
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #39 on: October 05, 2003, 11:54:58 AM »
First, I think the ranking system was so subjective and open to abuse or manipulation that it really lacked any credibility and therefore had little effect on my interpretation or interaction on the BEA. I was glad to see it go.

It is my opinion that what is at the base of this thread is not necessarily the ranking of individual posters (that does have merit) but rather the ranking of a thread as a whole when compared to the quality of the participants of that thread.

Lets keep the race for the record number of posts separate from the conversation for a bit.

Try this on for a suggestion -
Because this is called the BEA forum I will start with the premise that maximizing participation within the forum and more exactly, within a particular thread could be a good meter for the “quality” of that post and posters. A single post with say 3000 views, 150 posts, but only four or five contributors is not much of a post, regardless of the quality of the posters. That just smacks of a posting frenzy or another flame war or such.

My suggestion is to rank a post (not the posters) by a ratio of unique posters to that topic and then weight it to the number of views and combine that with some aspect of the thread rating data that appears at the bottom of the post. A post would have a high rate if it has only many unique contributors, is viewed many times, and has lets say been active for a long time.

That way one person posting 50 times to the same post does not help raise the post rank, but 50 people posting 1 time does. Or a post that stays active over several months (non-sticky type) on its own merits will rank well.

If we must rank individuals then we could rank them buy the number of high ranking posts they have contributed too versus the total number of posts they have made. That way some would be motivated to contribute to more “quality” threads, again reducing the urge to post massive numbers of one liners to a single post. (We could exclude the Off-topic section from the calculations because that sort of thing happens there a lot regardless of the “quality” of the post)

Bottom line - is to encourage participation across the board and in as many threads as possible without blindly rewarding mass posters or simply starting a bogus thread.

Also - lets rank across a range of say 10 and not 4 or 5.
Just some ideas to kick around.

Now who is going to put the bell on this cat's collar?  
BE Together...

Images are (c) Nimrod unless noted otherwise

*

DruulEmpire

  • Freakin' Huge!
  • 12880
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #40 on: October 05, 2003, 12:59:44 PM »
Nimrod, you may have failed with that whole Tower of Babel project, but these are some of the more inspired ideas I've heard -- still very inexact, but getting closer -- for making quality quantifiable.  NOW, of course, the question becomes: who would care enough, to actually try this?

(This reminds me of an Addventure discussion, in which writers would be rated not simply by episode number but word count per episode, since it's easy to spam the Addventure with quick ultrashort episodes.  A relatively simple idea -- but even that may prove to be an awfully involved measure toput into action.)

*

DrHyde

  • Mad Scientist
  • 3469
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #41 on: October 05, 2003, 01:13:38 PM »
Quote:

If we must rank individuals then we could rank them buy the number of high ranking posts they have contributed too versus the total number of posts they have made. That way some would be motivated to contribute to more “quality” threads, again reducing the urge to post massive numbers of one liners to a single post.




But what if that one line says something meaningful? Wait a minute, did I make a double negative here?

*

Seelie

  • G Cup
  • 739
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #42 on: October 05, 2003, 01:48:16 PM »
What I want to know, is why does anyone thing that we *need* a system that is significant or meaningful in any way shape or form? What's wrong with having something meaningless and silly and related to bigger boobs?

If I could, I'd plagairize that Calvin and Hobbes strip about Chew magazine where Hobbes complains that the articles on gum seem like they take all the fun out of it and how he just prefers to have fun. Calvin counters with the fact that he can't enjoy his fun unless it's been quantified and certified. Just enjoy the boobies.

 
-----
Hmm, I guess I'm not as omniscient as I thought.

*

HeavyMetal1980

  • Banned User
  • 4843
Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #43 on: October 05, 2003, 01:55:48 PM »
I think the question is. do people like posting here or not? Are they having fun? Is the experience as a whole enjoyable?

If the answer to the above threads is yes, then where's the problem? Why the focus on ranking?

Unless the thread (or author) is causing a problem (inappropriate content such as [censored] pornography, or excess spam, or the ever so wonderful and out of control Flame war) I recommend simply ignoring a thread that bothers you that much.

 
"Listen to the Wind and dance with the Flames..."

~ HeavyMetal1980

Re: The Star Ranking System ... Your Thoughts
« Reply #44 on: October 05, 2003, 11:32:33 PM »
Well, it is 12:30AM EST, making this post a little more than a day old.  Currently, 11 members (35%) vote for some kind of rating system, while 20 members (64%) vote against some kind of rating system.  It seems so far that there is strong opposition towards rating other users, but is not unanimous.

Please keep voting and posting your thoughts on this!